Can gravity account for the emergence of classicality?
arXiv:1509.04363 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.92.124050
Abstract
A recent debate has ensued over the claim by Pikovski et al. [Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] that systems with internal degrees of freedom undergo a universal, gravity-induced, type of decoherence that explains their quantum-to-classical transition. This decoherence is supposed to arise from the different gravitational redshifts experienced by such systems when placed in a superposition of two wave packets at different heights in a gravitational field. Here we investigate some aspects of the discussion with the aid of simple examples. In particular, we first resolve an apparent conflict between the reported results and the equivalence principle by noting that the static and free-fall descriptions focus on states associated with different hypersurfaces. Next, we emphasize that predictions regarding the observability of interference become relevant only in the context of concrete experimental settings. As a result, we caution against hasty claims of universal validity. Finally, we dispute the claim that, at least in the scenarios discussed by Pikovski et al., gravitation is responsible for the reported results, and we question the alleged ability of decoherence to explain the quantum-to-classical transition. In consequence, we argue against the extraordinary assertion by Pikovski et al. that gravity can account for the emergence of classicality.
arXiv comment10 pages, 6 figures
References in corpus (13)
- Gravitation and quantummechanical localization of macroobjects
- Universal decoherence due to gravitational time dilation
- Why Decoherence has not Solved the Measurement Problem: A Response to P. W. Anderson
- Does an atom interferometer test the gravitational redshift at the Compton frequency ?
- On a New Non-Geometric Element in Gravity
- Atom Interferometers and the Gravitational Redshift
- Does Quantum Mechanics Clash with the Equivalence Principle - and Does it Matter?
- On the Geometrical Character of Gravitation
- Gravitational Decoherence for Mesoscopic Systems
- Comment on "Universal decoherence due to gravitational time dilation"
- Testing the Equivalence Principle with Unstable Particles
- Time Dilation in Quantum Systems and Decoherence: Questions and Answers
- On the puzzle of Bremsstrahlung as described by coaccelerated observers
Cited by in corpus (15)
- Gravitational Decoherence
- Equivalence Principle for Quantum Systems: Dephasing and Phase Shift of Free-Falling Particles
- On universal decoherence under gravity: a perspective through the Equivalence Principle
- Gravitational Decoherence of Dark Matter
- Coupling Quantum Matter and Gravity
- Classical and Nonclassical Time Dilation for Quantum Clocks
- Decoherence due to gravitational time dilation: analysis of competing decoherence effects
- Post-Newtonian corrections to Schrödinger equations in gravitational fields
- General Relativistic Decoherence with Applications to Dark Matter Detection
- Decoherence from General Relativity
- Information transfer during the universal gravitational decoherence
- Semi-classical gravity phenomenology under the causal-conditional quantum measurement prescription
- Post-Newtonian Description of Quantum Systems in Gravitational Fields
- Gravitational entanglement and the mass contribution of internal energy in nonrelativistic quantum systems
- De Broglie relations, Gravitational time dilation and weak equivalence principle