Chasing the phantom: A closer look at Type Ia supernovae and the dark energy equation of state

Abstract

Some recent observations provide $>2\sigma$ evidence for phantom dark energy -- a value of the dark energy equation of state less than the cosmological-constant value of $-1$. We focus on constraining the equation of state by combining current data from the most mature geometrical probes of dark energy: Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) from the Supernova Legacy Survey (SNLS3), the Supernova Cosmology Project (Union2.1), and the Pan-STARRS1 survey (PS1); cosmic microwave background measurements from Planck and WMAP9; and a combination of measurements of baryon acoustic oscillations. The combined data are consistent with $w=-1$ for the Union2.1 sample, though they present moderate ($\sim 1.9\sigma$) evidence for a phantom value when either the SNLS3 or PS1 sample is used instead. We study the dependence of the constraints on the redshift, stretch, color, and host galaxy stellar mass of SNe, but we find no unusual trends. In contrast, the constraints strongly depend on any external $H_0$ prior: a higher adopted value for the direct measurement of the Hubble constant ($H_0\gtrsim 71\text{km/s/Mpc}$) leads to $\gtrsim 2\sigma$ evidence for phantom dark energy. Given Planck data, we can therefore make the following statement at $2\sigma$ confidence: either the SNLS3 and PS1 data have systematics that remain unaccounted for or the Hubble constant is below 71 km/s/Mpc; else the dark energy equation of state is indeed phantom.

12 pages, 6 figures; minor changes to match the published version

References in corpus (9)

• Dark Energy and the Accelerating Universe
• New Hubble Space Telescope Discoveries of Type Ia Supernovae at z > 1: Narrowing Constraints on the Early Behavior of Dark Energy
• Improved Cosmological Constraints from New, Old and Combined Supernova Datasets
• Spectra and Light Curves of Six Type Ia Supernovae at 0.511 < z < 1.12 and the Union2 Compilation
• Some Aspects of Measurement Error in Linear Regression of Astronomical Data
• Observational Constraints on the Nature of the Dark Energy: First Cosmological Results from the ESSENCE Supernova Survey
• Improved Dark Energy Constraints from ~100 New CfA Supernova Type Ia Light Curves
• Supernova Constraints and Systematic Uncertainties from the First 3 Years of the Supernova Legacy Survey
• Principal components of dark energy with SNLS supernovae: the effects of systematic errors

Cited by in corpus (71)

• Improved cosmological constraints from a joint analysis of the SDSS-II and SNLS supernova samples
• Constraints on the sum of the neutrino masses in dynamical dark energy models with $w(z)\ge -1$ are tighter than those obtained in $\Lambda$CDM
• Cosmological perturbations and structure formation in nonlocal infrared modifications of general relativity
• Non-local gravity and dark energy
• Simulations of the WFIRST Supernova Survey and Forecasts of Cosmological Constraints
• Dark Energy with Phantom Crossing and the $H_0$ tension
• Robust Preference for Dynamical Dark Energy in DESI BAO and SN Measurements
• Dynamical vacuum energy in the expanding Universe confronted with observations: a dedicated study
• A new interacting two fluid model and its consequences
• Cosmological consequences of an adiabatic matter creation process
• Illuminating a Dark Lens : A Type Ia Supernova Magnified by the Frontier Fields Galaxy Cluster Abell 2744
• A model with interaction of dark components and recent observational data
• Searching for dark matter - dark energy interactions: going beyond the conformal case
• Vacuum models with a linear and a quadratic term in H: structure formation and number counts analysis
• Testing coupled dark energy models with their cosmological background evolution
• Bayesian model selection without evidences: application to the dark energy equation-of-state
• Cosmological Models and Gamma-Ray Bursts Calibrated by Using Pade Method
• The state of the dark energy equation of state circa 2023
• Entropic-force dark energy reconsidered
• Phantom behavior via cosmological creation of particles
• Cosmic slowing down of acceleration for several dark energy parametrizations
• Constraining the Dark Energy Equation of State with HII Galaxies
• Evolution and Dynamics of a Matter creation model
• Can dark energy be expressed as a power series of the Hubble parameter?
• Independent Cosmological Constraints from high-z HII Galaxies
• Effects of shear and rotation on the spherical collapse model for clustering dark energy
• Banana Split: Testing the Dark Energy Consistency with Geometry and Growth
• How clustering dark energy affects matter perturbations
• Robust model comparison disfavors power law cosmology
• Cosmic acceleration without dark energy: Background tests and thermodynamic analysis
• Observational constraints on dark matter-dark energy scattering cross section
• Linear growth in power law $f(T)$ gravity
• Nonsingular Decaying Vacuum Cosmology and Entropy Production
• Background history and cosmic perturbations for a general system of self-conserved dynamical dark energy and matter
• Massive Photon and Dark Energy
• Gravitationally induced adiabatic particle production: From Big Bang to de Sitter
• Cosmological perturbations and observational constraints on nonlocal massive gravity
• No evidence for bulk velocity from type Ia supernovae
• Can Holographic dark energy models fit the observational data?
• Model selection and constraints from Holographic dark energy scenarios
• New Generalizations of Cosmography Inspired by the Pade Approximant
• Constraining the dynamical dark energy parameters: Planck-2013 vs WMAP9
• Dynamical analysis of interacting dark energy model in the framework of particle creation mechanism
• Connecting inflation with late cosmic acceleration by particle production
• Sound speed of scalar field dark energy: weak effects and large uncertainties
• Phantom-like dark energy from quantum gravity
• Spherical collapse model and cluster number counts in power law $f(T)$ gravity
• Crossing the phantom divide line as an effect of quantum transitions
• Observational Constraints on Growth Index with Cosmography
• New parameterization for unified dark matter and dark energy
• Dynamics of interacting scalar field model in the realm of chiral cosmology
• Constraining thawing and freezing models with cluster number counts
• Accretion of perfect fluids onto a class of regular black holes
• Combined cosmological tests of a bivalent tachyonic dark energy scalar field model
• Model Independent Analysis of Supernova Data, Dark Energy, Trans-Planckian Censorship and the Swampland
• Dynamics of minimally coupled dark energy in spherical halos of dark matter
• Interacting holographic Ricci dark energy as running vacuum
• Gravitationally induced particle production and its impact on structure formation
• The Hubble Rate Trouble: An Effective Field Theory of Dark Matter
• Cosmology In Terms Of The Deceleration Parameter. Part II
• Cosmic expansion and structure formation in running vacuum cosmologies
• Emergent Dark Energy from Dark Matter
• Constraints on the $\Lambda$CDM model with redshift tomography
• Dynamics of dark energy in the gravitational fields of matter inhomogeneities
• Bayesian analysis of running holographic Ricci dark energy
• Constraints on Dark Energy from New Observations including Pan-STARRS
• Updated reduced CMB data and constraints on cosmological parameters
• The consistency test on the cosmic evolution
• Observational constraints on thawing quintessence scalar field model
• K-essential covariant holography
• Covariant holography of a tachyonic accelerating universe