Exploring the biases of a new method based on minimum variance for interplanetary magnetic clouds

Abstract

Magnetic clouds (MCs) are twisted magnetic structures ejected from the Sun and probed by in situ instruments. They are typically modeled as flux ropes (FRs). The determination of the FR global characteristics requires the estimation of the FR axis orientation. Among the developed methods, the minimum variance (MV) is the most flexible, and features only a few assumptions. However, as other methods, MV has biases. We aim to investigate the limits of the method and extend it to a less biased method. We first identified the origin of the biases by testing the MV method on cylindrical and elliptical models with a temporal expansion comparable to the one observed in MCs. Then, we developed an improved MV method to reduce these biases. In contrast with many previous publications we find that the ratio of the MV eigenvalues is not a reliable indicator of the precision of the derived FR axis direction. Next, we emphasize the importance of the FR boundaries selected since they strongly affect the deduced axis orientation. We have improved the MV method by imposing that the same amount of azimuthal flux should be present before and after the time of closest approach to the FR axis. We emphasize the importance of finding simultaneously the FR axis direction and the location of the boundaries corresponding to a balanced magnetic flux, so as to minimize the bias on the deduced FR axis orientation. This method can also define an inner flux-balanced sub-FR. We show that the MV results are much less biased when a compromise in size of this sub-FR is achieved. For weakly asymmetric field temporal profiles, the improved MV provides a very good determination of the FR axis orientation. The main remaining bias is moderate (lower than 6 degrees) and is present mostly on the angle between the flux rope axis and the plane perpendicular to the Sun-Earth direction.

arXiv comment15 pages, 8 figures

References in corpus (14)

• Progressive transformation of a flux rope to an ICME
• Global and local expansion of magnetic clouds in the inner heliosphere
• Determining the Intrinsic CME Flux Rope Type Using Remote-sensing Solar Disk Observations
• Magnetic Field Configuration Models and Reconstruction Methods for Interplanetary Coronal Mass Ejections
• Superposed epoch study of ICME sub-structures near Earth and their effects on galactic cosmic rays
• On the twists of interplanetary magnetic flux ropes observed at 1 AU
• A STEREO Survey of Magnetic Cloud Coronal Mass Ejections Observed at Earth in 2008--2012
• Dynamical evolution of a magnetic cloud from the Sun to 5.4 AU
• Three-dimensional evolution of erupted flux ropes from the Sun (2-20 Rs) to 1 AU
• The Solar Connection of Enhanced Heavy Ion Charge States in the Interplanetary Medium: Implications for the Flux-rope Structure of CMEs
• Global axis shape of magnetic clouds deduced from the distribution of their local axis orientation
• Expansion of magnetic clouds in the outer heliosphere
• Grad-Shafranov reconstruction of magnetic clouds: overview and improvements
• Quantitative model for the generic 3D shape of ICMEs at 1 AU

Cited by in corpus (5)

• CME Magnetic Structure and IMF Preconditioning Affecting SEP Transport
• On the Radial and Longitudinal Variation of a Magnetic Cloud: ACE, Wind, ARTEMIS and Juno Observations
• Exploring the radial evolution of Interplanetary Coronal Mass Ejections using EUHFORIA
• A magnetic cloud prediction model for forecasting space weather relevant properties of Earth-directed coronal mass ejections
• Magnetic twist profile inside magnetic clouds derived with a superposed epoch analysis