Limitations of unconstrained LSDA+$U$ calculations in predicting the electronic and magnetic ground state of a geometrically frustrated ZnV${}_2$O${}_4$ compound

Abstract

In the present work, we investigate the applicability of the LSDA+$U$ method in understanding the electronic and magnetic properties of a geometrically frustrated ZnV${}_2$O${}_4$ compound, where the delicate balance of electrons, lattice, orbital and spin interactions play an important role in deciding its physical properties. In the ferromagnetic solution of the compound, only one type of orbital solution is found to exist in all ranges of $U$ studied here. However, in antiferromagnetic (AFM) phase, two types of orbital solutions, AFM(OS1) and AFM(OS2), exist for $U>$3 eV. If the difference of the electronic occupancy of $d_{xz}$ and $d_{yz}$ orbitals is less than 0.25, then AFM(OS1) solution is stabilized, whereas for higher values AFM(OS2) solution is stabilized. The use of unconstrained calculations within the fully localized double counting scheme is unable to predict the AFM ground state for $U⩽$3 eV. Our results clearly suggest the importance of constrained calculations in understanding the electronic and magnetic properties of a compound, where various competing interactions are present. In the AFM solution, the orbital ground state of the compound changes with varying $U$, where AFM(OS1) is found to be the ground state for $U⩽$3 eV and for higher values of $U$, AFM(OS2) is the ground state. The analysis of the band gap suggests that the AFM(OS2) is the real ground state of the compound.

23 pages, 7 figures, 2 tables

References in corpus (13)

• Restoring the density-gradient expansion for exchange in solids and surfaces
• Generalized gradient approximation for solids and their surfaces
• Structural, orbital, and magnetic order in vanadium spinels
• Magnetic transition and orbital degrees of freedom in vanadium spinels
• Spin and Orbital Order of the Vanadium Spinel MgV2O4
• Orbital order in ZnV${}_2$O${}_4$
• Orbital and magnetic transitions in geometrically-frustrated vanadium spinels -- Monte Carlo study of an effective spin-orbital-lattice coupled model --
• Enhanced Pressure Dependence of Magnetic Exchange in A2+[V2]O4 Spinels Approaching the Itinerant Electron Limit
• Orbital order in vanadium spinels
• Orbital ordering in the geometrically frustrated MgV${}_2$O${}_4$: \emph{Ab initio} electronic structure calculations
• Effect of pressure on the electronic and magnetic properties of CdV${}_2$O${}_4$: Density functional theory studies
• Orbital disorder induced by charge fluctuations in vanadium spinels
• Density matrix approach to the orbital ordering in the spinel vanadates: A case study

Cited by in corpus (4)

• Constrained DFT+$U$ approach for understanding the magnetic behaviour of ACr${}_2$O${}_4$ (A=Zn, Mg, Cd and Hg) compounds
• Self-consistent evaluation of effective Coulomb interaction of V atom and its importance to understand the comparative electronic behaviour of vanadium spinels
• Electronic structure study of vanadium spinels by using density functional theory and dynamical mean field theory
• The role of ionic sizes in inducing the cubic to tetragonal distortion in AV${}_2$O${}_4$ and ACr${}_2$O${}_4$ (A=Zn, Mg and Cd) compounds