Nature or nurture of coplanar Tatooines: the aligned circumbinary Kuiper belt analogue around HD 131511

Abstract

A key discovery of the Kepler mission is of the circumbinary planets known as "Tatooines", which appear to be well aligned with their host stars' orbits. Whether this alignment is due to initially coplanar circumbinary planet-forming discs (i.e. nature), or subsequent alignment of initially misaligned discs by warping the inner disc or torquing the binary (i.e. nurture), is not known. Tests of which scenario dominates may be possible by observing circumbinary Kuiper belt analogues ("debris discs"), which trace the plane of the primordial disc. Here, the 140 au diameter circumbinary debris disc around HD 131511 is shown to be aligned to within 10${}^{\circ }$ of the plane of the near edge-on 0.2 au binary orbit. The stellar equator is also consistent with being in this plane. If the primordial disc was massive enough to pull the binary into alignment, this outcome should be common and distinguishing nature versus nurture will be difficult. However, if only the inner disc becomes aligned with the binary, the HD 131511 system was never significantly misaligned. Given an initial misalignment, the $\sim$Gyr main-sequence lifetime of the star allows secular perturbations to align the debris disc out to 100 au at the cost of an increased scale height. The observed debris disc scale height limits any misalignment to less than 25${}^{\circ }$. With only a handful known, many more such systems need to be characterised to help test whether the alignment of circumbinary planets is nature or nurture.

arXiv commentAccepted to MNRAS Letters

References in corpus (32)

• Herschel Space Observatory - An ESA facility for far-infrared and submillimetre astronomy
• The Photodetector Array Camera and Spectrometer (PACS) on the Herschel Space Observatory
• Improved Age Estimation for Solar-Type Dwarfs Using Activity-Rotation Diagnostics
• Kepler-16: A Transiting Circumbinary Planet
• Radial Velocities for 889 Late-type Stars
• Discovery of a Cool Planet of 5.5 Earth Masses Through Gravitational Microlensing
• Contributions to the Nearby Stars (NStars) Project: Spectroscopy of Stars Earlier than M0 within 40 parsecs: The Northern Sample I
• A Planetary Companion to gamma Cephei A
• A planet on an inclined orbit as an explanation of the warp in the Beta Pictoris disk
• Observational Implications of Precessing Protostellar Discs and Jets
• High inclination orbits in the secular quadrupolar three-body problem
• Wave-like warp propagation in circumbinary discs I. Analytic theory and numerical simulations
• The Collisional Evolution of Debris Disks
• How not to build Tatooine: the difficulty of in situ formation of circumbinary planets Kepler 16b, Kepler 34b and Kepler 35b
• Formation and Evolution of Planetary Systems: Upper Limits to the Gas Mass in Disks Around Sun-like Stars
• On the Abundance of Circumbinary Planets
• 99 Herculis: Host to a Circumbinary Polar-ring Debris Disk
• A Far-ultraviolet Atlas of Low-resolution Hubble Space Telescope Spectra of T Tauri Stars
• Relative velocities among accreting planetesimals in binary systems: the circumbinary case
• HD 98800: A 10-Myr-Old Transition Disk
• Astrometric orbits of SB9 stars
• Truncated Disks in TW Hya Association Multiple Star Systems
• High Inclination Planets in Multistellar Systems
• Coplanar Circumbinary Debris Disks
• Alignment in star-debris disc systems seen by Herschel
• Linear and non-linear theory of a parametric instability of hydrodynamic warps in Keplerian discs
• The Radial Velocity TATOOINE Search for Circumbinary Planets: Planet Detection Limits for a Sample of Double-lined Binary Stars - Initial Results from Keck I/Hires, Shane/CAT/Hamspec and TNG/Sarg Observations
• Precision radial velocities of double-lined spectroscopic binaries with an iodine absorption cell
• Assembly of Protoplanetary Disks and Inclinations of Circumbinary Planets
• The circumbinary disk of HD 98800 B: Evidence for disk warping
• HD 98800: A most unusual debris disc
• Interpreting the extended emission around three nearby debris disc host stars

Cited by in corpus (5)

• The Degree of Alignment Between Circumbinary Disks and Their Binary Hosts
• Planet populations inferred from debris discs: insights from 178 debris systems in the ISPY, LEECH and LIStEN planet-hunting surveys
• On the frequencies of circumbinary discs in protostellar systems
• On the Estimation of Circumbinary Orbital Properties
• Glancing through the debris disk: Photometric analysis of DE Boo with CHEOPS