Quantum and Classical Behavior in Interacting Bosonic Systems

Abstract

It is understood that in free bosonic theories, the classical field theory accurately describes the full quantum theory when the occupancy numbers of systems are very large. However, the situation is less understood in interacting theories, especially on time scales longer than the dynamical relaxation time. Recently there have been claims that the quantum theory deviates spectacularly from the classical theory on this time scale, even if the occupancy numbers are extremely large. Furthermore, it is claimed that the quantum theory quickly thermalizes while the classical theory does not. The evidence for these claims comes from noticing a spectacular difference in the time evolution of expectation values of quantum operators compared to the classical micro-state evolution. If true, this would have dramatic consequences for many important phenomena, including laboratory studies of interacting BECs, dark matter axions, preheating after inflation, etc. In this work we critically examine these claims. We show that in fact the classical theory can describe the quantum behavior in the high occupancy regime, even when interactions are large. The connection is that the expectation values of quantum operators in a single quantum micro-state are approximated by a corresponding classical ensemble average over many classical micro-states. Furthermore, by the ergodic theorem, a classical ensemble average of local fields with statistical translation invariance is the spatial average of a single micro-state. So the correlation functions of the quantum and classical field theories of a single micro-state approximately agree at high occupancy, even in interacting systems. Furthermore, both quantum and classical field theories can thermalize, when appropriate coarse graining is introduced, with the classical case requiring a cutoff on low occupancy UV modes. We discuss applications of our results.

8 pages, 4 plots. V2: Updated figures and other minor improvements. V3: Some expansion of introduction and discussion; updated to version published in JCAP

References in corpus (24)

• Axion Cosmology
• Nonperturbative Dynamics Of Reheating After Inflation: A Review
• Bose-Einstein Condensation of Dark Matter Axions
• Axion Miniclusters and Bose Stars
• Do Dark Matter Axions Form a Condensate with Long-Range Correlation?
• Non-Linear Axion Dynamics and Formation of Cosmological Pseudo-Solitons
• Cosmological Constraints on Bose-Einstein-Condensed Scalar Field Dark Matter
• Angular Momentum and Vortex Formation in Bose-Einstein-Condensed Cold Dark Matter Haloes
• Quantum Radiation of Oscillons
• On the equivalence between the Boltzmann equation and classical field theory at large occupation numbers
• Cosmic axion thermalization
• Nonlinear Inflaton Fragmentation after Preheating
• The Lifetime of Axion Stars
• The approach to thermalization in the classical phi^4 theory in 1+1 dimensions: energy cascades and universal scaling
• Bose Einstein condensation of the classical axion field in cosmology?
• Origin of probabilities and their application to the multiverse
• Far from equilibrium dynamics of Bose-Einstein condensation for Axion Dark Matter
• Classical Real Time Correlation Functions And Quantum Corrections at Finite Temperature
• Effective gravitational interactions of dark matter axions
• Duration of classicality in highly degenerate interacting Bosonic systems
• Quantum Dew
• Short-scale gravitational instability in a disordered Bose gas
• The finite temperature real time \hbar^2 corrections in quantum mechanics
• Classical Simulation of Quantum Fields I

Cited by in corpus (33)

• Small-scale structure of fuzzy and axion-like dark matter
• Gravitational probes of dark matter physics
• Black hole formation from axion stars
• Dark Matter Axion Clump Resonance of Photons
• Analysis of Dark Matter Axion Clumps with Spherical Symmetry
• Can Light Dark Matter Solve the Core-Cusp Problem?
• Merger of Dark Matter Axion Clumps and Resonant Photon Emission
• Classicality and Quantum Break-Time for Cosmic Axions
• Scalar Dark Matter Clumps with Angular Momentum
• Hydrogen Axion Star: Metallic Hydrogen Bound to a QCD Axion BEC
• A Classical-Quantum Correspondence and Backreaction
• Friendship in the Axiverse: Late-time direct and astrophysical signatures of early-time nonlinear axion dynamics
• Beyond Schrödinger-Poisson: Nonrelativistic Effective Field Theory for Scalar Dark Matter
• Vacuum Decay in Real Time and Imaginary Time Formalisms
• Exploring the ultra-light to sub-MeV dark matter window with atomic clocks and co-magnetometers
• Boson stars and their relatives in semiclassical gravity
• Gravitational Decoherence of Dark Matter
• Microlensing constraints on axion stars including finite lens and source size effects
• Quantitative Analysis of the Stochastic Approach to Quantum Tunneling
• Yang-Mills stars in Higgsed non-Abelian dark matter
• Looking at the axionic dark sector with ANITA
• Effective theories for a nonrelativistic field in an expanding universe: Induced self-interaction, pressure, sound speed, and viscosity
• Ultra-light axions and the kinetic Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect
• Decay of Boson Stars with Application to Glueballs and Other Real Scalars
• Decoherence from General Relativity
• Revisiting isocurvature bounds in models unifying the axion with the inflaton
• On the single classical field description of interacting scalar fields
• When quantum corrections alter the predictions of classical field theory for scalar field dark matter
• Nonclassicality of axion-like dark matter through gravitational self-interactions
• Bubble nucleation and quantum initial conditions in classical statistical simulations
• Field moment expansion method for interacting Bosonic systems
• Effects of New Forces on Scalar Dark Matter Solitons
• Constraints on extended axion structures from the lensing of fast radio bursts