The quest for self-consistency in hydrogen-bond definitions

Abstract

In the last decades several hydrogen-bond definitions were proposed by classical computer simulations. Aiming at validating their self-consistency on a wide range of conditions, here we present a comparative study of six among the most common hydrogen-bond definitions for temperatures ranging from 220K to 400K and six classical water models. Our results show that, in the interval of temperatures investigated, a generally weak agreement among definitions is present. Moreover, cutoff choice for geometrically based definitions depends on both temperature and water model. As such, analysis of the same water model at different temperatures as well as different water models at the same temperature would require the development of specific cutoff values. Interestingly, large discrepancies were found between two hydrogen-bond definitions which were recently introduced to improve on more conventional methods. Our results anticipate that a more universal way to characterize hydrogen-bonds in classical molecular systems is needed.

7 pages, 7 figures

References in corpus (3)

• Canonical sampling through velocity-rescaling
• Towards a microscopic description of the free-energy landscape of water
• Accounting for the kinetics in order parameter analysis: lessons from theoretical models and a disordered peptide

Cited by in corpus (7)

• The Individual and Collective Effects of Exact Exchange and Dispersion Interactions on the Ab Initio Structure of Liquid Water
• Structural, Electronic, and Dynamical Properties of Liquid Water by ab initio Molecular Dynamics based on SCAN Functional within the Canonical Ensemble
• Unravelling the contribution of local structures to the anomalies of water: the synergistic action of several factors
• Network Topology in Water Nanoconfined between Phospholipid Membranes
• Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Water between Metal Walls under Electric Field: Dielectric Response and Dynamics after Field Reversal
• Fluctuations of local electric field and dipole moments in water between metal walls
• How do hydrogen bonds break in supercooled water?: Detecting pathways not going through the saddle point of two-dimensional potential of mean force