Identifying Tools for Comparing Simulations and Observations of Spectral-line Data Cubes

Abstract

We present a statistical framework to compare spectral-line data cubes of molecular clouds and use the framework to perform an analysis of various statistical tools developed from methods proposed in the literature. We test whether our methods are sensitive to changes in the underlying physical properties of the clouds or whether their behaviour is governed by random fluctuations. We perform a set of 32 self-gravitating magnetohydrodynamic simulations that test all combinations of five physical parameters -- Mach number, plasma parameter, virial parameter, driving scales, and solenoidal driving fraction -- each of which can be set to a low or high value. We create mock observational data sets of ${}^{13}\mathrm{CO}$(1-0) emission from each simulation. We compare these mock data to a those generated from a set of baseline simulations using pseudo-distance metrics based on 18 different statistical techniques that have previously been used to study molecular clouds. We analyze these results using methods from the statistical field of experimental design and find that several of the statistics can reliably track changes in the underlying physics. Our analysis shows that the interactions between parameters are often among the most significant effects. A small fraction of statistics are also sensitive to changes in magnetic field properties. We use this framework to compare the set of simulations to observations of three nearby star-forming regions: NGC 1333, Oph A, and IC 348. We find that no one simulation agrees significantly better with the observations, although there is evidence that the high Mach number simulations are more consistent with the observations.

26 pages, 12 figures, accepted to MNRAS. If the data DOI link is not yet active, go here for the data: http://apps.canfar.net/storage/list/ekoch/Koch2017_SimulatedObs

References in corpus (20)

• Theory of Star Formation
• Structural Analysis of Molecular Clouds: Dendrograms
• The Density Probability Distribution in Compressible Isothermal Turbulence: Solenoidal versus Compressive Forcing
• CO Isotopologues in the Perseus Molecular Cloud Complex: the X-Factor and Regional Variations
• The COMPLETE Survey of Star-Forming Regions: Phase I Data
• Bolocam Survey for 1.1 mm Dust Continuum Emission in the c2d Legacy Clouds. II. Ophiuchus
• Density Fluctuations in MHD Turbulence: Spectra, Intermittency and Topology
• Molecular clouds have power-law probability distribution functions
• Cosmic Calibration: Constraints from the Matter Power Spectrum and the Cosmic Microwave Background
• The statistical properties of stars and their dependence on metallicity: the effects of opacity
• Cosmic Calibration
• Structure analysis of interstellar clouds: I. Improving the Delta-variance method
• Turbulence Spectra from Spectral Lines: Tests of the Velocity Channel Analysis and Velocity Coordinate Spectrum Techniques
• The Kinematics of Molecular Cloud Cores in the Presence of Driven and Decaying Turbulence: Comparisons with Observations
• Topology of Neutral Hydrogen Within the Small Magellanic Cloud
• Structure analysis of interstellar clouds: II. Applying the Delta-variance method to interstellar turbulence
• Simulations and cosmological inference: A statistical model for power spectra means and covariances
• Astrochemical Correlations in Molecular Clouds
• An Exploration of the Statistical Signatures of Stellar Feedback
• The Interplay of Turbulence & Magnetic Fields in Star-Forming Regions: Simulations and Observations

Cited by in corpus (4)

• TurbuStat: Turbulence Statistics in Python
• Topological signatures of interstellar magnetic fields - I. Betti numbers and persistence diagrams
• Genus Statistic Applied to the X-ray Remnant of SN 1572: Clues to the Clumpy Ejecta Structure of Type Ia Supernovae
• The CARMA-NRO Orion Survey: Statistical Signatures of Feedback in the Orion A Molecular Cloud