The standard mean-field treatment of inter-particle attraction in classical DFT is better than one might expect

Abstract

In classical density functional theory (DFT) the part of the Helmholtz free energy functional arising from attractive inter-particle interactions is often treated in a mean-field or van der Waals approximation. On the face of it, this is a somewhat crude treatment as the resulting functional generates the simple random phase approximation (RPA) for the bulk fluid pair direct correlation function. We explain why using standard mean-field DFT to describe inhomogeneous fluid structure and thermodynamics is more accurate than one might expect based on this observation. By considering the pair correlation function $g(x)$ and structure factor $S(k)$ of a one-dimensional model fluid, for which exact results are available, we show that the mean-field DFT, employed within the test-particle procedure, yields results much superior to those from the RPA closure of the bulk Ornstein-Zernike equation. We argue that one should not judge the quality of a DFT based solely on the approximation it generates for the bulk pair direct correlation function.

9 pages, 3 figures

References in corpus (4)

• The Local Compressibility of Liquids near Non-Adsorbing Substrates: A Useful Measure of Solvophobicity and Hydrophobicity?
• Local molecular field theory for the treatment of electrostatics
• Integral equations for simple fluids in a general reference functional approach
• Layering Transitions and Solvation Forces in an Asymmetrically Confined Fluid

Cited by in corpus (27)

• A unified description of hydrophilic and superhydrophobic surfaces in terms of the wetting and drying transitions of liquids
• Neural functional theory for inhomogeneous fluids: Fundamentals and applications
• Machine-learning free-energy functionals using density profiles from simulations
• Mean-Field Theory of Inhomogeneous Fluids
• On the decay of the pair correlation function and the line of vanishing excess isothermal compressibility in simple fluids
• Learning classical density functionals for ionic fluids
• The Primitive Model in Classical Density Functional Theory: Beyond the Standard Mean-Field Approximation
• One-dimensional fluids with second nearest-neighbor interactions
• Order-preserving dynamics in one dimension -- single-file diffusion and caging from the perspective of dynamical density functional theory
• Local measures of fluctuations in inhomogeneous liquids: Statistical mechanics and illustrative applications
• Metadensity functional theory for classical fluids: Extracting the pair potential
• Bridging of liquid drops at chemically structured walls
• The Role of Energy Scales for the Structure of Ionic Liquids at Electrified Interfaces -- A Theory-Based Approach
• Conditional probability density functional theory
• Functional-renormalization-group approach to classical liquids with short-range repulsion: a scheme without repulsive reference system
• Dynamic Decay and Superadiabatic Forces in the van Hove Dynamics of Bulk Hard Sphere Fluids
• Phase diagrams for sticky rods in bulk and in a monolayer from a lattice free-energy functional for anisotropic particles with depletion attractions
• On the equivalence of self-consistent equations for nonuniform liquids: a unified description of the various modifications
• Fingerprints of ordered self-assembled structures in the liquid phase of a hard-core, square-shoulder system
• Combining integral equation closures with force density functional theory for the study of inhomogeneous fluids
• Metadensity functional learning for classical fluids: Regularizing with pair correlations
• Computation of drug solvation free energy in supercritical CO2: alternatives to all-atom computer simulations
• Binding potentials for vapour nanobubbles on surfaces using density functional theory
• PDE-Constrained Optimization Models and Pseudospectral Methods for Multiscale Particle Dynamics
• Classical density functional theory for nanoparticle-laden droplets
• A unified machine-learning framework for ab initio multiscale modeling of liquids
• Effective one-body interactions due to the presence of a liquid-vapor interface