A case against an X-shaped structure in the Milky Way young bulge

Abstract

CONTEXT. A number of recent papers have claimed the discovery of an X-shape structure in the bulge of our Galaxy in the population of the red clumps. AIMS. We endeavor to analyze the stellar density of bulge stars in the same regions using a different stellar population that is characteristic of the young bulge ($\lesssim 5$ Gyr). Particularly, we use F0-F5 main-sequence stars with distances derived through photometric parallax. METHODS. We extract these stars from extinction-corrected color-magnitude diagrams in the near-infrared of VISTA-VVV data in some bulge regions and calculate the densities along the line of sight. We take the uncertaintity in the photometric parallax and the contamination of other sources into account, and we see that these errors do not avoid the detection of a possible double peak along some lines of sight as expected for a X-shape bulge if it existed. RESULTS. Only a single peak in the density distribution along the line of sight is observed, so apparently there is no X-shape structure for this population of stars. Nonetheless, the effects of the dispersion of absolute magnitudes in the selected population might be an alternative explanation, although in principle these effects are insufficient to explain this lack of double peak according to our calculations. CONCLUSIONS. The results of the present paper do not demonstrate that previous claims of X-shaped bulge using only red clump stars are incorrect, but there are apparently some puzzling questions if we want to maintain the validity of both the red-clump results and the results of this paper.

arXiv comment10 pages, 9 figures, accepted to be published in A&A

References in corpus (38)

• Maps of Dust IR Emission for Use in Estimation of Reddening and CMBR Foregrounds
• Measuring Reddening with SDSS Stellar Spectra and Recalibrating SFD
• The Milky Way Tomography with SDSS: I. Stellar Number Density Distribution
• VISTA Variables in the Via Lactea (VVV): The public ESO near-IR variability survey of the Milky Way
• The UKIRT Infrared Deep Sky Survey ZYJHK Photometric System: Passbands and Synthetic Colours
• Chemical evolution of the Galactic bulge as traced by microlensed dwarf and subgiant stars. V. Evidence for a wide age distribution and a complex MDF
• Age and Metallicity Distribution of the Galactic Bulge from Extensive Optical and Near-IR Stellar Photometry
• Stellar SEDs from 0.3-2.5 Microns: Tracing the Stellar Locus and Searching for Color Outliers in SDSS and 2MASS
• VVV DR1: The First Data Release of the Milky Way Bulge and Southern Plane from the Near-Infrared ESO Public Survey VISTA Variables in the Via Lactea
• Mapping the Three-Dimensional Density of the Galactic Bulge with VVV Red Clump Stars
• Two Red Clumps and the X-Shaped Milky Way Bulge
• The Split Red Clump of the Galactic Bulge from OGLE-III
• The Bulge Radial Velocity Assay (BRAVA): II. Complete Sample and Data Release
• The metallicity distribution of bulge clump giants in Baade's Window
• Starcounts Redivivus. IV. Density Laws Through Photometric Parallaxes
• The APOGEE red-clump catalog: Precise distances, velocities, and high-resolution elemental abundances over a large area of the Milky Way's disk
• Chemical evolution of the Galactic bulge as traced by microlensed dwarf and subgiant stars. IV. Two bulge populations
• On the galactic disc age-metallicity relation
• The origin of the split red clump in the Galactic bulge of the Milky Way
• Insights on the Milky Way bulge formation from the correlations between kinematics and metallicity
• A secondary clump of red giant stars: why and where
• Mapping the X-Shaped Milky Way Bulge
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: metallicity and kinematic trends in the Milky Way bulge
• VVV Survey Near-Infrared Photometry of Known Bulge RR Lyrae stars: the Distance to the Galactic Center and Absence of a Barred Distribution of the Metal-Poor Population
• The First Detection of Blue Straggler Stars in the Milky Way Bulge
• K Giants in Baade's Window. II. The Abundance Distribution
• The Long Bar in the Milky Way. Corroboration of an old hypothesis
• The X-shaped Bulge of the Milky Way revealed by WISE
• A boxy bulge in the Milky Way. Inversion of the stellar statistics equation with 2MASS data
• The Age and Structure of the Galactic Bulge from Mira Variables
• Implications of New JHK Photometry and a Deep Infrared Luminosity Function for the Galactic Bulge
• Metallicity gradients through disk Instability: A simple model for the Milky Way's boxy bulge
• The Milky Way without X: An alternative interpretation of the double red clump in the Galactic bulge
• Mapping the outer bulge with RRab stars from the VVV Survey
• The X-Shaped Milky Way Bulge in OGLE-III Photometry and in N-Body Models
• The Controversial Star-Formation History and Helium Enrichment of the Milky Way Bulge
• Reinforcing the link between the double red clump and the X-shaped bulge of the Milky Way
• Calibrating Milky Way dust extinction using cosmological sources

Cited by in corpus (10)

• A parametric description of the 3D structure of the Galactic Bar/Bulge using the VVV survey
• Quantifying the (X/peanut)-shaped Structure of the Milky Way - New Constraints on the Bar Geometry
• New insight on the origin of the double red clump in the Milky Way bulge
• The structural evolution of galaxies with both thin and thick discs
• Absence of an X-shaped Structure in the Milky Way Bulge Using Mira Variable Stars
• Maximum Entropy Estimation of the Galactic Bulge Morphology via the VVV Red Clump
• HERBS I: Metallicity and alpha enhancement along the Galactic bulge minor axis
• The structure of the Milky Way based on unWISE 3.4$\mu$m integrated photometry
• Distribution of red clump stars does not support the X-shaped Galactic bulge
• Analysing the structure of the bulge with Mira variables