From Boole to Leggett-Garg: Epistemology of Bell-type Inequalities

Abstract

In 1862, George Boole derived an inequality for variables, now known as Boolean variables, that in his opinion represents a demarcation line between possible and impossible experience. This inequality forms an important milestone in the epistemology of probability theory and probability measures. In 1985 Leggett and Garg derived a physics related inequality, mathematically identical to Boole's, that according to them represents a demarcation between macroscopic realism and quantum mechanics. Their formalism, constructed for the magnetic flux of SQUIDS, includes general features and applies also to many other quantum experiments. We show that a wide gulf, a wide divide, separates the "sense impressions" and corresponding data, as well as the postulates of macroscopic realism, from the mathematical abstractions that are used to derive the inequality of Leggett-Garg. If the gulf can be bridged, one may indeed derive the said inequality, which is then clearly a demarcation between possible and impossible experience: it cannot be violated and is not violated by quantum theory. We deduce from this fact that a violation of the Leggett-Garg inequality does not mean that the SQUID-flux is not there when nobody looks, as Leggett-Garg suggest, but instead that the probability measures may not be what Leggett-Garg have assumed them to be, when no data can be secured that directly relate to them. We show that similar considerations apply to other well known quantum interpretation-puzzles including that of the two-slit experiment.

Added two paragraphs + references to discuss recent experiment

References in corpus (2)

• Ideal negative measurements in quantum walks disprove theories based on classical trajectories
• Reply to the Comment by A.J. Leggett and Anupam Garg

Cited by in corpus (8)

• Is the Moon there if nobody looks: Bell Inequalities and Physical Reality
• Contextuality-by-Default description of Bell tests: Contextuality as the rule not as an exception
• Quantum Cognitive Triad. Semantic geometry of context representation
• The Bell theorem revisited: geometric phases in gauge theories
• Constraints on Macroscopic Realism Without Assuming Non-Invasive Measurability
• My discussions of quantum foundations with John Stewart Bell
• The Transition from Quantum to Classical in weak measurements and reconstruction of Quantum Correlation
• Statistical Contextual Explanation of Quantum Paradoxes