Quantifying the validity and breakdown of the overdamped approximation in stochastic thermodynamics: Theory and experiment

Abstract

Stochastic thermodynamics provides an important framework to explore small physical systems where thermal fluctuations are inevitable. In the studies of stochastic thermodynamics, some thermodynamic quantities, such as the trajectory work, associated with the complete Langevin equation (the Kramers equation) are often assumed to converge to those associated with the overdamped Langevin equation (the Smoluchowski equation) in the overdamped limit under the overdamped approximation. Nevertheless, a rigorous mathematical proof of the convergence of the work distributions to our knowledge has not been reported so far. Here we study the convergence of the work distributions explicitly. In the overdamped limit, we rigorously prove the convergence of the extended Fokker-Planck equations including work using a multiple timescale expansion approach. By taking the linearly dragged harmonic oscillator as an exactly solvable example, we analytically calculate the work distribution associated with the Kramers equation, and verify its convergence to that associated with the Smoluchowski equation in the overdamped limit. We quantify the accuracy of the overdamped approximation as a function of the damping coefficient. In addition, we experimentally demonstrate that the data of the work distribution of a levitated silica nanosphere agrees with the overdamped approximation in the overdamped limit, but deviates from the overdamped approximation in the low-damping case. Our work fills a gap between the stochastic thermodynamics based on the complete Langevin equation (the Kramers equation) and the overdamped Langevin equation (the Smoluchowski equation), and deepens our understanding of the overdamped approximation in stochastic thermodynamics.

arXiv comment15 pages, 6 figures

References in corpus (37)

• A nonequilibrium equality for free energy differences
• Stochastic thermodynamics, fluctuation theorems, and molecular machines
• The Entropy Production Fluctuation Theorem and the Nonequilibrium Work Relation for Free Energy Differences
• Entropy production along a stochastic trajectory and an integral fluctuation theorem
• Verification of the Crooks fluctuation theorem and recovery of RNA folding free energies
• Information heat engine: converting information to energy by feedback control
• Brownian Carnot engine
• Stochastic thermodynamics under coarse-graining
• Work fluctuation theorems for harmonic oscillators
• Brownian motion at short time scales
• Entropy production in full phase space for continuous stochastic dynamics
• Optimal protocols for minimal work processes in underdamped stochastic thermodynamics
• Work and heat probability distribution of an optically driven Brownian particle: Theory and experiments
• Anomalous thermodynamics at the micro-scale
• Adiabatic processes realized with a trapped Brownian particle
• Electron spin control of optically levitated nanodiamonds in vacuum
• Experimental test of the differential fluctuation theorem and a generalized Jarzynski equality for arbitrary initial states
• Multiple-scale stochastic processes: decimation, averaging and beyond
• Onsager-Machlup theory for nonequilibrium steady states and fluctuation theorems
• Shortcuts to isothermality and nonequilibrium work relations
• Entropy Production of Brownian Macromolecules with Inertia
• Fluctuation Theorem for Hidden Entropy Production
• Path integral approach to quantum thermodynamics
• Work probability distribution in systems driven out of equilibrium
• Fluctuation relations for a driven Brownian particle
• Stochastic Dynamical Structure (SDS) of Nonequilibrium Processes in the Absence of Detailed Balance. III: potential function in local stochastic dynamics and in steady state of Boltzmann-Gibbs type distribution function
• Recovery of free energy branches in single molecule experiments
• High friction limit of the Kramers equation : the multiple time-scale approach
• Work fluctuations in a time-dependent harmonic potential: rigorous results and beyond the overdamped limit
• Asymptotics of work distributions in non-equilibrium systems
• Entropy production of nano systems with timescale separation
• Inertial Effects in Nonequilibrium Work Fluctuations by a Path Integral Approach
• Time reversibility and nonequilibrium thermodynamics of second-order stochastic processes
• Entropic anomaly and maximal efficiency of microscopic heat engines
• Path integral analysis of Jarzynski's equality: Analytical results
• Entropy production of a Brownian ellipsoid in the overdamped limit
• Brownian motion: from kinetics to hydrodynamics

Cited by in corpus (7)

• Kovacs memory effect with an optically levitated nanoparticle
• Functionals in stochastic thermodynamics: how to interpret stochastic integrals
• Entropy production and heat capacity of systems under time-dependent oscillating temperature
• Overdamped dynamics of a Brownian particle levitated in a Paul trap
• Hierarchical structure of fluctuation theorems for a driven system in contact with multiple heat reservoirs
• Stochastic light in a cavity: A Brownian particle in a scalar potential?
• Explicit noise and dissipation operators for quantum stochastic thermodynamics