Evidence for Cluster to Cluster Variations in Low-Mass Stellar Rotational Evolution

Abstract

A concordance model for angular momentum evolution has been developed by multiple investigators. This approach postulates that star forming regions and clusters are an evolutionary sequence which can be modeled with assumptions about the coupling between protostars and accretion disks, angular momentum loss from magnetized winds that saturates in a mass-dependent fashion at high rotation rates, and core-envelope decoupling for solar analogs. We test this approach by combining established data with the large h Per dataset from the MONITOR project and new low-mass Pleiades data. We confirm prior results that young low-mass stars can be used to test star-disk coupling and angular momentum loss independent of the treatment of internal angular momentum transport. For slow rotators, we confirm the need for star-disk interactions to evolve the ONC to older systems, using h Per (age 13~Myr) as our natural post-disk case. Further interactions are not required to evolve slow rotators from h Per to older systems, implying no justification for extremely long-lived disks as an alternative to core-envelope decoupling. However, our wind models cannot evolve rapid rotators from h Per to older systems consistently; this appears to be a general problem for any wind model that becomes ineffective in low-mass young stars. We outline two possible solutions: either there is cosmic variance in the distribution of stellar rotation rates in different clusters or there are substantially enhanced torques in low-mass rapid rotators. We favor the former explanation and discuss observational tests that could be used to distinguish them. If the distribution of initial conditions depends on environment, models which test parameters by assuming a universal underlying distribution of initial conditions will need to be re-evaluated.

Submitted to ApJ, 18 pages, 15 figures

References in corpus (14)

• Photoevaporation of protoplanetary discs II: evolutionary models and observable properties
• Weakened magnetic braking as the origin of anomalously rapid rotation in old field stars
• The Mass-Dependence of Angular Momentum Evolution in Sun-Like Stars
• Improved angular momentum evolution model for solar-like stars II. Exploring the mass dependence
• The Distances to Open Clusters from Main-Sequence Fitting. III. Improved Accuracy with Empirically Calibrated Isochrones
• Fitting the young main-sequence; distances, ages and age spreads
• A Correlation Between Pre-Main Sequence Stellar Rotation Rates and IRAC Excesses in Orion
• Older and Colder: The impact of starspots on pre-main sequence stellar evolution
• Deep MMT Transit Survey of the Open Cluster M37 III: Stellar Rotation at 550 Myr
• The Metastable Dynamo Model of Stellar Rotational Evolution
• Testing the Disk Regulation Paradigm with Spitzer Observations. I. Rotation Periods of Pre-main Sequence Stars in the IC 348 Cluster
• Deep MMT Transit Survey of the Open Cluster M37 I: Observations and Cluster Parameters
• Why are rapidly rotating M dwarfs in the Pleiades so (infra)red? New period measurements confirm rotation-dependent color offsets from the cluster sequence
• OPserver: interactive online-computations of opacities and radiative accelerations

Cited by in corpus (15)

• Rotation of Low-Mass Stars in Upper Scorpius and Rho Ophiuchus with K2
• WIYN Open Cluster Study. LXXV. Testing the Metallicity Dependence of Stellar Lithium Depletion Using Hyades-Aged Clusters. 1. Hyades & Praesepe
• Rotation of Late-Type Stars in Praesepe with K2
• Forward Modeling of the Kepler Stellar Rotation Period Distribution: Interpreting Periods from Mixed and Biased Stellar Populations
• Rotation of Low-Mass Stars in Taurus with K2
• The Impact of Metallicity on the Evolution of Rotation and Magnetic Activity of Sun-Like Stars
• Lithium abundance and rotation of seismic solar analogues - Solar and stellar connection from Kepler and Hermes observations
• The rotation period distribution of the rich Pleiades-age Southern open cluster NGC 2516. Existence of a representative zero-age main sequence distribution
• M Dwarf rotation from the $K2$ young clusters to the field. I. A Mass-Rotation Correlation at 10 Myr
• MESA models with magnetic braking
• The influence of the environment on the spin evolution of low-mass stars. I. External photoevaporation of circumstellar disks
• Rotation of Low-Mass Stars in Upper Centaurus Lupus and Lower Centaurus Crux with TESS
• Optical Photometric Variable Stars towards the Galactic \hii region NGC 2282
• The ionizing source of the bipolar HII region S106: a close massive binary
• 200,000+ Deep Learning-inferred Periods of Stellar Variability from the All-Sky Automated Survey for Supernovae