Statistical mechanics of the US Supreme Court

Abstract

We build simple models for the distribution of voting patterns in a group, using the Supreme Court of the United States as an example. The least structured, or maximum entropy, model that is consistent with the observed pairwise correlations among justices' votes is equivalent to an Ising spin glass. While all correlations (perhaps surprisingly) are positive, the effective pairwise interactions in the spin glass model have both signs, recovering some of our intuition that justices on opposite sides of the ideological spectrum should have a negative influence on one another. Despite the competing interactions, a strong tendency toward unanimity emerges from the model, and this agrees quantitatively with the data. The model shows that voting patterns are organized in a relatively simple "energy landscape," correctly predicts the extent to which each justice is correlated with the majority, and gives us a measure of the influence that justices exert on one another. These results suggest that simple models, grounded in statistical physics, can capture essential features of collective decision making quantitatively, even in a complex political context.

References in corpus (5)

• Statistical physics of social dynamics
• Searching for collective behavior in a network of real neurons
• Scaling and universality in proportional elections
• Justice blocks and predictability of US Supreme Court votes
• Editorial: Statistical Mechanics and Social Sciences

Cited by in corpus (21)

• A General Approach for Predicting the Behavior of the Supreme Court of the United States
• Statistical Criticality arises in Most Informative Representations
• Understanding interdependency through complex information sharing
• The Cultural Transmission of Tacit Knowledge
• Shape Is Destiny II: Configurational Information Approach to Instantons and False Vacuum Decay in D-dimensional Spacetime
• Quantifying Relevance in Learning and Inference
• Random versus maximum entropy models of neural population activity
• Pairwise Network Information and Nonlinear Correlations
• Inferring Cultural Landscapes with the Inverse Ising Model
• The Stochastic complexity of spin models: Are pairwise models really simple?
• On Maximum Entropy and Inference
• Classical spin Hamiltonians are context-sensitive languages
• Optimal design of experiments by combining coarse and fine measurements
• A random energy approach to deep learning
• CompLex: legal systems through the lens of complexity science
• Inference of stochastic time series with missing data
• The statistical mechanics of Twitter
• The grammar of the Ising model: A new complexity hierarchy
• Discovering sparse control strategies in C. elegans
• Empirical validation of the polarization transition in a double-random field model of elections
• Matrix approach to generalized ensemble theory for nonequilibrium discrete systems