Confronting uncertainties in stellar physics II. exploring differences in main-sequence stellar evolution tracks

Abstract

We assess the systematic uncertainties in stellar evolutionary calculations for low- to intermediate-mass, main-sequence stars. We compare published stellar tracks from several different evolution codes with our own tracks computed using the stellar codes STARS and MESA. In particular, we focus on tracks of 1 and 3 solar masses at solar metallicity. We find that the spread in the available 1 solar mass tracks (computed before the recent solar composition revision by Asplund et al.) can be covered by tracks between 0.97-1.01 solar masses computed with the STARS code. We assess some possible causes of the origin of this uncertainty, including how the choice of input physics and the solar constraints used to perform the solar calibration affect the tracks. We find that for a 1 solar mass track, uncertainties of around 10% in the initial hydrogen abundance and initial metallicity produce around a 2% error in mass. For the 3 solar mass tracks, there is very little difference between the tracks from the various different stellar codes. The main difference comes in the extent of the main sequence, which we believe results from the different choices of the implementation of convective overshooting in the core. Uncertainties in the initial abundances lead to a 1-2% error in the mass determination. These uncertainties cover only part of the total error budget, which should also include uncertainties in the input physics (e.g., reaction rates, opacities, convective models) and any missing physics (e.g., radiative levitation, rotation, magnetic fields). Uncertainties in stellar surface properties such as luminosity and effective temperature will further reduce the accuracy of any potential mass determinations.

11 pages, 11 figures. Accepted for publication in A&A

References in corpus (20)

• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA)
• The Dartmouth Stellar Evolution Database
• Scaled solar tracks and isochrones in a large region of the Z-Y plane I. From the ZAMS to the TP-AGB end for 0.15 - 2.5 Mo stars
• A probable stellar solution to the cosmological lithium discrepancy
• The elemental composition of the Sun I. The intermediate mass elements Na to Ca
• BONNSAI: a Bayesian tool for comparing stars with stellar evolution models
• Improvements to stellar structure models, based on a grid of 3D convection simulations. II. Calibrating the mixing-length formulation
• The evolution of rotating very massive stars with LMC composition
• The Stagger-grid: A grid of 3D stellar atmosphere models - III. The relation to mixing-length convection theory
• Isochrones for Old (> 5 Gyr) Stars and Stellar Populations. I. Models for $-2.4\le$ [Fe/H] $\le +0.6$, $0.25\le Y\le 0.33$, and $-0.4\le$ [$\alpha$\Fe] $\le +0.4$
• On the proper use of the Schwarzschild and Ledoux criteria in stellar evolution computations
• Confronting uncertainties in stellar physics: calibrating convective overshooting with eclipsing binaries
• On the Use of Blanketed Atmospheres as Boundary Conditions for Stellar Evolutionary Models
• Atomic diffusion and mixing in old stars II. Observations of stars in the globular cluster NGC 6397 with VLT/FLAMES-GIRAFFE
• Abundances in intermediate-mass AGB stars undergoing third dredge-up and hot-bottom burning
• Code dependencies of pre-supernova evolution and nucleosynthesis in massive stars: Evolution to the end of core helium burning
• Stellar models with mixing length and T(tau) relations calibrated on 3D convection simulations
• Stellar models with the ML2 theory of convection
• Does simultaneous solution matter for stellar evolution codes?
• Theory of stellar convection: Removing the Mixing-Length Parameter

Cited by in corpus (28)

• The First APOKASC Catalog of Kepler Dwarf and Subgiant Stars
• Mixing by overshooting and rotation in intermediate mass stars
• An Investigation of the Rotational Properties of Magnetic Chemically Peculiar Stars
• Progenitors of Type IIb Supernovae: I. Evolutionary Pathways and Rates
• The Effect of Tides on the Population of PN from Interacting Binaries
• Statistical errors and systematic biases in the calibration of the convective core overshooting with eclipsing binaries. A case study: TZ Fornacis
• The physics of Core-Collapse Supernovae: explosion mechanism and explosive nucleosynthesis
• Nonlinear seismic scaling relations
• A study of convective core overshooting as a function of stellar mass based on two-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations
• Post-common-envelope binary stars, radiative levitation, and blue large-amplitude pulsators
• Pulsation in faint blue stars
• BONNSAI: correlated stellar observables in Bayesian methods
• Models for Sixty Double-Lined Binaries containing Giants
• Synthetic observables for electron-capture supernovae and low-mass core collapse supernovae
• The effects of diffusion in hot subdwarf progenitors from the common envelope channel
• Hierarchically modelling Kepler dwarfs and subgiants to improve inference of stellar properties with asteroseismology
• Radiative levitation in carbon-enhanced metal-poor stars with s-process enrichment
• The formation of barium giants via mass accretion in binary systems
• Stellar masses from granulation and oscillations of 23 bright red giants observed by BRITE - Constellation
• Goodness-of-fit test for isochrone fitting in the Gaia era. Statistical assessment of the error distribution
• Unique Probe of Neutrino Electromagnetic Moments with Radiative Pair Emission
• Period Change Rates of Large Magellanic Cloud Cepheids using MESA
• Stellar model calibrations with the Ai Phe binary system. Open questions about the robustness of the fit
• Age and convective core overshooting calibrations in CPD-54 810 binary system. Statistical investigation on the solution robustness
• Disentangle Neutrino Electromagnetic Properties with Atomic Radiative Pair Emission
• Mass-effective temperature-surface gravity relation for intermediate-mass main-sequence stars
• Neutrinos and Asteroseismology of Stars over the Helium Flash
• Effects of stratification on overshooting and waves atop the convective core of $5M_{\odot }$ main-sequence stars