Thermality of the Hawking flux
arXiv:1409.7754 · doi:10.1007/JHEP07(2015)009
Abstract
Is the Hawking flux "thermal"? Unfortunately, the answer to this seemingly innocent question depends on a number of often unstated, but quite crucial, technical assumptions built into modern (mis-)interpretations of the word "thermal". The original 1850's notions of thermality --- based on classical thermodynamic reasoning applied to idealized "black bodies" or "lamp black surfaces" --- when supplemented by specific basic quantum ideas from the early 1900's, immediately led to the notion of the black-body spectrum, (the Planck-shaped spectrum), but "without" any specific assumptions or conclusions regarding correlations between the quanta. Many (not all) modern authors (often implicitly and unintentionally) add an extra, and quite unnecessary, assumption that there are no correlations in the black-body radiation; but such usage is profoundly ahistorical and dangerously misleading. Specifically, the Hawking flux from an evaporating black hole, (just like the radiation flux from a leaky furnace or a burning lump of coal), is only "approximately" Planck-shaped over a bounded frequency range. Standard physics (phase space and adiabaticity effects) explicitly bound the frequency range over which the Hawking flux is "approximately" Planck-shaped from both above and below --- the Hawking flux is certainly not exactly Planckian, and there is no compelling physics reason to assume the Hawking photons are uncorrelated.
arXiv commentV1: 13 pages. V2: Now 17 pages. 3 references added; other references updated; new section on the relationship between past and future null infinity; small edits throughout the text. V3: Now 19 pages. 4 more references added; extra discussion/small edits. No physics changes
References in corpus (45)
- Hawking Radiation as Tunneling
- Black Holes: Complementarity or Firewalls?
- Formation and evaporation of non-singular black holes
- Analogue Gravity
- Acoustic black holes: horizons, ergospheres, and Hawking radiation
- Measurement of stimulated Hawking emission in an analogue system
- Better Late than Never: Information Retrieval from Black Holes
- An Apologia for Firewalls
- Observation of self-amplifying Hawking radiation in an analog black hole laser
- Black hole evaporation: A paradigm
- Analog gravity from Bose-Einstein condensates
- Dirty blackholes: Thermodynamics and horizon structure
- Probing semiclassical analogue gravity in Bose--Einstein condensates with widely tunable interactions
- Information loss problem and a `black hole' model with a closed apparent horizon
- Bounding the greybody factors for Schwarzschild black holes
- Hawking radiation without black hole entropy
- Information Preservation and Weather Forecasting for Black Holes
- Minimal conditions for the existence of a Hawking-like flux
- Towards the observation of Hawking radiation in Bose--Einstein condensates
- Virtual Black Holes
- Conservative solutions to the black hole information problem
- Complementarity Is Not Enough
- Hawking-like radiation from evolving black holes and compact horizonless objects
- Nonviolent nonlocality
- Physical observability of horizons
- Hawking-like radiation does not require a trapped region
- Comments on black holes I: The possibility of complementarity
- Acoustic propagation in fluids: an unexpected example of Lorentzian geometry
- Causal structure of acoustic spacetimes
- Radiation from a collapsing object is manifestly unitary
- Complementarity Endures: No Firewall for an Infalling Observer
- Regge-Wheeler equation, linear stability, and greybody factors for dirty black holes
- Passing through the Firewall
- Black hole evaporation without an event horizon
- Holographic Space-Time Does Not Predict Firewalls
- Black holes without firewalls
- Global Structure of Evaporating Black Holes
- Classical aspects of Hawking radiation verified in analogue gravity experiment
- Comment on the black hole firewall
- Survey of analogue spacetimes
- The disinformation problem for black holes (conference version)
- How Black Holes Burn
- Firewalls, smoke and mirrors
- Hawking radiation: a particle physics perspective
- A Massless Firewall
Cited by in corpus (26)
- Observation of thermal Hawking radiation at the Hawking temperature in an analogue black hole
- The Hawking cascade from a black hole is extremely sparse
- Black Holes: Eliminating Information or Illuminating New Physics?
- Signatures of Energy Flux in Particle Production: A Black Hole Birth Cry and Death Gasp
- Entropy budget for Hawking evaporation
- Entropy/information flux in Hawking radiation
- Information retrieval from black holes
- Coarse graining Shannon and von Neumann entropies
- Extracting information about the initial state from the black hole radiation
- On burning a lump of coal
- Hawking radiation is corpuscular
- Particle creation rate for dynamical black holes
- Nonthermal acceleration radiation of atoms near a black hole in presence of dark energy
- Discrete quantum spectrum of black holes
- Multi-partite analysis of average-subsystem entropies
- Quantum information in Hawking radiation
- Sparsity of the Hawking flux
- Lectures in Quantum Gravity
- Total spectral distributions from Hawking radiation
- Decoding infrared imprints of quantum origins of black holes
- Atom-field dynamics in curved spacetime
- Evading the Trans-Planckian problem with Vaidya spacetimes
- Seeing through a nearly black star
- On the assumptions leading to the information loss paradox
- From mindless mathematics to thinking meat?
- On the nature of the black hole information problem