Comparing Fully General Relativistic and Newtonian Calculations of Structure Formation

Abstract

In the standard approach to studying cosmological structure formation, the overall expansion of the Universe is assumed to be homogeneous, with the gravitational effect of inhomogeneities encoded entirely in a Newtonian potential. A topic of ongoing debate is to what degree this fully captures the dynamics dictated by general relativity, especially in the era of precision cosmology. To quantitatively assess this, we directly compare standard N-body Newtonian calculations to full numerical solutions of the Einstein equations, for cold matter with various magnitude initial inhomogeneities on scales comparable to the Hubble horizon. We analyze the differences in the evolution of density, luminosity distance, and other quantities defined with respect to fiducial observers. This is carried out by reconstructing the effective spacetime and matter fields dictated by the Newtonian quantities, and by taking care to distinguish effects of numerical resolution. We find that the fully general relativistic and Newtonian calculations show excellent agreement, even well into the nonlinear regime. They only notably differ in regions where the weak gravity assumption breaks down, which arise when considering extreme cases with perturbations exceeding standard values.

17 pages, 14 figures; revised to match PRD version

References in corpus (10)

• The Cosmic Code Comparison Project
• How well is our universe described by an FLRW model?
• An Improved Gauge Driver for the Generalized Harmonic Einstein System
• Relativistic N-body simulations with massive neutrinos
• Inhomogeneous Cosmology with Numerical Relativity
• Conformal Thin-Sandwich Solver for Generic Initial Data
• Observable Deviations from Homogeneity in an Inhomogeneous Universe
• Black Hole Universe with $\Lambda$
• General Relativistic Corrections to the Weak Lensing Convergence Power Spectrum
• The extended ROSAT-ESO Flux-Limited X-ray Galaxy Cluster Survey (REFLEX II) V. Exploring a local underdensity in the Southern Sky

Cited by in corpus (30)

• Large-scale dark matter simulations
• Einstein's Universe: Cosmological structure formation in numerical relativity
• Preheating in Full General Relativity
• The trouble with Hubble: Local versus global expansion rates in inhomogeneous cosmological simulations with numerical relativity
• GRAMSES: a new route to general relativistic $N$-body simulations in cosmology. Part I. Methodology and code description
• Luminosity distance and anisotropic sky-sampling at low redshifts: a numerical relativity study
• The Limited Accuracy of Linearized Gravity
• Black Hole Formation from the Collision of Plane-Fronted Gravitational Waves
• Cosmological gravity on all scales: simple equations, required conditions, and a framework for modified gravity
• Starting inflation from inhomogeneous initial conditions with momentum
• Numerical solutions to Einstein's equations in a shearing-dust Universe: a code comparison
• Simulated reconstruction of the remote dipole field using the kinetic Sunyaev Zel'dovich effect
• General Relativistic Cosmological N-body Simulations I: time integration
• Cosmological distances with general-relativistic ray tracing: framework and comparison to cosmographic predictions
• Using kinetic theory to examine a self-gravitating system composed of baryons and cold dark matter
• Cosmology using numerical relativity
• Einstein-Vlasov Calculations of Structure Formation
• On the question of measuring spatial curvature in an inhomogeneous universe
• Understanding the Dyer-Roeder approximation as a consequence of local cancellations of projected shear and expansion rate fluctuations
• fNL - gNL mixing in the matter density field at higher orders
• Reconciling a decelerating Universe with cosmological observations
• Evolution of black holes through a nonsingular cosmological bounce
• 1+3 formulation of Newton's equations
• Perturbatively constructed cosmological model with periodically distributed dust inhomogeneities
• BiGONLight: light propagation with bi-local operators in Numerical Relativity
• EBWeyl: a Code to Invariantly Characterize Numerical Spacetimes
• Structure formation and quasi-spherical collapse from initial curvature perturbations with numerical relativity simulations
• Construction of the cosmological model with periodically distributed inhomogeneities with growing amplitude
• Direct correspondence between Newtonian gravitation and general relativity
• The averaging problem on the past null cone in inhomogeneous dust cosmologies