Seeing patterns in noise: Gigaparsec-scale `structures' that do not violate homogeneity
arXiv:1306.1700 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stt1028
Abstract
Clowes et al. (2013) have recently reported the discovery of a Large Quasar Group (LQG), dubbed the Huge-LQG, at redshift z~1.3 in the DR7 quasar catalogue of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. On the basis of its characteristic size ~500 Mpc and longest dimension >1 Gpc, it is claimed that this structure is incompatible with large-scale homogeneity and the cosmological principle. If true, this would represent a serious challenge to the standard cosmological model. However, the homogeneity scale is an average property which is not necessarily affected by the discovery of a single large structure. I clarify this point and provide the first fractal dimension analysis of the DR7 quasar catalogue to demonstrate that it is in fact homogeneous above scales of at most 130 Mpc/h, which is much less than the upper limit for ΛCDM. In addition, I show that the algorithm used to identify the Huge-LQG regularly finds even larger clusters of points, extending over Gpc scales, in explicitly homogeneous simulations of a Poisson point process with the same density as the quasar catalogue. This provides a simple null test to be applied to any cluster thus found in a real catalogue, and suggests that the interpretation of LQGs as `structures' is misleading.
arXiv comment9 pages, 6 figures. MNRAS published online. v2: minor typo corrected, added one missing reference
References in corpus (35)
- Spectroscopic Target Selection for the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: The Luminous Red Galaxy Sample
- The Sloan Digital Sky Survey Quasar Catalog V. Seventh Data Release
- The SDSS Quasar Survey: Quasar Luminosity Function from Data Release Three
- On average properties of inhomogeneous fluids in general relativity I: dust cosmologies
- The WiggleZ Dark Energy Survey: Survey Design and First Data Release
- A Map of the Universe
- Cosmic homogeneity demonstrated with luminous red galaxies
- An Imprint of Super-Structures on the Microwave Background due to the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe Effect
- Backreaction in late-time cosmology
- The WiggleZ Dark Energy Survey: the transition to large-scale cosmic homogeneity
- The universe seen at different scales
- The Supercluster-Void Network I. The Supercluster Catalogue and Large-Scale Distribution
- A structure in the early universe at z ~ 1.3 that exceeds the homogeneity scale of the R-W concordance cosmology
- Backreaction: directions of progress
- Fractal Dimension as a measure of the scale of Homogeneity
- Superclusters of galaxies from the 2dF redshift survey. I. The catalogue
- On the onset of cosmological backreaction
- An Empirical Calibration of the Completeness of the SDSS Quasar Survey
- The Challenge of the Largest Structures in the Universe to Cosmology
- Statistical Physics for Cosmic Structures
- The integrated Sachs-Wolfe imprints of cosmic superstructures: a problem for ΛCDM
- Superclusters of galaxies from the 2dF redshift survey. II. Comparison with simulations
- How unusual are the Shapley Supercluster and the Sloan Great Wall?
- The stacked ISW signal of rare superstructures in ΛCDM
- Luminous superclusters: remnants from inflation
- On the signature of superclusters and voids in the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect
- Very large scale correlations in the galaxy distribution
- Two close Large Quasar Groups of size ~ 350 Mpc at z ~ 1.2
- Fractal Dimensions of a Weakly Clustered Distribution and the Scale of Homogeneity
- Breaking the self-averaging properties of spatial galaxy fluctuations in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey - Data Release Six
- Searching for the scale of homogeneity
- Large-scale fluctuations in the distribution of galaxies from the Two Degree Field Galaxy Redshift Survey
- Connected structure in the 2dFGRS
- Are the 2dFGRS superstructures a problem for hierarchical models?
- Boundary Corrections in Fractal Analysis of Galaxy Surveys
Cited by in corpus (48)
- Cosmology and Fundamental Physics with the Euclid Satellite
- Cosmology and fundamental physics with the Euclid satellite
- The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
- Is the Observable Universe Consistent with the Cosmological Principle?
- Alignment of quasar polarizations with large-scale structures
- A robust public catalogue of voids and superclusters in the SDSS Data Release 7 galaxy surveys
- Homogeneity and isotropy in the 2MASS Photometric Redshift catalogue
- A 14 Gpc study of cosmic homogeneity using BOSS DR12 quasar sample
- New data support the existence of the Hercules-Corona Borealis Great Wall
- Direct Minkowski Functional analysis of large redshift surveys: a new high--speed code tested on the luminous red galaxy Sloan Digital Sky Survey-DR7 catalogue
- A Giant Arc on the Sky
- Cosmic troublemakers: the Cold Spot, the Eridanus Supervoid, and the Great Walls
- Implications of Symmetry and Pressure in Friedmann Cosmology. I. Formalism
- Exploring galaxy colour in different environments of the cosmic web with SDSS
- Measuring the scale of cosmic homogeneity with SDSS-IV DR14 quasars
- Cosmic homogeneity: a spectroscopic and model-independent measurement
- Testing Isotropic Universe Using the Gamma-Ray Burst Data of Fermi / GBM
- Cosmology Intertwined: A Review of the Particle Physics, Astrophysics, and Cosmology Associated with the Cosmological Tensions and Anomalies
- Probing spatial homogeneity with LTB models: a detailed discussion
- The scale of homogeneity in the local Universe with the ALFALFA catalogue
- The angular scale of homogeneity in the Local Universe with the SDSS blue galaxies
- Testing the anisotropy in the angular distribution of /GBM gamma-ray bursts
- Evidence for the alignment of quasar radio polarizations with large quasar group axes
- Tracing high redshift cosmic web with quasar systems
- Testing the homogeneity of the Universe using gamma-ray bursts
- Violation of the FRW consistency condition as a signature of backreaction
- Measuring the transition to homogeneity with photometric redshift surveys
- Update on Testing the Isotropy of the Properties of Gamma-Ray Bursts
- Not a Copernican observer: biased peculiar velocity statistics in the local Universe
- Backreaction and FRW consistency conditions
- An information theory based search for homogeneity on the largest accessible scale
- Quasars as a tracer of large-scale structures in the distant universe
- Correlated orientations of the axes of large quasar groups on Gpc scales
- Unravelling the Cosmic Web: An analysis of the SDSS DR14 with the Local Dimension
- Re-Examining the Evidence of the Hercules-Corona-Borealis Great Wall
- Compatibility of the Large Quasar Groups with the Concordance Cosmological Model
- Spatial density fluctuations and selection effects in galaxy redshift surveys
- Local alignments of parsec-scale AGN radiojets
- The Scale of Homogeneity in the Universe
- Testing homogeneity of the galaxy distribution in the SDSS using Renyi entropy
- Evaluating backreaction with the ellipsoidal collapse model
- Can the homogeneity scale be used as a standard ruler?
- Large Scale Cosmological Anomalies and Inhomogeneous Dark Energy
- Tracing the high-z cosmic web with Quaia: catalogues of voids and clusters in the quasar distribution
- Gravitational waves from dark domain walls
- Space-Time Entropy, Space of Singularities and Gravity Origin: A Case Study
- Anomalies in the GRB spatial distribution
- Time evolution of the mutual information between disjoint regions in the Universe