New look at the degeneracies in the neutrino oscillation parameters, and their resolution by T2K, NO$\nu$A and ICAL

Abstract

At present the three major unknowns in neutrino oscillation parameters are the mass hierarchy, the octant of ${\theta }_{23}$ and the CP phase ${\delta }_{CP}$. It is well known that the presence of hierarchy$-{\delta }_{CP}$ and octant degeneracies affects the unambiguous determination of these parameters. In this paper we show that a comprehensive way to study the remaining parameter degeneracies is in the form of a generalized hierarchy-${\theta }_{23}$ - ${\delta }_{CP}$ degeneracy. We show that the wrong-hierarchy and/or wrong-octant solutions can be further classified into eight different solutions depending on whether they occur with the wrong or right value of ${\delta }_{CP}$. These eight solutions are different from the original eightfold degenerate solutions and can exist, in principle, even if ${\theta }_{13}$ is known. These multiple solutions, apart from affecting the determination of the true hierarchy and octant, also affect the accurate estimation of ${\delta }_{CP}$. We identify which of these eight different degenerate solutions can occur in the test (${\theta }_{23}-{\delta }_{CP}$) parameter space, taking the long-baseline experiment NO$\nu$A running in the neutrino mode as an example. The inclusion of the NO$\nu$A antineutrino run removes the wrong-octant solutions appearing with both right and wrong hierarchy. Adding T2K data to this resolves the wrong hierarchy -- right octant solutions to a large extent. The remaining wrong hierarchy solutions can be removed by combining NO$\nu$A + T2K with atmospheric neutrino data. We demonstrate this using ICAL@INO as the prototype atmospheric neutrino detector. We find that the degeneracies can be resolved at the $2\sigma$ level by the combined data set, for the true parameter space considered in the study.

32 pages, 6 figures, 4 tables, version accepted for publication in Phys. Rev. D

References in corpus (65)

• Observation of Reactor Electron Antineutrino Disappearance in the RENO Experiment
• Indication of Electron Neutrino Appearance from an Accelerator-produced Off-axis Muon Neutrino Beam
• Simulation of long-baseline neutrino oscillation experiments with GLoBES
• New features in the simulation of neutrino oscillation experiments with GLoBES 3.0
• Updated fit to three neutrino mixing: status of leptonic CP violation
• Golden measurements at a neutrino factory
• Neutrino oscillations refitted
• Status of three-neutrino oscillation parameters, circa 2013
• Breaking Eight-fold Degeneracies in Neutrino CP Violation, Mixing, and Mass Hierarchy
• Getting the most from the statistical analysis of solar neutrino oscillations
• Exploring Neutrino Mixing with Low Energy Superbeams
• Analytic Approximations for Three Neutrino Oscillation Parameters and Probabilities in Matter
• Series expansions for three-flavor neutrino oscillation probabilities in matter
• Tests of three-flavor mixing in long-baseline neutrino oscillation experiments
• Atmospheric Neutrino Oscillations and New Physics
• Improved measurements of the neutrino mixing angle ${\theta }_{13}$ with the Double Chooz detector
• Resolving Neutrino Mass Hierarchy and CP Degeneracy by Two Identical Detectors with Different Baselines
• The silver channel at the Neutrino Factory
• Reactor Measurement of ${\theta }_{13}$ and Its Complementarity to Long-Baseline Experiments
• Neutrino Interactions In Oscillation Experiments
• Reactor Neutrino Experiments Compared to Superbeams
• Determining the Neutrino Mass Hierarchy with INO, T2K, NOvA and Reactor Experiments
• Superbeams plus Neutrino Factory: the golden path to leptonic CP violation
• Resolving parameter degeneracies in long-baseline experiments by atmospheric neutrino data
• Quantization of Fermionic Fields with Two Mass States in the First Order Formalism
• Mass Hierarchy Determination via future Atmospheric Neutrino Detectors
• Determining the Neutrino Mass Hierarchy with Atmospheric Neutrinos
• Atmospheric Neutrino Oscillations, theta(13) and Neutrino Mass Hierarchy
• Earth Matter Effects at Very Long Baselines and the Neutrino Mass Hierarchy
• Synergies between the first-generation JHF-SK and NuMI superbeam experiments
• Resolving Eight-Fold Neutrino Parameter Degeneracy by Two Identical Detectors with Different Baselines
• Resolving the octant of theta23 with T2K and NOvA
• A question of hierarchy: matter effects with atmospheric neutrinos and anti-neutrinos
• Three-Neutrino Oscillations of Atmospheric Neutrinos, theta13, Neutrino Mass Hierarchy and Iron Magnetized Detectors
• Measuring the deviation of the 2-3 lepton mixing from maximal with atmospheric neutrinos
• Probing the deviation from maximal mixing of atmospheric neutrinos
• Exploring Leptonic CP Violation by Reactor and Neutrino Superbeam Experiments
• Getting the best out of T2K and NOvA
• Off--axis Beams and Detector Clusters: Resolving Neutrino Parameter Degeneracies
• Potential of optimized NOvA for large theta(13) & combined performance with a LArTPC & T2K
• Solving the neutrino parameter degeneracy by measuring the T2K off-axis beam in Korea
• Untangling CP Violation and the Mass Hierarchy in Long Baseline Experiments
• How two neutrino superbeam experiments do better than one
• Medium effects for terrestrial and atmospheric neutrino oscillations
• The muon system of the Daya Bay Reactor antineutrino experiment
• Identifying the Neutrino mass Ordering with INO and NOvA
• Neutrino mass hierarchy and octant determination with atmospheric neutrinos
• A Simulations Study of the Muon Response of the Iron Calorimeter Detector at the India-based Neutrino Observatory
• Enhancing sensitivity to neutrino parameters at INO combining muon and hadron information
• Octant sensitivity for large theta(13) in atmospheric and long baseline neutrino experiments
• The Earth Mantle-Core Effect in Matter-Induced Asymmetries for Atmospheric Neutrino Oscillations
• Resolving theta_{23} Degeneracy by Accelerator and Reactor Neutrino Oscillation Experiments
• Interplay between Appearance and Disappearance Channels for Precision Measurements of ${\theta }_{23}$ and $\delta$
• Evidence for leptonic CP phase from NO$\nu$A, T2K and ICAL: A chronological progression
• What can we learn about the lepton CP phase in the next 10 years?
• Determining the Neutrino Mass Hierarchy and CP Violation in NOvA with a Second Off-Axis Detector
• The mass hierarchy with atmospheric neutrinos at INO
• Correlated, Precision Measurements of θ_{23} and $\delta$ using only the Electron Neutrino Appearance Experiments
• Can atmospheric neutrino experiments provide the first hint of leptonic CP violation?
• Measuring the Mass Hierarchy with Muon and Hadron Events in Atmospheric Neutrino Experiments
• Resolving the Mass Hierarchy with Atmospheric Neutrinos using a Liquid Argon Detector
• Unveiling Neutrino Mixing and Leptonic CP Violation
• Determining the Octant of ${\theta }_{23}$ with PINGU, T2K, NOvA and Reactor Data
• Probing the matter term at long baseline experiments
• Gain fractions of future neutrino oscillation facilities over T2K and NOvA

Cited by in corpus (38)

• Current unknowns in the three neutrino framework
• Neutrino oscillations: the rise of the PMNS paradigm
• New ambiguity in probing CP violation in neutrino oscillations
• Challenges posed by non-standard neutrino interactions in the determination of ${\delta }_{CP}$ at DUNE
• Correlations and degeneracies among the NSI parameters with tunable beams at DUNE
• Sensitivity to neutrino decay with atmospheric neutrinos at INO
• The physics of antineutrinos in DUNE and determination of octant and ${\delta }_{CP}$
• Complementarity Between Hyperkamiokande and DUNE in Determining Neutrino Oscillation Parameters
• Physics potential of the ESS$\nu$SB
• Effect of systematics in the T2HK, T2HKK, and DUNE experiments
• Probing CP violation with T2K, NO$\nu$A and DUNE in the presence of non-unitarity
• Effect of Non Unitarity on Neutrino Mass Hierarchy determination at DUNE, NO$\nu$A and T2K
• Imprints of scalar NSI on the CP-violation sensitivity using synergy among DUNE, T2HK and T2HKK
• Impact of high energy beam tunes on the sensitivities to the standard unknowns at DUNE
• A comparative study between ESSnuSB and T2HK in determining the leptonic CP phase
• Probing Lepton Flavor Models at Future Neutrino Experiments
• Study of parameter degeneracy and hierarchy sensitivity of NO$\nu$A in presence of sterile neutrino
• Probing muonic charged current nonstandard interactions at decay-at-rest facilities in conjunction with T2HK
• Reason for T2K to run in dominant neutrino mode for detecting CP violation
• Matter effects at the T2HK and T2HKK experiments
• Optimal configuration of Protvino to ORCA experiment for hierarchy and non-standard interactions
• Probing Light Mediators in the Radiative Emission of Neutrino Pair
• Here Comes the Sun: Solar Parameters in Long-Baseline Accelerator Neutrino Oscillations
• Octant Degeneracy, Quadrant of leptonic CPV phase at Long Baseline Neutrino Experiments and Baryogenesis
• Degeneracy resolution capabilities of NO$\nu$A and DUNE in the presence of light sterile neutrino
• On ${\theta }_{23}$ Octant Measurement in $3+1$ Neutrino Oscillations in T2HKK
• Neutrino Mass Ordering -- Circumventing the Challenges using Synergy between T2HK and JUNO
• A close look on 2-3 mixing angle with DUNE in light of current neutrino oscillation data
• Determining Neutrino Mass Ordering with ICAL, JUNO and T2HK
• Sensitivity study of Protvino to ORCA (P2O) experiment: Effect of antineutrino run, background and systematics
• Atmospheric Neutrinos: Status and Prospects
• Enhancing the sensitivity to neutrino oscillation parameters using synergy between T2K, NO$\nu$A and JUNO
• Effect of Matter Density in T2HK and DUNE
• Sensitivity of octant of ${\theta }_{23}$, CP violation and mass hierarchy in NO$\nu$A with multinucleon and detector effects
• Updated physics performance of the ESSnuSB experiment
• Majorana CP Violation Insights from Decaying Neutrinos
• Should T2K run in dominant neutrino mode to detect CP violation ?
• The Physics of antineutrinos in DUNE and resolution of octant degeneracy