A Consistent Approach to Falsifying Lambda-CDM with Rare Galaxy Clusters
arXiv:1210.4369 · doi:10.1088/1475-7516/2013/07/022
Abstract
We consider methods with which to answer the question "is any observed galaxy cluster too unusual for Lambda-CDM?" After emphasising that many previous attempts to answer this question will overestimate the confidence level at which Lambda-CDM can be ruled out, we outline a consistent approach to these rare clusters, which allows the question to be answered. We define three statistical measures, each of which are sensitive to changes in cluster populations arising from different modifications to the cosmological model. We also use these properties to define the 'equivalent mass at redshift zero' for a cluster --- the mass of an equally unusual cluster today. This quantity is independent of the observational survey in which the cluster was found, which makes it an ideal proxy for ranking the relative unusualness of clusters detected by different surveys. These methods are then used on a comprehensive sample of observed galaxy clusters and we confirm that all are less than 2-sigma deviations from the Lambda-CDM expectation. Whereas we have only applied our method to galaxy clusters, it is applicable to any isolated, collapsed, halo. As motivation for future surveys, we also calculate where in the mass redshift plane the rarest halo is most likely to be found, giving information as to which objects might be the most fruitful in the search for new physics.
arXiv comment18 pages, 6 figures, updated to fix dead url (text unchanged). Code for calculating rareness and equivalent mass at z=0 available https://bitbucket.org/itrharrison/hh13-cluster-rareness/
References in corpus (47)
- Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
- Toward a halo mass function for precision cosmology: the limits of universality
- Dark matter halo concentrations in the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe year 5 cosmology
- The MCXC: a Meta-Catalogue of X-ray detected Clusters of galaxies
- Scaling relations for galaxy clusters in the Millennium-XXL simulation
- The abundance of high-redshift objects as a probe of non-Gaussian initial conditions
- The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: Sunyaev Zel'dovich Selected Galaxy Clusters at 148 GHz in the 2008 Survey
- Galaxy clusters discovered via the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect in the first 720 square degrees of the South Pole Telescope survey
- LoCuSS: Subaru Weak Lensing Study of 30 Galaxy Clusters
- An SZ-selected sample of the most massive galaxy clusters in the 2500-square-degree South Pole Telescope survey
- Non-linear Evolution of f(R) Cosmologies III: Halo Statistics
- A mature cluster with X-ray emission at z=2.07
- The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: ACT-CL J0102-4915 "El Gordo," a Massive Merging Cluster at Redshift 0.87
- X-ray Properties of the First SZE-selected Galaxy Cluster Sample from the South Pole Telescope
- Constraints on f(R) gravity from probing the large-scale structure
- Multi-wavelength study of XMMU J2235.3-2557: the most massive galaxy cluster at z > 1
- Discovery and Cosmological Implications of SPT-CL J2106-5844, the Most Massive Known Cluster at z > 1
- Simultaneous Falsification of LCDM and Quintessence with Massive, Distant Clusters
- Scaling Relations and Overabundance of Massive Clusters at z>~1 from Weak-Lensing Studies with HST
- Hubble Space Telescope Weak-lensing Study of the Galaxy Cluster XMMU J2235.3-2557 at z=1.4: A Surprisingly Massive Galaxy Cluster when the Universe is One-third of its Current Age
- SPT-CL J0546-5345: A Massive z > 1 Galaxy Cluster Selected Via the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect with the South Pole Telescope
- Constraining dark energy with Sunyaev-Zel'dovich cluster surveys
- Cluster Abundance in f(R) Gravity Models
- The X-ray luminous galaxy cluster population at 0.9<z<~1.6 as revealed by the XMM-Newton Distant Cluster Project
- Spectroscopic Confirmation of Three Red-Sequence Selected Galaxy Clusters at z=0.87, 1.16 and 1.21 from the SpARCS Survey
- Optical Redshift and Richness Estimates for Galaxy Clusters Selected with the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect from 2008 South Pole Telescope Observations
- SPT-CL J0205-5829: A z = 1.32 Evolved Massive Galaxy Cluster in the South Pole Telescope Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect Survey
- IDCS J1426.5+3508: Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Measurement of a Massive IR-selected Cluster at z=1.75
- The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: Physical Properties of Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect Clusters on the Celestial Equator
- Implications of multiple high-redshift galaxy clusters
- Early massive clusters and the bouncing coupled dark energy
- Implications for Primordial Non-Gaussianity (f_NL) from weak lensing masses of high-z galaxy clusters
- Weak-Lensing Mass Measurements of Five Galaxy Clusters in the South Pole Telescope Survey Using Magellan/Megacam
- Testing Cosmology with Extreme Galaxy Clusters
- Southern Cosmology Survey II: Massive Optically-Selected Clusters from 70 square degrees of the SZE Common Survey Area
- Most massive halos with Gumbel Statistics
- First lensing measurements of SZ-discovered clusters
- Probability of the most massive cluster under non-Gaussian initial conditions
- Estimating f_NL and g_NL from Massive High-Redshift Galaxy Clusters
- The most massive objects in the Universe
- Primordial Non-Gaussianity and Extreme-Value Statistics of Galaxy Clusters
- Quantifying the rareness of extreme galaxy clusters
- An application of extreme value statistics to the most massive galaxy clusters at low and high redshifts
- A critical analysis of high-redshift, massive galaxy clusters: I
- Extreme value statistics of smooth random Gaussian fields
- XMM-Newton detection of two clusters of galaxies with strong SPT Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect signatures
- Cl 1103.7-1245 at z=0.96: the highest redshift galaxy cluster in the EDisCS survey
Cited by in corpus (19)
- The XXL Survey: I. Scientific motivations - XMM-Newton observing plan - Follow-up observations and simulation programme
- Galaxy growth in a massive halo in the first billion years of cosmic history
- Dusty Starbursts Masquerading as Ultra-high Redshift Galaxies in JWST CEERS Observations
- Weighing "El Gordo" with a Precision Scale: Hubble Space Telescope Weak-lensing Analysis of the Merging Galaxy Cluster ACT-CL J0102-4915 at z=0.87
- CLASH: Complete Lensing Analysis of the Largest Cosmic Lens MACS J0717.5+3745 and Surrounding Structures
- Physical Characterization of an Unlensed Dusty Star-Forming Galaxy at
- Cosmology from the Thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Power Spectrum: Primordial non-Gaussianity and Massive Neutrinos
- Mapping Obscuration to Reionization with ALMA (MORA): 2mm Efficiently Selects the Highest-Redshift Obscured Galaxies
- Emergence of an Ultra-Red Ultra-Massive Galaxy Cluster Core at
- The XXL Survey V: Detection of the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect of the Redshift 1.9 Galaxy Cluster XLSSU J021744.1-034536 with CARMA
- Cluster-Void Degeneracy Breaking: Dark Energy, Planck and the Largest Cluster & Void
- Spectroscopic confirmation of a mature galaxy cluster at redshift two
- Comprehensive Gas Characterization of a Protocluster: A Cluster Core Caught in the Beginning of Virialization?
- COSMOS2020: Identification of High-z Protocluster Candidates in COSMOS
- On the Significance of Rare Objects at High Redshift: The Impact of Cosmic Variance
- Constraining the Mass of the Emerging Galaxy Cluster SpARCS1049+56 at z=1.71 with Infrared Weak Lensing
- The infrared-luminous progenitors of high-z quasars
- X-ray cluster cosmology
- X-ray characterisation of the massive galaxy clusterClG-J104803.7+313843 at z=0.76 with XMM-Newton