How Much SETI Has Been Done? Finding Needles in the n-Dimensional Cosmic Haystack

Abstract

Many articulations of the Fermi Paradox have as a premise, implicitly or explicitly, that humanity has searched for signs of extraterrestrial radio transmissions and concluded that there are few or no obvious ones to be found. Tarter et al. (2010) and others have argued strongly to the contrary: bright and obvious radio beacons might be quite common in the sky, but we would not know it yet because our search completeness to date is so low, akin to having searched a drinking glass's worth of seawater for evidence of fish in all of Earth's oceans. Here, we develop the metaphor of the multidimensional "Cosmic Haystack" through which SETI hunts for alien "needles" into a quantitative, eight-dimensional model and perform an analytic integral to compute the fraction of this haystack that several large radio SETI programs have collectively examined. Although this model haystack has many qualitative differences from the Tarter et al. (2010) haystack, we conclude that the fraction of it searched to date is also very small: similar to the ratio of the volume of a large hot tub or small swimming pool to that of the Earth's oceans. With this article we provide a Python script to calculate haystack volumes for future searches and for similar haystacks with different boundaries. We hope this formalism will aid in the development of a common parameter space for the computation of upper limits and completeness fractions of search programs for radio and other technosignatures.

20 pages, 4 figures. Submitted to The Astronomical Journal on 17th August 2018, Accepted on 11th September 2018. Published on 14th November 2018 v2 includes a correction to Eq. 11. Thanks to Bart Wlodarczyk-Sroka and Michael Garrett for spotting the typographical error (a missing factor of 4pi), which has no effect on the rest of the paper or the associated code

References in corpus (12)

• 55 Cancri (Copernicus): A Multi-Planet System with a Hot Super-Earth and a Jupiter Analogue
• The Breakthrough Listen Search for Intelligent Life: 1.1-1.9 GHz observations of 692 Nearby Stars
• The Ĝ Infrared Search for Extraterrestrial Civilizations with Large Energy Supplies. III. The Reddest Extended Sources in WISE
• The Ĝ Infrared Search for Extraterrestrial Civilizations with Large Energy Supplies. I. Background and Justification
• The Breakthrough Listen Search for Intelligent Life: A Wideband Data Recorder System for the Robert C. Byrd Green Bank Telescope
• SETI Observations of Exoplanets with the Allen Telescope Array
• The Fermi Paradox is Neither Fermis Nor a Paradox
• A VLA Search for Radio Signals from M31 and M33
• An Opportunistic Search for ExtraTerrestrial Intelligence (SETI) with the Murchison Widefield Array
• A search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) toward the Galactic Anticenter with the Murchison Widefield Array
• Fermi's Paradox Is a Daunting Problem---Under Whatever Label
• Nodes: A Proposed Solution to Fermi's Paradox

Cited by in corpus (48)

• The Breakthrough Listen Search for Intelligent Life: Observations of 1327 Nearby Stars over 1.10-3.45 GHz
• The Breakthrough Listen Search For Intelligent Life Near the Galactic Center I
• The Breakthrough Listen Search for Intelligent Life: A 3.95-8.00 GHz Search for Radio Technosignatures in the Restricted Earth Transit Zone
• The Astrobiological Copernican Weak and Strong Limits for Extraterrestrial Intelligent Life
• First SETI Observations with China's Five-hundred-meter Aperture Spherical radio Telescope (FAST)
• The Nine Axes of Merit for Technosignature Searches
• An Objective Bayesian Analysis of Life's Early Start and Our Late Arrival
• A Search for Technosignatures Around 31 Sun-like Stars with the Green Bank Telescope at 1.15-1.73 GHz
• The Fermi Paradox and the Aurora Effect: Exo-civilization Settlement, Expansion and Steady States
• The Breakthrough Listen Search for Intelligent Life: MeerKAT Target Selection
• Strategies and Advice for the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence
• A SETI Survey of the Vela Region using the Murchison Widefield Array: Orders of Magnitude Expansion in Search Space
• Narrow-Band Signal Localization for SETI on Noisy Synthetic Spectrogram Data
• Minimal conditions for survival of technological civilizations in the face of stellar evolution
• Qualitative classification of extraterrestrial civilizations
• Upper limits on transmitter rate of extragalactic civilizations placed by Breakthrough Listen observations
• A Green Bank Telescope search for narrowband technosignatures between 1.1-1.9 GHz during 12 Kepler planetary transits
• COSMIC's Large-Scale Search for Technosignatures during the VLA sky Survey: Survey Description and First Results
• Possibility of a coordinated signaling scheme in the Galaxy and SETI experiments
• Strategies for Maximizing Detection Rate in Radio SETI
• A Search for Optical Laser Emission from Proxima Centauri
• Search for Galactic Civilizations Using Historical Supernovae
• Signal Synchronization Strategies and Time Domain SETI with Gaia DR3
• A reassessment of the "hard-steps" model for the evolution of intelligent life
• Planck Frequencies as Schelling Points in SETI
• A Search for Monochromatic Light Toward the Galactic Centre
• SETI in 2020
• Unbound Close Stellar Encounters in the Solar Neighborhood
• Inferring the rate of technosignatures from 60 yr of nondetection
• Constraints on the abundance of $0.01c$ stellar engines in the Milky Way
• A Quantitative Assessment of Communicating Extra-Terrestrial Intelligent Civilizations in the Galaxy and the Case of FRB-like Signals
• A VERITAS/Breakthrough Listen Search for Optical Technosignatures
• Search for Transient, Monochromatic Light from the Galactic Plane
• Artificial Broadcasts as Galactic Populations: I. A Point Process Formalism for Extraterrestrial Intelligences and Their Broadcasts
• Demography of galactic technosignatures
• One of Everything: The Breakthrough Listen Exotica Catalog
• SPARKESX: Single-dish PARKES data sets for finding the uneXpected -- A data challenge
• Searching for Technosignatures: Implications of Detection and Non-Detection
• Laser Communication with Proxima and Alpha Centauri using the Solar Gravitational Lens
• SETI@home: Data Acquisition and Front-End Processing
• A proposal for enhancing technosignature search toward the Galactic center
• Astrometric study of Gaia DR2 stars for interstellar communication
• Towards a Comprehensive Bibliography for SETI
• The radio search for technosignatures in the decade 2020-2030
• Undetected past contacts with technological species: implications for technosignature science
• Artificial Broadcasts as Galactic Populations: II. Comparing Individualist and Collective Bounds on Broadcast Populations in Single Galaxies
• Searching for technosignatures in exoplanetary systems with current and future missions
• Artificial Broadcasts as Galactic Populations: III. Constraints on Radio Broadcasts from the Cosmic Population of Inhabited Galaxies