A simple model for multiple-choice collective decision making

Abstract

We describe a simple model of heterogeneous, interacting agents making decisions between $n\ge 2$ discrete choices. For a special class of interactions, our model is the mean field description of random-field Potts-like models, and is effectively solved by finding the extrema of the average energy $E$ per agent. In these cases, by studying the propagation of decision changes via avalanches, we argue that macroscopic dynamics is well-captured by a gradient flow along $E$. We focus on the permutation-symmetric case, where all $n$ choices are (on average) the same, and spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) arises purely from cooperative social interactions. As examples, we show that bimodal heterogeneity naturally provides a mechanism for the spontaneous formation of hierarchies between decisions, and that SSB is a preferred instability to discontinuous phase transitions between two symmetric points. Beyond the mean field limit, exponentially many stable equilibria emerge when we place this model on a graph of finite mean degree. We conclude with speculation on decision making with persistent collective oscillations. Throughout the paper, we emphasize analogies between methods of solution to our model and common intuition from diverse areas of physics, including statistical physics and electromagnetism.

1+18 pages (main text) + 12 pages (appendices/references). 8 + 3 figures. v2: more references, a couple more comments/explanations and a short new section on finite size effects added

References in corpus (28)

• The structure and function of complex networks
• Statistical physics of social dynamics
• Theory of Phase Ordering Kinetics
• A model for cascading failures in complex networks
• Social Influence and the Collective Dynamics of Opinion Formation
• Failure Processes in Elastic Fiber Bundles
• Agent-based Models of Financial Markets
• Phase Transitions in the Coloring of Random Graphs
• Is the Voter Model a model for voters?
• Rational Group Decision Making. A random field Ising model at T=0
• Crises and collective socio-economic phenomena: simple models and challenges
• Exponential decay properties of Wannier functions and related quantities
• Endogenous Versus Exogenous Shocks in Complex Networks: an Empirical Test Using Book Sale Ranking
• Oscillatory Dynamics in Rock-Paper-Scissors Games with Mutations
• Theory of collective opinion shifts: from smooth trends to abrupt swings
• Modelling diffusion of innovations in a social network
• Coarsening in the q-State Potts Model and the Ising Model with Globally Conserved Magnetization
• Universality Class of Fiber Bundle Model on Complex Networks
• Election turnout statistics in many countries: similarities, differences, and a diffusive field model for decision-making
• Spatial correlations in vote statistics: a diffusive field model for decision-making
• A statistical mechanics model for the emergence of consensus
• Universality in movie rating distributions
• Modelling the Spatial Dynamics of Culture Spreading in the Presence of Cultural Strongholds
• On the emergence of an "intention field" for socially cohesive agents
• Multistable binary decision making on networks
• A maximum entropy model for opinions in social groups
• Entanglement between Demand and Supply in Markets with Bandwagon Goods
• Binary decision making with very heterogeneous influence

Cited by in corpus (11)

• Free-fermion Entanglement Spectrum through Wannier Interpolation
• Band flatness optimization through complex analysis
• Exact holographic mapping in free fermion systems
• Geometric construction of Quantum Hall clustering Hamiltonians
• Model of human collective decision-making in complex environments
• Phase Transitions and Criticality in the Collective Behavior of Animals -- Self-organization and biological function
• Kinked Entropy and Discontinuous Microcanonical Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking
• Non-equilibrium phase transitions in competitive markets caused by network effects
• Coordination problems on networks revisited: statics and dynamics
• Collective decision-making with heterogeneous biases: Role of network topology and susceptibility
• Exact Mappings in Condensed Matter Physics