Revising and Extending the Linear Response Theory for Statistical Mechanical Systems: Evaluating Observables as Predictors and Predictands

Abstract

Linear response theory has developed into a formidable set of tools for studying the forced behaviour of a large variety of systems - including out of equilibrium ones. In this paper we provide a new angle on the problem, by studying under which conditions it is possible to perform predictions on the response of a given observable of a system to perturbations, using one or more other observables of the same system as predictors, and thus bypassing the need to know all the details of the acting forcing. Thus, we break the rigid separation between forcing and response, which is key in linear response theory, and revisit the concept of causality. As a result, the surrogate Green functions one constructs for predicting the response of the observable of interest may have support that is not necessarily limited to the nonnegative time axis. This implies that not all observables are equally good as predictands when a given forcing is applied, as result of the properties of their corresponding susceptibility. In particular, problems emerge from the presence of complex zeros. We derive general explicit formulas that, in absence of such pathologies, allow one to reconstruct the response of an observable of interest to N independent forcings by using as predictors N other observables. We provide a thorough test of the theory and of the possible pathologies by using numerical simulations of the paradigmatic Lorenz '96 model. Our results are potentially relevant for problems like the reconstruction of data from proxy signals, like in the case of paleoclimate, and, in general, the analysis of signals and feedbacks in complex systems where our knowledge on the system is limited, as in neurosciences. Our technique might also be useful for reconstructing the response to forcings of a spatially extended system in a given location by looking at the response in a separate location.

26 pages, 7 Figures; Revised Version

References in corpus (10)

• Fluctuation-Dissipation: Response Theory in Statistical Physics
• A review of linear response theory for general differentiable dynamical systems
• Climate dynamics and fluid mechanics: Natural variability and related uncertainties
• An update on nonequilibrium linear response
• Equivalence of Non-Equilibrium Ensembles and Representation of Friction in Turbulent Flows: The Lorenz 96 Model
• The quest for the ultimate anisotropic Banach space
• Linear response, susceptibility and resonances in chaotic toy models
• A proof of concept for scale-adaptive parameterizations: the case of the Lorenz '96 model
• On the validity of linear response theory in high-dimensional deterministic dynamical systems
• Resonances in a Chaotic Attractor Crisis of the Lorenz Flow

Cited by in corpus (22)

• The Physics of Climate Variability and Climate Change
• Reduced-Order Models for Coupled Dynamical Systems: Data-driven Methods and the Koopman Operator
• Can we use linear response theory to assess geoengineering strategies?
• Beyond Forcing Scenarios: Predicting Climate Change through Response Operators in a Coupled General Circulation Model
• Theoretical tools for understanding the climate crisis from Hasselmann's program and beyond
• Extreme sensitivity and climate tipping points
• Reconsidering the relationship of the El Niño--Southern Oscillation and the Indian monsoon using ensembles in Earth system models
• On Some Aspects of the Response to Stochastic and Deterministic Forcings
• Ruelle-Pollicott Resonances of Stochastic Systems in Reduced State Space. Part I: Theory
• Response Theory and Phase Transitions for the Thermodynamic Limit of Interacting Identical Systems
• Quadratic response of random and deterministic dynamical systems
• Detecting and Attributing Change in Climate and Complex Systems: Foundations, Green's Functions, and Nonlinear Fingerprints
• Response and flux of information in extended non-equilibrium dynamics
• A data-driven framework for dimensionality reduction and causal inference in climate fields
• Climate Response and Sensitivity: Timescales and Late Tipping Points
• Universal Upper Estimate for Prediction Errors under Moderate Model Uncertainty
• Separating internal and externally-forced contributions to global temperature variability using a Bayesian stochastic energy balance framework
• A Stochastic Model for Induced Seismicity at the Geothermal Systems: A Case of the Geysers
• Space-split algorithm for sensitivity analysis of discrete chaotic systems with unstable manifolds of arbitrary dimension
• Predictors and Predictands of Linear Response in Spatially Extended Systems
• Introduction to the Special Issue on the Statistical Mechanics of Climate
• Kolmogorov Modes and Linear Response of Jump-Diffusion Models