Investigating the Minimum Energy Principle in Searches for New Molecular Species - the Case of H${}_2$C${}_3$O Isomers

Abstract

Recently, Lattelais et al. (2009) have interpreted aggregated observations of molecular isomers to suggest that there exists a "minimum energy principle'', such that molecular formation will favor more stable molecular isomers for thermodynamic reasons. To test the predictive power of this principle, we have fully characterized the spectra of the three isomers of C${}_3$H${}_2$O toward the well known molecular region Sgr B2(N). Evidence for the detection of the isomers cyclopropenone (c-C${}_3$H${}_2$O) and propynal (HCCCHO) is presented, along with evidence for the non-detection of the lowest zero-point energy isomer, propadienone (CH${}_2$CCO). We interpret these observations as evidence that chemical formation pathways, which may be under kinetic control, have a more pronounced effect on final isomer abundances than thermodynamic effects such as the minimum energy principle.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in ApJ, 11 pages, 6 figures

References in corpus (15)

• Complex Chemistry in Star-Forming Regions: An Expanded Gas-Grain Warm-up Chemical Model
• Complex organic molecules in the interstellar medium: IRAM 30 m line survey of Sagittarius B2(N) and (M)
• Detection of HCN, HCO+ and HNC in the Mrk231 molecular outflow - Dense molecular gas in the AGN wind
• Herschel observations of EXtra-Ordinary Sources: Analysis of the HIFI 1.2 THz Wide Spectral Survey Toward Orion KL I. Methods
• Detection of E-cyanomethanimine towards Sagittarius B2(N) in the Green Bank Telescope PRIMOS Survey
• The Detection of Interstellar Ethanimine (CH3CHNH) from Observations taken during the GBT PRIMOS Survey
• The HNC/HCN Ratio in Star-Forming Regions
• Herschel observations of EXtraordinary Sources: Analysis of the full Herschel/HIFI molecular line survey of Sagittarius B2(N)
• Laboratory and tentative interstellar detection of trans-methyl formate using the publicly available Green Bank Telescope PRIMOS survey
• Three-dimensional off-lattice Monte Carlo kinetics simulations of interstellar grain chemistry and ice structure
• Hydrogen cyanide and isocyanide in prestellar cores
• The rotational excitation of HCN and HNC by He: New insights on the HCN/HNC abundance ratio in molecular clouds
• Weak maser emission of methyl formate toward Sagittarius B2(N) in the Green Bank Telescope PRIMOS Survey
• A Search for l-C3H+ and l-C3H in Sgr B2(N), Sgr B2(OH), and the Dark Cloud TMC-1
• Non-Thermal Continuum toward SGRB2(N-LMH)

Cited by in corpus (21)

• Discovery of the Interstellar Chiral Molecule Propylene Oxide (CH${}_3$CHCH${}_2$O)
• Rotational spectroscopy, tentative interstellar detection, and chemical modelling of N-methylformamide
• The interstellar chemistry of C3H and C3H2 isomers
• The interstellar chemistry of H2C3O isomers
• Aromatics and Cyclic Molecules in Molecular Clouds: A New Dimension of Interstellar Organic Chemistry
• The Case of H${}_2$C${}_3$O Isomers, Revisited: Solving the Mystery of the Missing Propadienone
• Detection of Interstellar HC${}_5$O in TMC-1 with the Green Bank Telescope
• Isomers in Interstellar Environments (I): The Case of Z- and E-Cyanomethanimine
• First detection in space of the high-energy isomer of cyanomethanimine: H2CNCN
• The origin of the E/Z isomer ratio of imines in the interstellar medium
• Molecular Polymorphism: Microwave Spectra, Equilibrium Structures, and an Astronomical Investigation of the HNCS Isomeric Family
• ALMA Observations of the Spatial Distribution of three C${}_2$H${}_4$O${}_2$ Isomers towards Sgr B2(N)
• Diastereoselective Formation of trans-HC(O)SH Through Hydrogenation of OCS on Interstellar Dust Grains
• Hydrogen abstraction reactions in formic and thioformic acid isomers by hydrogen and deuterium atoms. Insights on isomerism and deuteration
• Submillimeter spectroscopy and astronomical searches of vinyl mercaptan, C${}_2$H${}_3$SH
• Searches for Interstellar HCCSH and H${}_2$CCS
• A sequential acid-base (SAB) mechanism in the interstellar medium: The emergence of cis formic acid in dark molecular clouds
• Constraints of the formation and abundances of methyl carbamate, a glycine isomer, in hot corinos
• Piecing together formic acid isomerism in dark clouds. Detection of cis-formic acid in TMC-1 and astrochemical modeling
• Expanding the C${}_3$H${}_6$O${}_2$ Isomeric Interstellar Inventory: Discovery of Lactaldehyde and Methoxyacetaldehyde in G+0.693-0.027
• 3-Methoxy-1-propanol Rotational Spectroscopy and Radio Astronomical Search toward NGC 6334I