Conflict and Computation on Wikipedia: a Finite-State Machine Analysis of Editor Interactions
arXiv:1512.04177 · doi:10.3390/fi8030031
Abstract
What is the boundary between a vigorous argument and a breakdown of relations? What drives a group of individuals across it? Taking Wikipedia as a test case, we use a hidden Markov model to approximate the computational structure and social grammar of more than a decade of cooperation and conflict among its editors. Across a wide range of pages, we discover a bursty war/peace structure where the systems can become trapped, sometimes for months, in a computational subspace associated with significantly higher levels of conflict-tracking "revert" actions. Distinct patterns of behavior characterize the lower-conflict subspace, including tit-for-tat reversion. While a fraction of the transitions between these subspaces are associated with top-down actions taken by administrators, the effects are weak. Surprisingly, we find no statistical signal that transitions are associated with the appearance of particularly anti-social users, and only weak association with significant news events outside the system. These findings are consistent with transitions being driven by decentralized processes with no clear locus of control. Models of belief revision in the presence of a common resource for information-sharing predict the existence of two distinct phases: a disordered high-conflict phase, and a frozen phase with spontaneously-broken symmetry. The bistability we observe empirically may be a consequence of editor turn-over, which drives the system to a critical point between them.
arXiv comment23 pages, 3 figures. Matches published version. Code for HMM fitting available at http://bit.ly/sfihmm ; time series and derived finite state machines at bit.ly/wiki_hmm
References in corpus (16)
- The origin of bursts and heavy tails in human dynamics
- Dynamics of conflicts in Wikipedia
- Dynamical and bursty interactions in social networks
- Early warning signals for critical transitions: A generalized modeling approach
- Opinions, Conflicts and Consensus: Modeling Social Dynamics in a Collaborative Environment
- Edit wars in Wikipedia
- Bootstrap Methods for the Empirical Study of Decision-Making and Information Flows in Social Systems
- Inductive Game Theory and the Dynamics of Animal Conflict
- Value production in a collaborative environment
- The Evolution of Wikipedia's Norm Network
- Modeling Social Dynamics in a Collaborative Environment
- Collective Phenomena and Non-Finite State Computation in a Human Social System
- Evidence of strategic periodicities in collective conflict dynamics
- Statistical Signatures of Structural Organization: The case of long memory in renewal processes
- Group Minds and the Case of Wikipedia
- Analyzing Organizational Routines in Online Knowledge Collaborations: A Case for Sequence Analysis in CSCW