Dust polarisation studies on MHD simulations of molecular clouds: methods comparison for the relative orientations analysis

Abstract

Context. Polarized dust emission can be used as a probe for magnetic fields at different scales. In particular, the analysis of the relative orientation between the density structures and the magnetic field projected on the plane of the sky can provide information on the role of magnetic fields in shaping the structure of molecular clouds. Aims. The relative orientation has been investigated using different methods. Our goal is to explicitly compare two of them: the Rolling Hough Transform (RHT) and the gradient technique. Methods. We have applied the RHT method and the gradient technique to two regions, identified in surface brightness maps at 353 GHz generated via MHD simulations post-processed using radiative transfer modelling. For both methods we have derived the relative orientation between the magnetic field and the density structures, to which we have applied two different statistics, the histogram of relative orientation (HRO) statistic and the projected Rayleigh statistic (PRS). Results. The samples of pixels selected by each method are substantially different. When the methods are applied to the same pixel selection, the results in terms of relative orientation as a function of column density are consistent between each other. When each method is applied to its own pixel selection, the differences are apparent. In Region 1, the RHT method roughly reproduces the observed trend of the relative orientation becoming more perpendicular for increasing column density, while the gradient method, applied at the same resolution as RHT, gives the opposite trend, with the relative orientation moving towards a more parallel alignment. In Region 2, the situation is reversed. The inconsistent results, which are due to the different pixel selections operated by the methods and to the intrinsic differences between them, provide complementary valuable information. Abridged.

arXiv comment15 pages, 9 figures, submitted to A&A, comments welcomed

References in corpus (32)

• Cosmological Hydrodynamics with Adaptive Mesh Refinement: a new high resolution code called RAMSES
• Characterizing interstellar filaments with Herschel in IC5146
• The persistent cosmic web and its filamentary structure I: Theory and implementation
• Herschel view of the Taurus B211/3 filament and striations: Evidence of filamentary growth?
• Planck intermediate results. XXXV. Probing the role of the magnetic field in the formation of structure in molecular clouds
• Momentum Injection by Supernovae in the Interstellar Medium
• On the Star Formation Efficiency of Turbulent Magnetized Clouds
• The global dust SED: Tracing the nature and evolution of dust with DustEM
• An Imprint of Molecular Cloud Magnetization in the Morphology of the Dust Polarized Emission
• Magnetically Aligned HI Fibers and the Rolling Hough Transform
• Supernova Driving. I. The Origin of Molecular Cloud Turbulence
• Two regimes of Turbulent Fragmentation and the stellar IMF from Primordial to Present Day Star Formation
• On the origin of non self-gravitating filaments in the ISM
• The Pipe Nebula as seen with Herschel: Formation of filamentary structures by large-scale compression ?
• What are we learning from the relative orientation between density structures and the magnetic field in molecular clouds?
• On the relation between the column density structures and the magnetic field orientation in the Vela C molecular complex
• A Herschel study of the properties of starless cores in the Polaris Flare dark cloud region using PACS and SPIRE
• Using Herschel and Planck observations to delineate the role of magnetic fields in molecular cloud structure
• Cooling and Heating Functions of Photoionized Gas
• Supernova Driving. IV. The Star Formation Rate of Molecular Clouds
• Submillimeter and Far-Infrared Polarimetric Observations of Magnetic Fields in Star-Forming Regions
• Change of Magnetic Field$-$Gas Alignment at Gravity-Driven Alfvénic Transition in Molecular Clouds: Implications for Dust Polarization Observations
• An application of an optimal statistic for characterising relative orientations
• Matching dust emission structures and magnetic field in high-latitude cloud L1642: comparing Herschel and Planck maps
• The magnetic field and dust filaments in the Polaris Flare
• Formation of HI Clouds in Shock-compressed Interstellar Medium: Physical Origin of Angular Correlation Between Filamentary Structure and Magnetic Field
• Supernova Driving. II. Compressive Ratio in Molecular-Cloud Turbulence
• TRUST I: A 3D externally illuminated slab benchmark for dust radiative transfer
• SOC program for dust continuum radiative transfer
• Statistical analysis of the interplay between magnetic fields and filaments hosting Planck Galactic Cold Clumps
• Supernova Driving. III. Synthetic Molecular Cloud Observations
• Galactic cold cores IX. Column density structures and radiative transfer modelling

Cited by in corpus (4)

• Polarization power spectra and dust cloud morphology
• Anisotropy in the carbon monoxide (CO) line emission across the Milky Way's disk
• The JCMT BISTRO Survey: The magnetised evolution of star-forming cores in the Ophiuchus Molecular Cloud interpreted using Histograms of Relative Orientation
• Interstellar filament detection and characterization: methods and implications for studies of magnetized interstellar medium