Sensitivity of predictions in an effective model -- application to the chiral critical end point position in the Nambu--Jona-Lasinio model

Abstract

The measurement of the position of the chiral critical end point (CEP) in the QCD phase diagram is under debate. While it is possible to predict its position by using effective models specifically built to reproduce some of the features of the underlying theory (QCD), the quality of the predictions (\textit{e.g.}, the CEP position) obtained by such effective models, depends on whether solving the model equations constitute a well- or ill-posed inverse problem. Considering these predictions as being inverse problems provides tools to evaluate if the problem is ill-conditioned, meaning that infinitesimal variations of the inputs of the model can cause comparatively large variations of the predictions. If it is ill-conditioned, it has major consequences because of finite variations that could come from experimental and/or theoretical errors. In the following, we shall apply such a reasoning on the predictions of a particular Nambu--Jona-Lasinio model within the mean field + ring approximations, with special attention to the prediction of the chiral CEP position in the $(T-\mu )$ plane. We find that the problem is ill-conditioned (\idest very sensitive to input variations) for the $T$-coordinate of the CEP, whereas, it is well-posed for the $\mu$-coordinate of the CEP. As a consequence, when the chiral condensate varies in a $10$ MeV range, ${\mu }_{CEP}$ varies far less. As an illustration to understand how problematic this could be, we show that the main consequence when taking into account finite variation of the inputs, is that the existence of the CEP itself cannot be predicted anymore: for a deviation as low as 0.6 \% with respect to vacuum phenomenology (well within the estimation of the first correction to the ring approximation) the CEP may or may not exist.

Improved version: slightly modified title, the introduction of the sensitivity was improved; reformulation of the sections; v2 with 20 pages and only 9 figures. Version accepted for publication in EPJA

References in corpus (13)

• The QCD equation of state with dynamical quarks
• The Phase Structure of the Polyakov--Quark-Meson Model
• Error Estimates of Theoretical Models: a Guide
• The phase structure of the Polyakov--quark-meson model beyond mean field
• The phase boundary for the chiral transition in (2+1)-flavor QCD at small values of the chemical potential
• The chiral and deconfinement crossover transitions: PNJL model beyond mean field
• Critical endpoint in the Polyakov-loop extended NJL model
• Observation of the critical end point in the phase diagram for hot and dense nuclear matter
• The Hot QCD White Paper: Exploring the Phases of QCD at RHIC and the LHC
• The QCD critical end point in the PNJL model
• Error analysis of nuclear mass fits
• The QCD critical end point in the SU(3) Nambu--Jona-Lasinio model
• Signature of QCD critical point: Anomalous transverse velocity dependence of antiproton-proton ratio

Cited by in corpus (4)

• Phase diagram and nucleation in the Polyakov-loop-extended Quark-Meson truncation of QCD with the unquenched Polyakov-loop potential
• A Bayesian analysis of the properties of hybrid stars with the NJL model
• Quark and Polyakov-loop correlations in effective models at zero and non-vanishing density
• Phase Diagram, Scalar-Pseudoscalar Meson Behavior and Restoration of Symmetries in (2+1) Polyakov-Nambu-Jona-Lasinio Model