Short-range Ising spin glasses: the metastate interpretation of replica symmetry breaking

Abstract

Parisi's formal replica-symmetry--breaking (RSB) scheme for mean-field spin glasses has long been interpreted in terms of many pure states organized ultrametrically. However, the early version of this interpretation, as applied to the short-range Edwards-Anderson model, runs into problems because as shown by Newman and Stein (NS) it does not allow for chaotic size dependence, and predicts non-self-averaging that cannot occur. NS proposed the concept of the metastate (a probability distribution over infinite-size Gibbs states in a given sample that captures the effects of chaotic size dependence) and a non-standard interpretation of the RSB results in which the metastate is non-trivial and is responsible for what was called non-self-averaging. Here we use the effective field theory of RSB, in conjunction with the rigorous definitions of pure states and the metastate in infinite-size systems, to show that the non-standard picture follows directly from the RSB mean-field theory. In addition, the metastate-averaged state possesses power-law correlations throughout the low temperature phase; the corresponding exponent $\zeta$ takes the value $4$ according to the field theory in high dimensions $d$, and describes the effective fractal dimension of clusters of spins. Further, the logarithm of the number of pure states in the decomposition of the metastate-averaged state that can be distinguished if only correlations in a window of size $W$ can be observed is of order $W^{d-\zeta }$. These results extend the non-standard picture quantitatively; we show that arguments against this scenario are inconclusive.

arXiv comment32 pages. v2: various small changes and additional references. v3: yet more small changes; published version

References in corpus (28)

• Broken Replica Symmetry Bounds in the Mean Field Spin Glass Model
• Replica Symmetry Breaking in Short-Range Spin Glasses: Theoretical Foundations and Numerical Evidences
• General properties of overlap probability distributions in disordered spin systems. Toward Parisi ultrametricity
• On the Stability of the Quenched State in Mean Field Spin Glass Models
• Non-Mean-Field Behavior of Realistic Spin Glasses
• Ordering and Broken Symmetry in Short-Ranged Spin Glasses
• The metastate approach to thermodynamic chaos
• Spatial Inhomogeneity and Thermodynamic Chaos
• Simplicity of State and Overlap Structure in Finite-Volume Realistic Spin Glasses
• Nature of the spin-glass phase at experimental length scales
• Disappearance of the de Almeida-Thouless line in six dimensions
• Ground State Structure in a Highly Disordered Spin Glass Model
• Replica symmetry breaking in and around six dimensions
• Theory of minimum spanning trees I: Mean-field theory and strongly disordered spin-glass model
• Spin glass transition in a magnetic field: a renormalization group study
• Uniqueness of Ground States for Short-Range Spin Glasses in the Half-Plane
• Evidence of non-mean-field-like low-temperature behavior in the Edwards-Anderson spin-glass model
• Small Window Overlaps Are Effective Probes of Replica Symmetry Breaking in 3D Spin Glasses
• Free energy fluctuations in Ising spin glasses
• Comment on "Evidence of Non-Mean-Field-Like Low-Temperature Behavior in the Edwards-Anderson Spin-Glass Model"
• Which measures of spin-glass overlaps are informative?
• Nonrealistic Behavior of Mean Field Spin Glasses
• The cumulative overlap distribution function in realistic spin glasses
• Reply to Comment on "Evidence of Non-Mean-Field-Like Low-Temperature Behavior in the Edwards-Anderson Spin-Glass Model"
• Factorization properties in d-dimensional spin glasses. Rigorous results and some perspectives
• Realistic spin glasses below eight dimensions: a highly disordered view
• Spatial correlation functions and dynamical exponents in very large samples of 4D spin glasses
• The perturbative structure of spin glass field theory

Cited by in corpus (23)

• Evolutionary potential games on lattices
• Evidence against a mean field description of short-range spin glasses revealed through thermal boundary conditions
• One-step replica-symmetry-breaking phase below the de Almeida-Thouless line in low-dimensional spin glasses
• Number of thermodynamic states in the three-dimensional Edwards-Anderson spin glass
• The Fractal Dimension of Interfaces in Edwards-Anderson and Long-range Ising Spin Glasses: Determining the Applicability of Different Theoretical Descriptions
• The droplet-scaling versus replica symmetry breaking debate in spin glasses revisited
• Non-equilibrium evolution of window overlaps in spin glasses
• Low-temperature behavior of the statistics of the overlap distribution in Ising spin-glass models
• Numerical construction of the Aizenman-Wehr metastate
• Ground State Stability and the Nature of the Spin Glass Phase
• The connection between statics and dynamics of spin glasses
• Spin-glass dynamics: experiment, theory and simulation
• Thermodynamic Identities and Symmetry Breaking in Short-Range Spin Glasses
• Proof of single-replica equivalence in short-range spin glasses
• Nontrivial maturation metastate-average state in a one-dimensional long-range Ising spin glass: above and below the upper critical range
• On the superposition principle and non-linear response in spin glasses
• Numerical simulations of Ising spin glasses with free boundary conditions: the role of droplet excitations and domain walls
• Critical Droplets and Replica Symmetry Breaking
• Triviality of the ground-state metastate in long-range Ising spin glasses in one dimension
• Overlap Structure and Free Energy Fluctuations in Short-Range Spin Glasses
• Free Energy Difference Fluctuations in Short-Range Spin Glasses
• Probability Theory in Statistical Physics, Percolation, and Other Random Topics: The Work of C. Newman
• Deepening the knowledge of Spin Glasses: Metastate, Off-equilibrium phenomena and Temperature Chaos