Reappraisal of the limit on the variation in $\alpha$ implied by Oklo

Abstract

We reconsider the analysis of the sensitivity of neutron resonance energies $E_i$ to changes in $\alpha$ with a view to resolving uncertainties that plague earlier treatments. We point out that, with more appropriate choices of nuclear parameters, the standard estimate (due to Damour and Dyson) of the sensitivity for resonances in ${}^{150}$Sm is increased by a factor of 2.5. We go on to identify and compute excitation, Coulomb and deformation corrections. To this end, we use deformed Fermi density distributions fitted to the output of Hartree-Fock (HF) + BCS calculations (with both the SLy4 and SkM${}^{\ast }$ Skyrme functionals), the energetics of the surface diffuseness of nuclei, and thermal properties of their deformation. We also invoke the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis, performing the requisite microcanonical averages with two phenomenological level densities which, via the leptodermous expansion of the level density parameter, include the effect of increased surface diffuseness. Theoretical uncertainties are assessed with the \emph{inter-model} prescription of Dobaczewski et al. [J. Phys. G: Nucl. Part. Phys. {\bf 41}, 074001 (2014)]. The corrections diminish the revised ${}^{150}$Sm sensitivity but not by more than 25\%. Subject to a weak and testable restriction on the change in $m_q/\Lambda$ (relative to the change in $\alpha$) since the time when the Oklo reactors were active ($m_q$ is the average of the $\text{u}$ and $\text{d}$ current quark masses, and $\Lambda$ is the mass scale of quantum chromodynamics), we deduce that $|{\alpha }_{\text{Oklo}}-{\alpha }_{\text{now}}|<1.1\times 10^{-8}{\alpha }_{\text{now}}$ (95\% confidence level). The corresponding bound on the present-day time variation of $\alpha$ is tighter than the best limit to date from atomic clock experiments.

Changes to text and abstract (dealing with confidence intervals), some references added (9 pages)

References in corpus (27)

• Beyond the Cosmological Standard Model
• Frequency ratio of two optical clock transitions in ${}^{171}$Yb${}^{+}$ and constraints on the time-variation of fundamental constants
• Improved limit on a temporal variation of $m_p/m_e$ from comparisons of Yb${}^{+}$ and Cs atomic clocks
• Error Estimates of Theoretical Models: a Guide
• Spatial variation in the fine-structure constant -- new results from VLT/UVES
• Coupled Variations of Fundamental Couplings and Primordial Nucleosynthesis
• Impact of instrumental systematic errors on fine-structure constant measurements with quasar spectra
• Analysis of bulk and surface contributions in the neutron skin of nuclei
• Time-variability of alpha from realistic models of Oklo reactors
• The UVES Large Program for testing fundamental physics - III. Constraints on the fine-structure constant from 3 telescopes
• Reconstructing the dark energy equation of state with varying couplings
• Enhanced effect of quark mass variation in 229Th and limits from Oklo data
• D-BIonic Screening of Scalar Fields
• Late-time cosmology of scalar-tensor theories with universal multiplicative coupling between the scalar field and the matter Lagrangian
• Evolution of the fine-structure constant in runaway dilaton models
• Polarization of the nuclear surface in deformed nuclei
• Dark Energy coupling with electromagnetism as seen from future low-medium redshift probes
• Fundamental cosmology in the E-ELT era: The status and future role of tests of fundamental coupling stability
• Varying Alpha: New Constraints from Seasonal Variations
• Consistency tests of the stability of fundamental couplings and unification scenarios
• Unifying cosmological and recent time variations of fundamental couplings
• Influence of the single-particle structure on the nuclear surface and the neutron skin
• Oklo reactors and implications for nuclear science
• Fundamental Cosmology from Precision Spectroscopy: I. Varying Couplings
• Fine-structure constant constraints on Bekenstein-type models
• Variations of the fine-structure constant $\alpha$ in exotic singularity models
• Implications of the Oklo phenomenon in a chiral approach to nuclear matter

Cited by in corpus (8)

• Euclid: constraining dark energy coupled to electromagnetism using astrophysical and laboratory data
• The variation of the fine-structure constant from disformal couplings
• Fine-structure transitions as a tool for studying variation of alpha at high redshifts
• [CI], [CII] and CO emission lines as a probe for alpha variations at low and high redshifts
• Constraining fundamental parameters in modified gravity using Gaia-DR2 massive white dwarf observation
• Variation of fundamental constants and white dwarfs
• Effect of temperature on measurement of fundamental constants using white dwarfs in Gaia-EDR3 survey
• Refining fundamental constants with white dwarfs: machine learning informed constraints on fine-structure constant and proton-to-electron mass ratio