Fundamental limits to radiative heat transfer: theory

Abstract

Near-field radiative heat transfer between bodies at the nanoscale can surpass blackbody limits on thermal radiation by orders of magnitude due to contributions from evanescent electromagnetic fields, which carry no energy to the far-field. Thus far, principles guiding explorations of larger heat transfer beyond planar structures have assumed utility in surface nanostructuring, which can enhance the density of states, and further assumed that such design paradigms can approach Landauer limits, in analogy to conduction. We derive fundamental shape-independent limits to radiative heat transfer, applicable in near- through far-field regimes, that incorporate material and geometric constraints such as intrinsic dissipation and finite object sizes, and show that these preclude reaching the Landauer limits in all but a few restrictive scenarios. Additionally, we show that the interplay of material response and electromagnetic scattering among proximate bodies means that bodies which maximize radiative heat transfer actually maximize scattering rather than absorption. Finally, we compare our new bounds to existing Landauer limits, as well as limits involving bodies maximizing far-field absorption, and show that these lead to overly optimistic predictions. Our results have ramifications for the ultimate performance of thermophotovoltaics and nanoscale cooling, as well as related incandescent and luminescent devices.

arXiv comment12 pages including appendices, 1 figure; SM and PSV contributed equally

References in corpus (23)

• Radiative heat transfer between nanostructures
• Trace formulae for non-equilibrium Casimir interactions, heat radiation and heat transfer for arbitrary objects
• A mesoscopic description of radiative heat transfer at the nanoscale
• Frequency-selective near-field enhancement of radiative heat transfer via photonic-crystal slabs: a general computational approach for arbitrary geometries and materials
• Fundamental limits to optical response in absorptive systems
• Enhancing Near-Field Radiative Heat Transfer with Si-based Metasurfaces
• Fluctuational-electrodynamic theory and dynamics of heat transfer in multiple dipolar systems
• A scattering approach to Casimir forces and radiative heat transfer for nanostructured surfaces out of thermal equilibrium
• Fluctuating surface-current formulation of radiative heat transfer: theory and applications
• Fundamental limits for non-contact transfers between two bodies
• Shape-Independent Limits to Near-Field Radiative Heat Transfer
• Fluctuating volume-current formulation of electromagnetic fluctuations in inhomogeneous media: incandecence and luminescence in arbitrary geometries
• Heat transfer between nanoparticles: Thermal conductance for near-field interactions
• Near-field radiative heat transfer between arbitrarily-shaped objects and a surface
• Radiative heat transfer between metallic gratings using adaptive spatial resolution
• Length dependence of the thermal conductance of alkane-based single-molecule junctions: An ab-initio study
• Fundamental limits to radiative heat transfer: the limited role of nanostructuring in the near field
• $\mathbb{T}$-operator bounds on angle-integrated absorption and thermal radiation for arbitrary objects
• Fluctuation-Induced Phenomena in Nanoscale Systems: Harnessing the Power of Noise
• Material Scaling and Frequency-Selective Enhancement of Near-Field Radiative Heat Transfer for Lossy Metals in Two Dimensions via Inverse Design
• Near-field thermal electromagnetic transport: An overview
• Overcoming limits to near-field radiative heat transfer in uniform planar media through multilayer optimization
• Phonon-polariton mediated thermal radiation and heat transfer among molecules and macroscopic bodies: nonlocal electromagnetic response at mesoscopic scales

Cited by in corpus (22)

• Transforming heat transfer with thermal metamaterials and devices
• Near-field Radiative Heat Transfer in Many-Body Systems
• Upper bounds on absorption and scattering
• Fundamental limits to radiative heat transfer: the limited role of nanostructuring in the near field
• Computational bounds to light-matter interactions via local conservation laws
• Global $\mathbb{T}$ operator bounds on electromagnetic scattering: Upper bounds on far-field cross sections
• Heuristic Methods and Performance Bounds for Photonic Design
• Hierarchical Mean-Field $\mathbb{T}$ Operator Bounds on Electromagnetic Scattering: Upper Bounds on Near-Field Radiative Purcell Enhancement
• Trace formulation for photonic inverse design with incoherent sources
• Trade-offs in absorption and scattering by nanophotonic structures
• Fundamental bounds for scattering from absorptionless electromagnetic structures
• Conservation-law-based global bounds to quantum optimal control
• Topological phonon polariton enhanced radiative heat transfer in bichromatic nanoparticle arrays mimicking Aubry-André-Harper model
• Magnetic field control of the near-field radiative heat transfer in three-body planar systems
• Approaching the upper limits of the local density of states via optimized metallic cavities
• Tight bounds and the role of optical loss in polariton-mediated near-field heat transfer
• Mechanical relations between conductive and radiative heat transfer
• Performance Bounds of Magnetic Traps for Neutral Particles
• Channel-based algebraic limits to conductive heat transfer
• Physical limits on electromagnetic response
• Fundamental Bounds to Time-Harmonic Quadratic Metrics in Electromagnetism: Overview and Implementation
• $\mathbb{T}$-Operator Limits on Optical Communication: Metaoptics, Computation, and Input-Output Transformations