Energy in first order 2+1 gravity
arXiv:1503.03030 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.92.044040
Abstract
We consider =0 three dimensional gravity with asymptotically flat boundary conditions. This system was studied by Ashtekar and Varadarajan within the second order formalism -with metric variables- who showed that the Regge-Teitelboim formalism yields a consistent Hamiltonian description where, surprisingly, the energy is bounded from below and from above. The energy of the spacetime is, however, determined up to an arbitrary constant. The natural choice was to fix that freedom such that Minkowski spacetime has zero energy. More recently, Marolf and Patiño started from the Einstein-Hilbert action supplemented with the Gibbons-Hawking term and showed that, in the 2+1 decomposition of the theory, the energy is shifted from the Ashtekar-Varadarajan analysis in such a way that Minkowski spacetime possesses a negative energy. In this contribution we consider the first order formalism, where the fundamental variables are a so(2,1) connection and a triad . We consider two actions. A natural extension to 3 dimensions of the consistent action in 4D Palatini gravity is shown to be finite and differentiable. For this action, the 2+1 decomposition (that we perform using two methods) yields a Hamiltonian boundary term that corresponds to energy. It assigns zero energy to Minkowski spacetime. We then put forward a totally gauge invariant action, and show that it is also well defined and differentiable. Interestingly, it turns out to be related, on shell, to the 3D Palatini action by an additive constant in such a way that its associated energy is given by the Marolf-Patiño expression. Thus, we conclude that, from the perspective of the first order formalism, Minkowski spacetime can consistently have either, zero, or a negative energy equal to -1/4G, depending on the choice of consistent action employed as starting point.
arXiv comment36 pages, typos corrected, references added
References in corpus (21)
- The Dynamics of General Relativity
- Classical central extension for asymptotic symmetries at null infinity in three spacetime dimensions
- The flat limit of three dimensional asymptotically anti-de Sitter spacetimes
- Asymptotic Structure of Symmetry Reduced General Relativity
- Holographic Renormalization of Asymptotically Flat Spacetimes
- Energy-Momentum Conservation in General Relativity
- Gravitational collapse in 2+1 dimensional AdS spacetime
- Large quantum gravity effects: Unexpected limitations of the classical theory
- A Striking Property of the Gravitational Hamiltonian
- Vortices in holographic superfluids and superconductors as conformal defects
- Variational principle and 1-point functions in 3-dimensional flat space Einstein gravity
- Geometrodynamics vs. Connection Dynamics
- Asymptotics and Hamiltonians in a First order formalism
- On boundary conditions in three-dimensional AdS gravity
- Imaginary action, spinfoam asymptotics and the 'transplanckian' regime of loop quantum gravity
- Hamiltonian and Noether charges in first order gravity
- Surface terms, Asymptotics and Thermodynamics of the Holst Action
- On a spacetime duality in 2+1 gravity
- The non-zero energy of 2+1 Minkowski space
- Energy Theorem for 2+1 dimensional gravity
- The Phase Space of 2+1 Dimensional Gravity in the Ashtekar Formulation
Cited by in corpus (8)
- Lorentz-diffeomorphism edge modes in 3d gravity
- The gravitational Hamiltonian, first order action, Poincaré charges and surface terms
- The point-particle solution and the asymptotic flatness in 2+1 Horava gravity
- Chern-Simons Gravity Dual of BCFT
- Vacuum energy in asymptotically flat 2+1 gravity
- Towards quantum gravity with neural networks: Solving quantum Hamilton constraints of 3d Euclidean gravity in the weak coupling limit
- Constructing the theory at the boundary, its dynamics and degrees of freedom
- Boundary terms, branes and AdS/BCFT in first-order gravity