Effects of flare definitions on the statistics of derived flare distributions

Abstract

The statistical examination of solar flares is crucial to revealing their global characteristics and behaviour. Such examinations can tackle large-scale science questions or give context to detailed single-event studies. However, they are often performed using standard but basic flare detection algorithms relying on arbitrary thresholds. This arbitrariness may lead to important scientific conclusions being drawn from results caused by subjective choices in algorithms rather than the true nature of the Sun. In this paper, we explore the effect of the arbitrary thresholds used in the GOES (Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite) event list and LYRA (Large Yield RAdiometer) Flare Finder algorithms. We find that there is a small but significant relationship between the power law exponent of the GOES flare peak flux frequency distribution and the flare start thresholds of the algorithms. We also find that the power law exponents of these distributions are not stable, but appear to steepen with increasing peak flux. This implies that the observed flare size distribution may not be a power law at all. We show that depending on the true value of the exponent of the flare size distribution, this deviation from a power law may be due to flares missed by the flare detection algorithms. However, it is not possible determine the true exponent from GOES/XRS observations. Additionally we find that the PROBA2/LYRA flare size distributions are artificially steep and clearly non-power law. We show that this is consistent with an insufficient degradation correction. This means that PROBA2/LYRA should not be used for flare statistics or energetics unless degradation is adequately accounted for. However, it can be used to study variations over shorter timescales and for space weather monitoring.

14 pages, 8 figures, 1 table

References in corpus (11)

• Power-law distributions in empirical data
• 25 Years of Self-Organized Criticality: Solar and Astrophysics
• A Contemporary View of Coronal Heating
• Automated Solar Flare Statistics in Soft X-rays over 37 Years of GOES Observations - The Invariance of Self-Organized Criticality during Three Solar Cycles
• SunPy - Python for Solar Physics
• Global Energetics of Solar Flares: II. Thermal Energies
• The Thermal Properties of Solar Flares Over Three Solar Cycles Using GOES X-ray Observations
• The LYRA Instrument Onboard PROBA2: Description and In-Flight Performance
• An ALMA Disk Mass for the Candidate Protoplanetary Companion to FW Tau
• Coronal Fourier power spectra: implications for coronal seismology and coronal heating
• The Effect of Limited Sample Sizes on the Accuracy of the Estimated Scaling Parameter for Power-Law-Distributed Solar Data

Cited by in corpus (7)

• Stellar Coronal Mass Ejections I. Estimating occurrence frequencies and mass-loss rates
• Hot X-ray Onsets of Solar Flares
• Lyman-alpha Variability During Solar Flares Over Solar Cycle 24 Using GOES-15/EUVS-E
• A Statistical Study of Short-period Decayless Oscillations of Coronal Loops in an Active Region
• The Effect of Limited Sample Sizes on the Accuracy of the Estimated Scaling Parameter for Power-Law-Distributed Solar Data
• Coronal Heating as Determined by the Solar Flare Frequency Distribution Obtained by Aggregating Case Studies
• Solar flare catalog from 3 years of Chandrayaan-2 XSM observations