Regularization versus renormalization: Why are Casimir energy differences so often finite?
arXiv:1601.01374 · doi:10.3390/particles2010002
Abstract
One of the very first applications of the quantum field theoretic vacuum state was in the development of the notion of Casimir energy. Now field theoretic Casimir energies, considered individually, are always infinite. But differences in Casimir energies (at worst regularized, not renormalized) are quite often finite --- a fortunate circumstance which luckily made some of the early calculations, (for instance, for parallel plates and hollow spheres), tolerably tractable. We shall explore the extent to which this observation can be made systematic. For instance: What are necessary and sufficient conditions for Casimir energy differences to be finite (with regularization but without renormalization)? And, when the Casimir energy differences are not formally finite, can anything useful nevertheless be said by invoking renormalization? We shall see that it is the difference in the first few Seeley--DeWitt coefficients that is central to answering these questions. In particular, for any collection of conductors (be they perfect or imperfect) and/or dielectrics, as long as one merely moves them around without changing their shape or volume, then physically the Casimir energy difference (and so also the physically interesting Casimir forces) are guaranteed to be finite without invoking any renormalization.
arXiv commentV1: 23 pages; Based on a talk given at the "Quantum Vacuum and Gravitation" conference,QVG2015, MITP, Gutenberg University, Mainz, June 2015. V2: Now 28 pages; note change in title; significant extra discussion and references. This e-print closely parallels the published version
References in corpus (30)
- New Developments in the Casimir Effect
- Heat kernel expansion: user's manual
- Observation of the Dynamical Casimir Effect in a Superconducting Circuit
- The Casimir force between real materials: experiment and theory
- The Casimir effect: Recent controversies and progress
- The Casimir Effect and the Quantum Vacuum
- Casimir forces between arbitrary compact objects
- Scattering Theory Approach to Electrodynamic Casimir Forces
- Opposites Attract - A Theorem About The Casimir Force
- Repulsive Casimir forces
- Zeta Functions and the Casimir Energy
- Sakharov's induced gravity: a modern perspective
- Calculating Vacuum Energies in Renormalizable Quantum Field Theories: A New Approach to the Casimir Problem
- Casimir Effect on the Worldline
- Casimir forces in a T operator approach
- The Dirichlet Casimir Problem
- Dynamical Casimir effect entangles artificial atoms
- The Casimir Effect and Geometric Optics
- Casimir Energies in Light of Quantum Field Theory
- Systematics of the Relationship between Vacuum Energy Calculations and Heat Kernel Coefficients
- Scale anomalies imply violation of the averaged null energy condition
- Analytic results for the effective action
- From dispersion relations to spectral dimension - and back again
- Casimir effect in dielectrics: Bulk Energy Contribution
- Schwinger's Dynamical Casimir Effect: Bulk Energy Contribution
- Casimir effect in dielectrics: Surface area contribution
- Mode summation approach to Casimir effect between two objects
- Renormalization for a Scalar Field in an External Scalar Potential
- Zeta functions, renormalization group equations, and the effective action
- Scalar Casimir Energies of Tetrahedra and Prisms
Cited by in corpus (5)
- Feynman's i-epsilon prescription, almost real spacetimes, and acceptable complex spacetimes
- Null Second Order Corrections to Casimir Energy in Weak Gravitational Field
- Casimir effect in Snyder Space
- Pauli-Villars regularization of Kaluza-Klein Casimir energy with Lorentz symmetry
- UV sensitivity of Casimir energy