Planck confronts large scale structure: methods to quantify discordance
arXiv:1703.05959 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.95.123535
Abstract
Discordance in the CDM cosmological model can be seen by comparing parameters constrained by CMB measurements to those inferred by probes of large scale structure. Recent improvements in observations, including final data releases from both Planck and SDSS-III BOSS, as well as improved astrophysical uncertainty analysis of CFHTLenS, allows for an update in the quantification of any tension between large and small scales. This paper is intended, primarily, as a discussion on the quantifications of discordance when comparing the parameter constraints of a model when given two different data sets. We consider KL-divergence, comparison of Bayesian evidences and other statistics which are sensitive to the mean, variance and shape of the distributions. However, as a by-product, we present an update to the similar analysis in (Battye, Charnock and Moss; 2015) where we find that, considering new data and treatment of priors, the constraints from the CMB and from a combination of LSS probes are in greater agreement and any tension only persists to a minor degree. In particular, we find the parameter constraints from the combination of LSS probes which are most discrepant with the Planck2015+Pol+BAO parameter distributions can be quantified at a 2.55 tension using the method introduced in (Battye, Charnock and Moss; 2015). If instead we use the distributions constrained by the combination of LSS probes which are in greatest agreement with those from Planck2015+Pol+BAO this tension is only 0.76.
arXiv comment13 pages + 5 page abstract, 10 figures
References in corpus (46)
- Planck 2015 results. XIII. Cosmological parameters
- Planck 2013 results. XVI. Cosmological parameters
- Nine-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Parameter Results
- Cosmological parameters from CMB and other data: a Monte-Carlo approach
- The 6dF Galaxy Survey: Baryon Acoustic Oscillations and the Local Hubble Constant
- Weak Gravitational Lensing of the CMB
- Massive neutrinos and cosmology
- The clustering of galaxies in the SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: Baryon Acoustic Oscillations in the Data Release 9 Spectroscopic Galaxy Sample
- Planck 2015 results. XI. CMB power spectra, likelihoods, and robustness of parameters
- A 2% Distance to z=0.35 by Reconstructing Baryon Acoustic Oscillations - I : Methods and Application to the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- CFHTLenS tomographic weak lensing cosmological parameter constraints: Mitigating the impact of intrinsic galaxy alignments
- Planck 2013 results. XX. Cosmology from Sunyaev-Zeldovich cluster counts
- The 6dF Galaxy Survey: Samples, Observational Techniques and the First Data Release
- Weighing Neutrinos with Galaxy Surveys
- Gravitational Lensing Analysis of the Kilo Degree Survey
- Planck 2013 results. XVII. Gravitational lensing by large-scale structure
- Cosmological Constraints from Measurements of Type Ia Supernovae discovered during the first 1.5 years of the Pan-STARRS1 Survey
- The clustering of galaxies in the SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: Testing gravity with redshift-space distortions using the power spectrum multipoles
- Weighing the Giants IV: Cosmology and Neutrino Mass
- Evidence for massive neutrinos from CMB and lensing observations
- CFHTLenS revisited: assessing concordance with Planck including astrophysical systematics
- CDM: Neutrinos help reconcile Planck with the Local Universe
- The clustering of galaxies in the SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: RSD measurement from the LOS-dependent power spectrum of DR12 BOSS galaxies
- Quantifying discordance in the 2015 Planck CMB spectrum
- Cosmology from Cosmic Shear with DES Science Verification Data
- The clustering of galaxies in the SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: BAO measurement from the LOS-dependent power spectrum of DR12 BOSS galaxies
- Tension between the power spectrum of density perturbations measured on large and small scales
- The clustering of galaxies in the SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: Signs of neutrino mass in current cosmological datasets
- A new life for sterile neutrinos: resolving inconsistencies using hot dark matter
- Probing dark energy with cluster counts and cosmic shear power spectra: including the full covariance
- Bayesian evidence as a tool for comparing datasets
- Neutrino physics from precision cosmology
- Neutrino Masses from Cosmological Probes
- No new cosmological concordance with massive sterile neutrinos
- Banana Split: Testing the Dark Energy Consistency with Geometry and Growth
- Combining Planck with Large Scale Structure gives strong neutrino mass constraint
- Combining Probes of Large-Scale Structure with CosmoLike
- Probing the neutrino mass hierarchy with CMB weak lensing
- Information Gains from Cosmic Microwave Background Experiments
- Quantifying Tensions between CMB and Distance Datasets in Models with Free Curvature or Lensing Amplitude
- Constraints and tensions in testing general relativity from Planck and CFHTLenS including intrinsic alignment systematics
- Discrepancies between CFHTLenS cosmic shear & Planck: new physics or systematic effects?
- Information Gains from Cosmological Probes
- Can modified gravity models reconcile the tension between CMB anisotropy and lensing maps in Planck-like observations?
- Cosmology from cross correlation of CMB lensing and galaxy surveys
- The tension on the cosmological parameters from different observational data
Cited by in corpus (42)
- Planck evidence for a closed Universe and a possible crisis for cosmology
- Dynamical dark energy in light of the latest observations
- Curvature tension: evidence for a closed universe
- Dark energy two decades after: Observables, probes, consistency tests
- Dark Energy Survey Year 1 Results: Cosmological Constraints from Cluster Abundances and Weak Lensing
- Concordance and Discordance in Cosmology
- Hyper Suprime-Cam Year 3 Results: Cosmology from Cosmic Shear Power Spectra
- Baryon Acoustic Oscillations and the Hubble Constant: Past, Present and Future
- Dark Energy Survey Year 1 Results: Methods for Cluster Cosmology and Application to the SDSS
- KiDS+VIKING-450 and DES-Y1 combined: Mitigating baryon feedback uncertainty with COSEBIs
- Quantifying tensions in cosmological parameters: Interpreting the DES evidence ratio
- Cosmological Constraints from DES Y1 Cluster Abundances and SPT Multi-wavelength data
- Assessing tension metrics with Dark Energy Survey and Planck data
- Quantifying the global parameter tensions between ACT, SPT and Planck
- Cosmological discordances II: Hubble constant, Planck and large-scale-structure data sets
- Cosmological discordances: a new measure, marginalization effects, and application to geometry vs growth current data sets
- Non-Gaussian estimates of tensions in cosmological parameters
- Cosmological Measurements from Angular Power Spectra Analysis of BOSS DR12 Tomography
- Consistency tests in cosmology using relative entropy
- A Bayesian interpretation of inconsistency measures in cosmology
- Quantifying the global "CMB tension" between the Atacama Cosmology Telescope and the Planck satellite in extended models of cosmology
- Quantifying Suspiciousness Within Correlated Data Sets
- Optimised angular power spectra for spectroscopic galaxy surveys
- CosmoBit: A GAMBIT module for computing cosmological observables and likelihoods
- Conservative cosmology: combining data with allowance for unknown systematics
- CMB Anomalies and the Hubble Tension
- Does Quartessence Ease Tensions?
- Developing a unified pipeline for large-scale structure data analysis with angular power spectra -- I. The importance of redshift-space distortions for galaxy number counts
- A new measure of tension between experiments
- Concordance Cosmology?
- A Bayesian quantification of consistency in correlated datasets
- Cosmological discordances III: more on measure properties, Large-Scale-Structure constraints, the Hubble constant and Planck
- Dark Energy Survey Year 3 Results: Measurement of the Baryon Acoustic Oscillations with Three-dimensional Clustering
- When tension is just a fluctuation: How noisy data affect model comparison
- Integrated cosmological probes: Concordance quantified
- Relic Neutrino Degeneracies and Their Impact on Cosmological Parameters
- Turnaround density as a probe of the cosmological constant
- One Extension to Explain Them All, One Scale-Invariant Spectrum to Test Them All, and in One Model Bind Them
- The maximum turnaround radius for axisymmetric cosmic structures
- Data-Space Validation of High-Dimensional Models by Comparing Sample Quantiles
- Model-independent constraints on clustering and growth of cosmic structures from BOSS DR12 galaxies in harmonic space
- Calibrating Bayesian Tension Statistics using Neural Ratio Estimation