Distribution of red clump stars does not support the X-shaped Galactic bulge

Abstract

CONTEXT. Claims of an X-shaped Galactic bulge were based on the assumption of red clump stars as standard candles in some lines of sight crossing the off-plane bulge. However, some doubts have been cast on whether the two peaks in star counts along the line of sight really represent a double peak in the density distribution, or whether there is something wrong with the assumption of a unique constant absolute magnitude for all of these stars. AIMS. With the advent of Gaia-DR2 parallaxes in combination with near-infrared VISTA-VVV data, we are able to check which of the hypotheses is correct. METHODS. We calculated the median absolute magnitude $M_K$ corresponding to both peaks of putative red clumps in seven lines of sight with the lowest extinction in the interesting coordinates' range. RESULTS. The difference between the absolute magnitude of the bright and the faint peak is $\Delta M_K\approx 0.4$. The selected stars in both peaks cannot be represented by the same red clump giants with constant $M_K\approx -1.6$. CONCLUSIONS. The hypothesis that the bulge contains an X-shape is based on the assumption that the faint and bright peaks of the density distribution towards the bulge are dominated by standard red clump stars. However, we show that both the faint and bright peaks cannot be dominated by standard red clump stars simultaneously.

arXiv comment5 pages, accepted to be published in A&A

References in corpus (38)

• Maps of Dust IR Emission for Use in Estimation of Reddening and CMBR Foregrounds
• Gaia Data Release 2. Summary of the contents and survey properties
• Measuring Reddening with SDSS Stellar Spectra and Recalibrating SFD
• Gaia Data Release 2: The astrometric solution
• Estimating distances from parallaxes IV: Distances to 1.33 billion stars in Gaia Data Release 2
• VISTA Variables in the Via Lactea (VVV): The public ESO near-IR variability survey of the Milky Way
• Gaia Data Release 2: using Gaia parallaxes
• Gaia Data Release 2: Catalogue validation
• VVV DR1: The First Data Release of the Milky Way Bulge and Southern Plane from the Near-Infrared ESO Public Survey VISTA Variables in the Via Lactea
• Mapping the Three-Dimensional Density of the Galactic Bulge with VVV Red Clump Stars
• Evidence for a systematic offset of -80 micro-arcseconds in the Gaia DR2 parallaxes
• Two Red Clumps and the X-Shaped Milky Way Bulge
• Old stellar Galactic disc in near-plane regions according to 2MASS: scales, cut-off, flare and warp
• The Split Red Clump of the Galactic Bulge from OGLE-III
• Population effects on the red giant clump absolute magnitude: The K-band
• The origin of the split red clump in the Galactic bulge of the Milky Way
• Deciphering the 3D structure of the old Galactic bulge from the OGLE RR Lyrae stars
• Modelling the Galactic bar using OGLE-II Red Clump Giant Stars
• A secondary clump of red giant stars: why and where
• Mapping the X-Shaped Milky Way Bulge
• The X-shaped Bulge of the Milky Way revealed by WISE
• A boxy bulge in the Milky Way. Inversion of the stellar statistics equation with 2MASS data
• Red clump stars and Gaia: Calibration of the standard candle using a hierarchical probabilistic model
• A parametric description of the 3D structure of the Galactic Bar/Bulge using the VVV survey
• The Milky Way without X: An alternative interpretation of the double red clump in the Galactic bulge
• Testing asteroseismology with Gaia DR2: Hierarchical models of the Red Clump
• 3D kinematics through the X-shaped Milky Way bulge
• Orbital dynamics of three-dimensional bars: IV. Boxy isophotes in face-on views
• The X-Shaped Milky Way Bulge in OGLE-III Photometry and in N-Body Models
• Star formation history and metallicity in the Galactic inner bulge revealed by the red giant branch bump
• The structure behind the Galactic bar traced by red clump stars in the VVV survey
• Gaia-DR2 extended kinematical maps. Part I: Method and application
• New insight on the origin of the double red clump in the Milky Way bulge
• Absence of an X-shaped Structure in the Milky Way Bulge Using Mira Variable Stars
• Mapping the Three-Dimensional "X-Shaped Structure" in Models of the Galactic Bulge
• Common Origin of Two RR Lyrae Populations and the Double Red Clump in the Milky Way Bulge
• A case against an X-shaped structure in the Milky Way young bulge
• Discovery of a Very Large (~20 kpc) Galaxy at z=3.72

Cited by in corpus (8)

• Age Demographics of the Milky Way Disk and Bulge
• The OGLE Collection of Variable Stars. Nearly 66,000 Mira stars in the Milky Way
• Blanco DECam Bulge Survey (BDBS) II: Project Performance, Data Analysis, and Early Science Results
• Multiwavelength Absolute Magnitudes and Colours of Red Clump Stars in {\it Gaia} Era
• A three-dimensional map of the Milky Way using 66,000 Mira variable stars
• The structure of the Milky Way based on unWISE 3.4$\mu$m integrated photometry
• Difference in chemical composition between the bright and faint red clump stars in the Milky Way bulge
• Analysing the structure of the bulge with Mira variables