Yule-Simpson's paradox in Galactic Archaeology

Abstract

Simpson's paradox, or Yule-Simpson effect, arises when a trend appears in different subsets of data but disappears or reverses when these subsets are combined. We describe here seven cases of this phenomenon for chemo-kinematical relations believed to constrain the Milky Way disk formation and evolution. We show that interpreting trends in relations, such as the radial and vertical chemical abundance gradients, the age-metallicity relation, and the metallicity-rotational velocity relation (MVR), can lead to conflicting conclusions about the Galaxy past if analyses marginalize over stellar age and/or birth radius. It is demonstrated that the MVR in RAVE giants is consistent with being always strongly negative, when narrow bins of [Mg/Fe] are considered. This is directly related to the negative radial metallicity gradients of stars grouped by common age (mono-age populations) due to the inside out disk formation. The effect of the asymmetric drift can then give rise to a positive MVR trend in high-[alpha/Fe] stars, with a slope dependent on a given survey's selection function and observational uncertainties. We also study the variation of lithium abundance, A(Li), with [Fe/H] of AMBRE:HARPS dwarfs. A strong reversal in the positive A(Li)-[Fe/H] trend of the total sample is found for mono-age populations, flattening for younger groups of stars. Dissecting by birth radius shows strengthening in the positive A(Li)-[Fe/H] trend, shifting to higher [Fe/H] with decreasing birth radius; these observational results suggest new constraints on chemical evolution models. This work highlights the necessity for precise age estimates for large stellar samples covering wide spatial regions.

arXiv comment13 p., 7 Fig., Accepted to MNRAS

References in corpus (74)

• Gaia Data Release 1. Summary of the astrometric, photometric, and survey properties
• The Aquarius Project: the subhalos of galactic halos
• The Galaxy in Context: Structural, Kinematic and Integrated Properties
• The PLATO 2.0 Mission
• The New Galaxy: Signatures of its Formation
• Radial Mixing in Galactic Discs
• The GALAH Survey: Scientific Motivation
• Chemical evolution with radial mixing
• Chemical abundances of 1111 FGK stars from the HARPS GTO planet search program.Galactic stellar populations and planets
• The age structure of stellar populations in the solar vicinity. Clues of a two-phase formation history of the Milky Way disk
• The Radial Velocity Experiment (RAVE): Fifth Data Release
• Riding the Spiral Waves: Implications of Stellar Migration for the Properties of Galactic Disks
• Chemodynamical evolution of the Milky Way disk I: The solar vicinity
• The RAdial Velocity Experiment (RAVE): Fourth data release
• The thick disks of spiral galaxies as relics from gas-rich, turbulent, clumpy disks at high redshift
• Origin and structure of the Galactic disc(s)
• Cold Dark Matter Substructure and Galactic Disks I: Morphological Signatures of Hierarchical Satellite Accretion
• The Formation and Survival of Discs in a Lambda-CDM Universe
• Towards a more realistic population of bright spiral galaxies in cosmological simulations
• Chemodynamical evolution of the Milky Way disk II: Variations with Galactic radius and height above the disk plane
• Radial mixing and the transition between the thick and thin Galactic discs
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: the Galactic Thick to Thin Disc transition
• StarHorse: A Bayesian tool for determining stellar masses, ages, distances, and extinctions for field stars
• The Influence of Sagittarius and the Large Magellanic Cloud on the Milky Way Galaxy
• Lithium abundances in nearby FGK dwarf and subgiant stars: internal destruction, Galactic chemical evolution, and exoplanets
• Chemodynamics of the Milky Way. I. The first year of APOGEE data
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: radial metallicity gradients and age-metallicity relation of stars in the Milky Way disk
• Estimating stellar birth radii and the time evolution of the Milky Way's ISM metallicity gradient
• Radial Migration Does Little for Galactic Disc Thickening
• The age-metallicity structure of the Milky Way disk
• The Long-term Evolution of the Galactic Disk Traced by Dissolving Star Clusters
• Vertical disc heating in Milky Way-sized galaxies in a cosmological context
• The Structure and Dynamical Evolution of the Stellar Disk of a Simulated Milky Way-Mass Galaxy
• The global structure of galactic discs
• Measuring the vertical age structure of the Galactic disc using asteroseismology and SAGA
• Metallicity Gradients in the Milky Way Disk as Observed by the SEGUE Survey
• Li abundances in F stars: planets, rotation and galactic evolution
• Misaligned Angular Momentum in Hydrodynamic Cosmological Simulations: Warps, Outer Discs, and Thick Discs
• Thick disks of edge-on galaxies seen through the Spitzer Survey of Stellar Structure in Galaxies (S4G): Lair of missing baryons?
• Lithium Abundances of the Local Thin Disk Stars
• Evolving Gravitationally Unstable Disks Over Cosmic Time: Implications For Thick Disk Formation
• A spectroscopic survey of thick disc stars outside the solar neighbourhood
• SDSS-V: Pioneering Panoptic Spectroscopy
• PLATO as it is: a legacy mission for Galactic archaeology
• A radial age gradient in the geometrically thick disk of the Milky Way
• Understanding inverse metallicity gradients in galactic discs as a consequence of inside-out formation
• A new stellar chemo-kinematic relation reveals the merger history of the Milky Way disc
• The Effects of Radial Migration on the Vertical Structure of Galactic Discs
• The Metallicity Distribution Functions of SEGUE G and K dwarfs: Constraints for Disk Chemical Evolution and Formation
• Chemical gradients in the Milky Way from the RAVE data. I. Dwarf stars
• Idealized models for galactic disk formation and evolution in 'realistic' LambdaCDM haloes
• Mapping the Milky Way with LAMOST III: Complicated spatial structure in the outer disc
• Cepheid Variables in the Flared Outer Disk of our Galaxy
• Dissecting simulated disc galaxies I: the structure of mono-age populations
• The relationship between mono-abundance and mono-age stellar populations in the Milky Way disk
• The AMBRE Project: Constraining the lithium evolution in the Milky Way
• The relation between chemical abundances and kinematics of the Galactic disc with RAVE
• Impacts of a Flaring Star-forming Disc and Stellar Radial Mixing on the Vertical Metallicity Gradient
• ${}^7$Li evolution in the thin and thick disks of the Milky Way
• Through Thick and Thin: Kinematic and Chemical Components in the Solar Neighbourhood
• Dynamics for Galactic Archaeology
• Constraints on Radial Migration in Spiral Galaxies - II. Angular momentum distribution and preferential migration
• Origin of the Metallicity Distribution in the Thick Disc
• The Vertical Metallicity Gradient of the Milky Way Disk: Transitions in [a/Fe] Populations
• Explaining the decrease in ISM lithium at super-solar metallicities in the solar vicinity
• Stellar ages and masses in the solar neighbourhood: Bayesian analysis using spectroscopy and Gaia DR1 parallaxes
• Metallicity distributions of mono-age stellar populations of the Galactic disc from the LAMOST Galactic spectroscopic surveys
• Constraining the Milky Way assembly history with Galactic Archaeology. Ludwig Biermann Award Lecture 2015
• A-type stars in the Canada-France Imaging Survey II. Tracing the height of the disc at large distances with Blue Stragglers
• Numerical Simulation of a possible origin of the positive radial metallicity gradient of the thick disk
• Red Clump stars from LAMOST II: the outer disc of the Milky Way
• Dynamical evidence of the age--metallicity relation in the Milky Way disk
• The vertical metallicity gradients of mono-age stellar populations in the Milky Way with the RAVE and Gaia data
• The Lives of Stars: Insights From the TGAS-RAVE-LAMOST Dataset

Cited by in corpus (26)

• The Biggest Splash
• The Open Cluster Chemical Abundances and Mapping Survey: IV. Abundances for 128 Open Clusters using SDSS/APOGEE DR16
• Sausage & Mash: The dual origin of the Galactic thick disc and halo from the gas-rich Gaia-Enceladus-Sausage merger
• The Inside-out Growth of the Galactic Disk
• Keeping it Cool: Much Orbit Migration, yet Little Heating, in the Galactic Disk
• NIHAO-UHD: The properties of MW-like stellar disks in high resolution cosmological simulations
• Fundamental relations for the velocity dispersion of stars in the Milky Way
• Evolution of lithium in the Milky Way halo, discs and bulge
• Unveiling the time evolution of chemical abundances across the Milky Way disk with APOGEE
• The K2 Galactic Archaeology Program Data Release 3: Age-abundance patterns in C1-C8 and C10-C18
• The RAdial Velocity Experiment (RAVE): Parameterisation of RAVE spectra based on convolutional neural networks
• Milky Way Analogues in MaNGA: Multi-Parameter Homogeneity and Comparison to the Milky Way
• The chemodynamics of prograde and retrograde Milky Way stars
• The GALAH Survey: Temporal Chemical Enrichment of the Galactic Disk
• The relationship between age, metallicity, and abundances for disk stars in a simulated Milky Way galaxy
• Chemical Properties of the Local Galactic Disk and Halo. I. Fundamental Properties of 1,544 Nearby, High Proper-Motion M dwarfs and subdwarfs
• On the Flaring of Thick Disc of Galaxies: Insights from Simulations
• Tracing birth properties of stars with abundance clustering
• Disk flaring with TNG50: diversity across Milky Way and M31 analogs
• The Milky Way Revealed by Variable Stars I: Sample Selection of RR Lyrae stars, and Evidence for the Merger History
• Elemental abundances distributions in (R, $V_{\varphi }$) plane with LAMOST DR5 and Gaia DR2
• Using heritability of stellar chemistry to reveal the history of the Milky Way
• The vertical structure of the spiral galaxy NGC 3501: first stages of the formation of a thin metal-rich disc
• Ensemble age inversions for large spectroscopic surveys
• Quantifying chemical and kinematical properties of Galactic disks
• DoGR: Disaggregated Gaussian Regression for Reproducible Analysis of Heterogeneous Data