A critical analysis of high-redshift, massive galaxy clusters: I
arXiv:1108.5458 · doi:10.1088/1475-7516/2012/02/009
Abstract
We critically investigate current statistical tests applied to high redshift clusters of galaxies in order to test the standard cosmological model and describe their range of validity. We carefully compare a sample of high-redshift, massive, galaxy clusters with realistic Poisson sample simulations of the theoretical mass function, which include the effect of Eddington bias. We compare the observations and simulations using the following statistical tests: the distributions of ensemble and individual existence probabilities (in the >M,>z sense), the redshift distributions, and the 2d Kolmogorov-Smirnov test. Using seemingly rare clusters from Hoyle et al. (2011), and Jee et al. (2011) and assuming the same survey geometry as in Jee et al. (2011, which is less conservative than Hoyle et al. 2011), we find that the (>M,>z) existence probabilities of all clusters are fully consistent with LCDM. However assuming the same survey geometry, we use the 2d K-S test probability to show that the observed clusters are not consistent with being the least probable clusters from simulations at >95% confidence, and are also not consistent with being a random selection of clusters, which may be caused by the non-trivial selection function and survey geometry. Tension can be removed if we examine only a X-ray selected sub sample, with simulations performed assuming a modified survey geometry.
arXiv comment20 pages, 6 figures, 2 tables, modified to match accepted version (JCAP); title changed, main analysis unchanged, additional analysis
References in corpus (28)
- Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
- The Structure of Cold Dark Matter Halos
- Toward a halo mass function for precision cosmology: the limits of universality
- The Red-Sequence Cluster Survey I: The Survey and Cluster Catalogs for Patches RCS0926+37 and RCS1327+29
- The abundance of high-redshift objects as a probe of non-Gaussian initial conditions
- Effects of Scale-Dependent Non-Gaussianity on Cosmological Structures
- An SZ-selected sample of the most massive galaxy clusters in the 2500-square-degree South Pole Telescope survey
- A mature cluster with X-ray emission at z=2.07
- Simultaneous Falsification of LCDM and Quintessence with Massive, Distant Clusters
- Scaling Relations and Overabundance of Massive Clusters at z>~1 from Weak-Lensing Studies with HST
- X-ray groups and clusters of galaxies in the Subaru-XMM Deep Field
- The XMM Cluster Survey: The build up of stellar mass in Brightest Cluster Galaxies at high redshift
- The Halo Mass Function from Excursion Set Theory. III. Non-Gaussian Fluctuations
- N-body simulations with generic non-Gaussian initial conditions I: Power Spectrum and halo mass function
- Discovery of a massive X-ray luminous galaxy cluster at z=1.579
- iCosmo: an Interactive Cosmology Package
- Implications of multiple high-redshift galaxy clusters
- Implications for Primordial Non-Gaussianity (f_NL) from weak lensing masses of high-z galaxy clusters
- Non-Gaussianity from Large-Scale Structure Surveys
- An Improved Calculation of the Non-Gaussian Halo Mass Function
- Excursion Sets and Non-Gaussian Void Statistics
- Are Clusters Standard Candles? Galaxy Cluster Scaling Relations With the Sunyaev-Zeldovich Effect
- Testing the galaxy cluster mass-observable relations at z = 1 with XMM-Newton and Chandra observations of XLSSJ022403.9-041328
- Estimating f_NL and g_NL from Massive High-Redshift Galaxy Clusters
- Probability of the most massive cluster under non-Gaussian initial conditions
- Quantifying the rareness of extreme galaxy clusters
- A two-dimensional Kolmogorov-Smirnov test for crowded field source detection: ROSAT sources in NGC 6397
- The Extreme Tail of the Non-Gaussian Mass Function
Cited by in corpus (18)
- Scaling relations for galaxy clusters in the Millennium-XXL simulation
- Voids in Modified Gravity: Excursion Set Predictions
- Constraining primordial non-Gaussianity with future galaxy surveys
- CLASH: Precise New Constraints on the Mass Profile of Abell 2261
- Spherical collapse in Galileon gravity: fifth force solutions, halo mass function and halo bias
- The Massive and Distant Clusters of WISE Survey. I: Survey Overview and a Catalog of >2000 Galaxy Clusters at z~1
- Cosmology from the Thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Power Spectrum: Primordial non-Gaussianity and Massive Neutrinos
- SPT-CL J0205-5829: A z = 1.32 Evolved Massive Galaxy Cluster in the South Pole Telescope Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect Survey
- Statistics of extreme objects in the Juropa Hubble Volume simulation
- The structure of cosmic voids in a LCDM Universe
- Optical Confirmation and Redshift Estimation of the Planck Cluster Candidates overlapping the Pan-STARRS Survey
- I. Apples to apples : realistic galaxy simulated catalogs and photometric redshift predictions for next-generation surveys
- A Consistent Approach to Falsifying Lambda-CDM with Rare Galaxy Clusters
- Galaxy clusters and groups in the ALHAMBRA Survey
- Constraining the Mass of the Emerging Galaxy Cluster SpARCS1049+56 at z=1.71 with Infrared Weak Lensing
- Order statistics applied to the most massive and most distant galaxy clusters
- EXSdetect: an end-to-end software for extended source detection in X-ray images: application to Swift-XRT data
- X-ray cluster cosmology