Should the research performance of scientists be distinguished by gender?

Abstract

The literature on gender differences in research performance seems to suggest a gap between men and women, where the former outperform the latter. Whether one agrees with the different factors proposed to explain the phenomenon, it is worthwhile to verify if comparing the performance within each gender, rather than without distinction, gives significantly different ranking lists. If there were some structural factor that determined a penalty in performance of female researchers compared to their male peers, then under conditions of equal capacities of men and women, any comparative evaluations of individual performance that fail to account for gender differences would lead to distortion of the judgments in favor of men. In this work we measure the extent of differences in rank between the two methods of comparing performance in each field of the hard sciences: for professors in the Italian university system, we compare the distributions of research performance for men and women and subsequently the ranking lists with and without distinction by gender. The results are of interest for the optimization of efficient selection in formulation of recruitment, career advancement and incentive schemes.

References in corpus (13)

• How do you define and measure research productivity?
• Research collaboration and productivity: is there correlation?
• The Possible Role of Resource Requirements and Academic Career-Choice Risk on Gender Differences in Publication Rate and Impact
• Gender differences in research productivity: a bibliometric analysis of the Italian academic system
• Gender differences in research collaboration
• A heuristic approach to author name disambiguation in bibliometrics databases for large-scale research assessments
• Research productivity: are higher academic ranks more productive than lower ones?
• The importance of accounting for the number of co-authors and their order when assessing research performance at the individual level in the life sciences
• The contribution of star scientists to overall sex differences in research productivity
• Revisiting the scaling of citations for research assessment
• What is the appropriate length of the publication period over which to assess research performance?
• Individual research performance: a proposal for comparing apples to oranges
• Revisiting size effects in higher education research productivity

Cited by in corpus (4)

• Gender differences in research performance within and between countries: Italy vs Norway
• The north-south divide in the Italian higher education system
• Accounting for gender research performance differences in ranking universities
• Do females create higher impact research? Scopus citations and Mendeley readers for articles from five countries