Comparing Long-Duration Gamma-Ray Flares and High-Energy Solar Energetic Particles

Abstract

Little is known about the origin of the high-energy and sustained emission from solar Long-Duration Gamma-Ray Flares (LDGRFs), identified with the Compton Gamma Ray Observatory (CGRO), the Solar Maximum Mission (SMM), and now Fermi. Though Fermi/Large Area Space Telescope (LAT) has identified dozens of flares with LDGRF signature, the nature of this phenomenon has been a challenge to explain both due to the extreme energies and long durations. The highest-energy emission has generally been attributed to pion production from the interaction of >300 MeV protons with the ambient matter. The extended duration suggests that particle acceleration occurs over large volumes extending high in the corona, either from stochastic acceleration within large coronal loops or from back precipitation from coronal mass ejection driven shocks. It is possible to test these models by making direct comparison between the properties of the accelerated ion population producing the gamma-ray emission derived from the Fermi/LAT observations, and the characteristics of solar energetic particles (SEPs) measured by the Payload for Matter-Antimatter Exploration and Light Nuclei Astrophysics (PAMELA) spacecraft in the energy range corresponding to the pion-related emission detected with Fermi. For fourteen of these events we compare the two populations -- SEPs in space and the interacting particles at the Sun -- and discuss the implications in terms of potential sources. Our analysis shows that the two proton numbers are poorly correlated, with their ratio spanning more than five orders of magnitude, suggesting that the back precipitation of shock-acceleration particles is unlikely the source of the LDGRF emission.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (30)

• The Large Area Telescope on the Fermi Gamma-ray Space Telescope Mission
• Microwave and Hard X-Ray Observations of the 2017 September 10 Solar Limb Flare
• Global Energetics of Solar Flares: V. Energy Closure in Flares and Coronal Mass Ejections
• Impulsive and Long Duration High-Energy Gamma-ray Emission From the Very Bright 2012 March 7 Solar Flares
• High-Energy Gamma-Ray Emission From Solar Flares: Summary of Fermi LAT Detections and Analysis of Two M-Class Flares
• Height of Shock Formation in the Solar Corona Inferred from Observations of Type II Radio Bursts and Coronal Mass Ejections
• Observations of the December 13 and 14, 2006, Solar Particle Events in the 80 MeV/n - 3 GeV/n range from space with PAMELA detector
• Solar energetic particle events observed by the PAMELA mission
• Characteristics of Sustained >100 MeV Gamma-ray Emission Associated with Solar Flares
• Large Solar Energetic Particle Events Associated with Filament Eruptions Outside of Active Regions
• Fermi-LAT Observations of High-energy Behind-the-limb Solar Flares
• Fermi Detection of γ-ray emission from the M2 Soft X-ray Flare on 2010 June 12
• Ground Level Enhancement in the 2014 January 6 Solar Energetic Particle Event
• Drift-induced perpendicular transport of Solar Energetic Particles
• Solar cycle 24: an unusual polar field reversal
• Spectral Analysis of the September 2017 Solar Energetic Particle Events
• The Fermi All-sky Variability Analysis: A list of flaring gamma-ray sources and the search for transients in our Galaxy
• The magnetic connectivity of coronal shocks from behind-the-limb flares to the visible solar surface during $\gamma$-ray events
• Soft X-ray Fluxes of Major Flares Far Behind the Limb as Estimated Using STEREO EUV Images
• Probing the Puzzle of Behind-the-Limb $\gamma$-ray Flares: Data-driven Simulations of Magnetic Connectivity and CME-driven Shock Evolution
• Self-consistent Monte Carlo simulations of proton acceleration in coronal shocks: Effect of anisotropic pitch-angle scattering of particles
• Calibration of the GOES-13/15 high energy proton detectors based on the PAMELA solar energetic particle observations
• Modelling Solar Energetic Particle transport near a wavy Heliospheric Current Sheet
• Radio, Hard X-Ray, and Gamma-Ray Emissions Associated with a Far-Side Solar Event
• High-energy solar particle events in cycle 24
• 25 MeV Solar Proton Events in Cycle 24 and Previous Cycles
• A Hierarchical Relationship between the Fluence Spectra and CME Kinematics in Large Solar Energetic Particle Events: A Radio Perspective
• A Statistical Study to Determine the Origin of Long-Duration Gamma-ray Flares
• Geomagnetically trapped, albedo and solar energetic particles: trajectory analysis and flux reconstruction with PAMELA
• The Relationship between Long-Duration Gamma-Ray Flares and Solar Cosmic Rays

Cited by in corpus (15)

• Extreme solar events
• The First Fermi-LAT Solar Flare Catalog
• A Primer on Focused Solar Energetic Particle Transport: Basic physics and recent modelling results
• Evidence for a Coronal Shock Wave Origin for Relativistic Protons Producing Solar Gamma-Rays and Observed by Neutron Monitors at Earth
• 3D propagation of relativistic solar protons through interplanetary space
• Empirical Model of 10-130 MeV Solar Energetic Particle Spectra at 1 AU Based on Coronal Mass Ejection Speed and Direction
• Source of Energetic Protons in the 2014 September 1 Sustained Gamma-ray Emission Event
• The coupling of an EUV coronal wave and ion acceleration in a Fermi-LAT behind-the-limb solar flare
• The Common Origin of High-energy Protons in Solar Energetic Particle Events and Sustained Gamma-ray Emission from the Sun
• Energetic Proton Back-Precipitation onto the Solar Atmosphere in Relation to Long-Duration Gamma-Ray Flares
• FLUKA Simulations of Pion Decay Gamma-radiation from Energetic Flare Ions
• Evidence for flare-accelerated particles in large scale loops in the behind-the-limb gamma-ray solar flare of September 29, 2022
• Modelling Solar Energetic Neutral Atoms from Solar Flares and CME-driven Shocks
• The 2024 July 16 Solar Event: A Challenge To The Coronal Mass Ejection Origin Of Long-Duration Gamma-Ray Flares
• Role of CME clusters and CME-CME interactions in producing sustained $\gamma$-ray emission