25 Years of Self-Organized Criticality: Concepts and Controversies

Abstract

Introduced by the late Per Bak and his colleagues, self-organized criticality (SOC) has been one of the most stimulating concepts to come out of statistical mechanics and condensed matter theory in the last few decades, and has played a significant role in the development of complexity science. SOC, and more generally fractals and power laws, have attacted much comment, ranging from the very positive to the polemical. The other papers in this special issue (Aschwanden et al, 2014; McAteer et al, 2014; Sharma et al, 2015) showcase the considerable body of observations in solar, magnetospheric and fusion plasma inspired by the SOC idea, and expose the fertile role the new paradigm has played in approaches to modeling and understanding multiscale plasma instabilities. This very broad impact, and the necessary process of adapting a scientific hypothesis to the conditions of a given physical system, has meant that SOC as studied in these fields has sometimes differed significantly from the definition originally given by its creators. In Bak's own field of theoretical physics there are significant observational and theoretical open questions, even 25 years on (Pruessner, 2012). One aim of the present review is to address the dichotomy between the great reception SOC has received in some areas, and its shortcomings, as they became manifest in the controversies it triggered. Our article tries to clear up what we think are misunderstandings of SOC in fields more remote from its origins in statistical mechanics, condensed matter and dynamical systems by revisiting Bak, Tang and Wiesenfeld's original papers.

52 pages, 3 figures

References in corpus (59)

• Nonequilibrium Critical Phenomena and Phase Transitions into Absorbing States
• Emergent complex neural dynamics
• Universality classes in nonequilibrium lattice systems
• The Limited Scaling Range of Empirical Fractals
• Destruction of Anderson localization by a weak nonlinearity
• Does the 1/f frequency-scaling of brain signals reflect self-organized critical states?
• Critical phenomena in atmospheric precipitation
• Critical Percolation in Finite Geometries
• Power Laws in Solar Flares: Self-Organized Criticality or Turbulence?
• Universal scaling behavior of non-equilibrium phase transitions
• Paths to Self-Organized Criticality
• Avalanches, Barkhausen Noise, and Plain Old Criticality
• The abelian sandpile and related models
• Directed percolation criticality in turbulent liquid crystals
• Molecular motors robustly drive active gels to a critically connected state
• EUV Flare Activity in Late-Type Stars
• The universality class of absorbing phase transitions with a conserved field
• Self-organized criticality as an absorbing-state phase transition
• Tracer Dispersion in a Self-Organized Critical System
• Transport in Sand Piles, Interface Depinning, and Earthquake Models
• Driving, conservation and absorbing states in sandpiles
• Self-organization without conservation: true or just apparent scale-invariance?
• Forest fires and other examples of self-organized criticality
• Rare events and breakdown of simple scaling in the Abelian sandpile
• Numerical Determination of the Avalanche Exponents of the Bak-Tang-Wiesenfeld Model
• On possible experimental realizations of directed percolation
• Mapping Self-Organized Criticality onto Criticality
• Avalanche dynamics, surface roughening and self-organized criticality - experiments on a 3 dimensional pile of rice
• Critical behavior of a one-dimensional fixed-energy stochastic sandpile
• Height variables in the Abelian sandpile model: scaling fields and correlations
• Coexistence of Self-Organized Criticality and Intermittent Turbulence in the Solar Corona
• Sandpiles with height restrictions
• Broken scaling in the Forest Fire Model
• Universality Classes in Isotropic, Abelian and non-Abelian, Sandpile Models
• Adaptation to the Edge of Chaos in the Self-Adjusting Logistic Map
• A sandpile model with tokamak-like enhanced confinement phenomenology
• 25 Years of Self-Organized Criticality: Numerical Detection Methods
• Avalanche Merging and Continuous Flow in a Sandpile Model
• Theoretical Results for Sandpile Models of SOC with Multiple Topplings
• Large Scale Structures, Symmetry, and Universality in Sandpiles
• Abelian Manna model on various lattices in one and two dimensions
• Precise toppling balance, quenched disorder, and universality for sandpiles
• The Oslo rice pile model is a quenched Edwards-Wilkinson equation
• Scaling in the space climatology of the auroral indices: Is SOC the only possible explanation ?
• Avalanches and Self-Organized Criticality in Superconductors
• The four height variables, boundary correlations, and dissipative defects in the Abelian sandpile model
• Testing the SOC hypothesis for the magnetosphere
• A topological approximation of the nonlinear Anderson model
• Self-organized Criticality and Absorbing States: Lessons from the Ising Model
• Universality and a numerical ε-expansion of the Abelian Manna model below upper critical dimension
• SOC in a population model with global control
• A new, efficient algorithm for the Forest Fire Model
• Exact integration of height probabilities in the Abelian Sandpile Model
• A solvable non-conservative model of Self-Organized Criticality
• Exact solution of the totally asymmetric Oslo model
• Playing with sandpiles
• Connecting the Micro-dynamics to the Emergent Macro-variables: Self-Organized Criticality and Absorbing Phase Transitions in the Deterministic Lattice Gas
• Multiscaling in the sequence of areas enclosed by coalescing random walkers
• Anomalous Transport in Conical Granular Piles

Cited by in corpus (58)

• Colloquium: Criticality and dynamical scaling in living systems
• 25 Years of Self-Organized Criticality: Solar and Astrophysics
• Power-law size distributions in geoscience revisited
• Signatures of Self-Organised Criticality in an Ultracold Atomic Gas
• Predicting trends in the quality of state-of-the-art neural networks without access to training or testing data
• Feedback mechanisms for self-organization to the edge of a phase transition
• Universality in driven open quantum matter
• Self-Organized Criticality in Solar and Stellar Flares: Are Extreme Events Scale-Free ?
• Critical neuronal models with relaxed timescales separation
• Self-Organized Criticality and Pattern Emergence through the lens of Tropical Geometry
• Insights into the physics of neutron star interiors from pulsar glitches
• Evolutionary Dynamics of Social Inequality and Coincidence of Gini and Kolkata indices under Unrestricted Competition
• Universality in spectral condensation
• Sandpile Universality in Social Inequality: Gini and Kolkata Measures
• Phase transition, scaling of moments, and order-parameter distributions in Brownian particles and branching processes with finite-size effects
• Simulating pulsar glitches: an $N$-body solver for superfluid vortex motion in two dimensions
• Quasistatic kinetic avalanches and self-organized criticality in deviatorically loaded granular media
• Linking space-time correlations for a class of self-organized critical systems
• Superconducting phase transition reveals an electromagnetic coupling to a scalar field potential that generates mechanical work
• Self Organized Criticality in a two dimensional Cellular Automaton model of a magnetic flux tube with background flow
• Density relaxation in conserved Manna sandpiles
• $1/\phi$ Spectrum of the Stress Dynamics with the Bak-Tang-Wiesenfeld Sandpile
• Criticality or Supersymmetry Breaking ?
• Effects of Turbulent Environment and Random Noise on Self-Organized Critical Behavior: Universality vs Nonuniversality
• The Emergence of Weak Criticality in SOC systems
• Effects of turbulent environment on self-organized critical behavior: Isotropy vs Anisotropy
• Fractal analyses of networks of integrate-and-fire stochastic spiking neurons
• Self-Organized Higgs Criticality
• Tail of the distribution of fatalities in epidemics
• Ubiquitous order known as chaos
• Controlling excitation avalanches in driven Rydberg gases
• Evolving Powergrids in Self-Organized Criticality: An analogy with Sandpile and Earthquakes
• Adaptation to criticality through organizational invariance in embodied agents
• Description of mesoscale pattern formation in shallow convective cloud fields by using time-dependent Ginzburg-Landau and Swift-Hohenberg stochastic equations
• Renormalization group analysis of a self-organized critical system: Intrinsic anisotropy vs random environment
• $1/x$ Probability Distribution in a Close Proximity of the Bak-Tang-Wiesenfeld Sandpile
• Percolation with trapping mechanism drives active gels to the critically connected state
• Correlation Functions of Photospheric Magnetic Fields in Solar Active Regions
• From Boltzmann to Zipf through Shannon and Jaynes
• A New Approach to Solar Flare Prediction
• Dimensional transmutation and nonconventional scaling behaviour in a model of self-organized criticality
• Can biological quantum networks solve NP-hard problems?
• The Pedagogical Representation of Mass Functions with LEGO and their Origin
• Delegated Causality of Complex Systems
• Mandelbrot's 1/f fractional renewal models of 1963-67: The non-ergodic missing link between change points and long range dependence
• Emergence of oscillations in fixed energy sandpile models on complex networks
• Expanding and Self-Organizing 2D Universe Models Emerging from Frozen Trivalent Spin Networks
• Measuring complexity
• Criticality Analysis: Bio-inspired Nonlinear Data Representation
• Temperature-activated dislocation avalanches signaling brittle-to-ductile transition in BCC micropillars
• von Karman - Howarth Similarity of Spatial Correlations and the Distribution of Correlation Lengths in Solar Photospheric Turbulence
• Time path of turbulence and multi-fractality of magnetic field in the evolution of an active region
• Nearly Tight Bounds for Sandpile Transience on the Grid
• Forecasting Solar Flares by Data Assimilation in Sandpile Models
• Topological Field Theory and Stochastic Dynamics
• A Spiking Neural Dynamical Drift-Diffusion Model on Collective Decision Making with Self-Organized Criticality
• Ergodic Concepts for a Self-Organizing Trivalent Spin Network: A Path to $(2+1)$-dimensional Black Hole Entropy
• An extension of the Ising-Curie-Weiss model of self-organized criticality with a threshold on the interaction range