On the accuracy of the optical determination of the proton charge radius

Abstract

Determination of the proton charge radius by different methods has produced an inconsistency. The most precise value (from spectroscopy of muonic hydrogen) strongly disagrees with three less accurate values (from spectroscopy of ordinary hydrogen and deuterium, from relative measurements of the cross section of the elastic electron-proton scattering at MAMI and from evaluation of the world data on absolute measurements of e-p cross sections). Here, we question the accuracy of the determination of the proton charge radius by means of spectroscopy of ordinary hydrogen and deuterium and demonstrate that its accuracy was probably overestimated. In particular, we revisit determination from each relevant transition and find that the results of two optical experiments, which are the most statistically important, are not perfectly consistent. The inconsistency is rather a `tension' between the results than their discrepancy, however, it implies that a more conservative estimation of the uncertainty is needed. With the more realistic estimation of the uncertainty, the results for the proton charge radius from spectroscopy of ordinary and muonic atoms are rather in fair agreement.

References in corpus (9)

• CODATA Recommended Values of the Fundamental Physical Constants: 2010
• High-precision determination of the electric and magnetic form factors of the proton
• New Limits to the Drift of Fundamental Constants from Laboratory Measurements
• Improved Measurement of the Hydrogen 1S - 2S Transition Frequency
• Precision physics of simple atoms: QED tests, nuclear structure and fundamental constants
• On the rms-radius of the proton
• The Lamb Shift of Excited S-Levels in Hydrogen and Deuterium Atoms
• Optical frequency measurement of the 1S-3S two-photon transition in hydrogen
• A self-consistent value of the electric radius of the proton from the Lamb shift in muonic hydrogen

Cited by in corpus (7)

• A tabulation of the bound-state energies of atomic hydrogen
• Nuclear structure corrections to the Lamb shift in ${\mu }^3$He${}^{+}$ and ${\mu }^3$H
• The Triton Charge Radius to Next-to-next-to-leading order in Pionless Effective Field Theory
• Virtual Delbrück scattering and the Lamb shift in light hydrogen-like atoms
• Master equation for high-precision spectroscopy
• Angular correlations in two-photon spectroscopy of hydrogen
• Towards a spectroscopically accurate set of potentials for heavy hydride laser cooling candidates: effective core potential calculations of BaH