Direct N-Body Modeling of the Old Open Cluster NGC 188: A Detailed Comparison of Theoretical and Observed Binary Star and Blue Straggler Populations

Abstract

(Abridged) Following on from a recently completed radial-velocity survey of the old (7 Gyr) open cluster NGC 188 in which we study in detail the solar-type hard binaries and blue stragglers of the cluster, here we investigate the dynamical evolution of NGC 188 through a sophisticated N-body model. We employ the observed binary properties of the young (150 Myr) open cluster M35, where possible, to guide our choices for parameters of the initial binary population. At 7 Gyr the main-sequence solar-type hard-binary population in the model matches that of NGC 188 in both binary frequency and distributions of orbital parameters. This agreement between the model and observations is in a large part due to the similarities between the NGC 188 and M35 solar-type binaries. Indeed, among the 7 Gyr main-sequence binaries in the model, only those with P>1000 days show potentially observable evidence for modifications by dynamical encounters. This emphasizes the importance of defining accurate initial conditions for star cluster models, which we propose is best accomplished through comparisons with observations of young open clusters like M35. Furthermore, this suggests that observations of the present-day binaries in even old open clusters can provide valuable information on their primordial binary populations. However, despite the model's successes at matching the true cluster, the model underproduces blue stragglers and produces an overabundance of long-period circular main-sequence--white-dwarf binaries as compared to NGC 188. We conclude that improvements in the physics of mass transfer and common envelope may in fact solve both discrepancies with the observations. This project highlights the unique accessibility of open clusters to both comprehensive observational surveys and full-scale N-body simulations, and underscores the importance of open clusters to the study of star cluster dynamics.

25 pages, 19 figures, accepted for publication in AJ (minor changes from previous submitted version)

References in corpus (9)

• Tertiary companions to close spectroscopic binaries
• Accelerating NBODY6 with Graphics Processing Units
• The Palomar/Keck Adaptive Optics Survey of Young Solar Analogs: Evidence for a Universal Companion Mass Function
• WIYN Open Cluster Study XXXII: Stellar Radial Velocities in the Old Open Cluster NGC 188
• Mass transfer from a giant star to a main sequence companion and its contribution to long-orbital-period blue stragglers
• Evolution of stellar collision products in open clusters. I. Blue stragglers in N-body models of M67
• WIYN Open Cluster Study. XXXVI. Spectroscopic Binary Orbits in NGC 188
• The Size Scale of Star Clusters
• A Survey of Open Clusters in the u'g'r'i'z' Filter System: III. Results for the Cluster NGC 188

Cited by in corpus (74)

• Mergers and Obliquities in Stellar Triples
• Black hole mergers and blue stragglers from hierarchical triples formed in globular clusters
• The impact of companions on stellar evolution
• Stellar Radial Velocities in the Old Open Cluster M67 (NGC 2682) I. Memberships, Binaries, and Kinematics
• Evolution of Mass Functions of Coeval Stars through Wind Mass Loss and Binary Interactions
• Binary stars in the Galactic thick disc
• Spin alignment of stars in old open clusters
• Implications for the Formation of Blue Straggler Stars from HST Ultraviolet Observations of NGC 188
• WIYN Open Cluster Study. LX. Spectroscopic Binary Orbits in NGC 6819
• Detection of white dwarf companions to blue stragglers in the open cluster NGC 188: direct evidence for recent mass transfer
• WASP-4b Arrived Early for the TESS Mission
• Blue Lurkers: Hidden Blue Stragglers on the M67 Main Sequence Identified from their Kepler/K2 Rotation Periods
• The Dynamical Significance of Triple Star Systems in Star Clusters
• Black hole and neutron star mergers in Galactic Nuclei: the role of triples
• Supernova enrichment and dynamical histories of solar-type stars in clusters
• In Search of the Thermal Eccentricity Distribution
• Stellar Radial Velocities in the Old Open Cluster M67 (NGC 2682). II. The Spectroscopic Binary Population
• Consequences of Dynamical Disruption and Mass Segregation for the Binary Frequencies of Star Clusters
• UVIT Open Cluster Study. I. Detection of a White Dwarf Companion to a Blue Straggler in M67: Evidence of Formation through Mass Transfer
• The binary companion mass ratio distribution: an imprint of the star formation process?
• On the origins of enigmatic stellar populations in Local Group galactic nuclei
• Dynamical evolution of star forming regions - II. Basic kinematics
• On the Origin of Sub-Subgiant Stars II: Binary Mass Transfer, Envelope Stripping, and Magnetic Activity
• A Census of Blue Stragglers in Gaia DR2 Open Clusters as a Test of Population Synthesis and Mass Transfer Physics
• Blue Straggler Populations of Seven Open Clusters with Gaia DR2
• Tidal dissipation due to inertial waves can explain the circularization periods of solar-type binaries
• Hubble Space Telescope proper motion (HSTPROMO) catalogs of Galactic globular clusters. IV. Kinematic profiles and average masses of blue straggler stars
• A dynamical gravitational wave source in a dense cluster
• WIYN Open Cluster Study. LXXVII. Radial-Velocity Measurements and Spectroscopic Binary Orbits in the Open Cluster NGC 7789
• Interrupted Stellar Encounters in Star Clusters
• The chaotic four-body problem in Newtonian gravity I: Identical point-particles
• On the Origin of Sub-subgiant Stars. III. Formation Frequencies
• A Megacam Survey of Outer Halo Satellites. II. Blue Stragglers in the Lowest Stellar Density Systems
• A Fresh Look at AGB stars in Galactic Open Clusters with Gaia: Impact on Stellar Models and the Initial-Final Mass Relation
• Evolution of star cluster systems in isolated galaxies: first results from direct $N$-body simulations
• Hunting for C-rich long-period variable stars in the Milky Way's bar-bulge using unsupervised classification of Gaia BP/RP spectra
• The Orbital Nature of 81 Ellipsoidal Red Giant Binaries in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• Different Dynamical Ages for the Two Young and Coeval LMC Star Clusters NGC 1805 and NGC 1818 Imprinted on Their Binary Populations
• WIYN Open Cluster Study. LXXXVII. HST Ultraviolet Detection of Hot White Dwarf Companions to Blue Lurkers in M67
• The Blue Stragglers of the Old Open Cluster NGC 188
• Mock Observations of Blue Stragglers in Globular Cluster Models
• The Far-Away Blues: Exploring the Furthest Extents of the Boötes I Ultra Faint Dwarf Galaxy
• Interrupted Binary Mass Transfer in Star Clusters
• Barium Surface Abundances of Blue Stragglers in the Open Cluster NGC 6819
• Bayesian Characterization of Main Sequence Binaries in the Old Open Cluster NGC 188
• UVIT/ASTROSAT studies of Blue Straggler stars and post-mass transfer systems in star clusters: Detection of one more blue lurker in M67
• A Tale of Two Circularization Periods
• The X-ray Emissivity of Low-Density Stellar Populations
• Small-N collisional dynamics II: Roaming the realm of not-so-small-N
• Detailed equilibrium and dynamical tides: impact on circularization and synchronization in open clusters
• A study of the blue straggler population of the old open cluster Collinder 261
• Unresolved binaries and Galactic clusters' mass estimates
• Unresolved Binaries in the Intermediate Mass Range in the Pleiades Star Cluster
• Blue Stragglers and Friends: Initial Evolutionary Pathways in Close Low-Mass Binaries: Literature Review
• Reconstructing the initial mass function of disc-bulge Galactic globular clusters from N-body simulations
• Illustrating chaos: A schematic discretization of the general three-body problem in Newtonian gravity
• Symmetry breaking in merging binary black holes from young massive clusters and isolated binaries
• The Rich Lack Close Neighbours: The Dependence of Blue-Straggler Fraction on Metallicity
• When does a star cluster become a multiple star system? I. Lifetimes of equal-mass small-N systems
• Investigating Mass Segregation of the Binary Stars in the Open Cluster NGC 6819
• Photometric Determination of Unresolved Main-sequence Binaries in the Pleiades: Binary Fraction and Mass Ratio Distribution
• M67 Blue Stragglers with High-resolution Infrared Spectroscopy
• GlobULeS-V. UVIT/AstroSat studies of stellar populations in NGC 362: Detection of Blue Lurkers in a Globular Cluster
• The Multiple Origin of Blue Straggler Stars: Theory vs. Observations
• A fast-rotating blue straggler star in the tidal tail of the open cluster NGC 752
• On the dynamical evolution of Cepheid multiplicity in star clusters and its implications for B-star multiplicity at birth
• Blue straggler stars beyond the Milky Way: a non-segregated population in the Large Magellanic Cloud cluster NGC 2213
• A spectroscopic quadruple as a possible progenitor of sub-Chandrasekhar Type Ia supernovae
• Time-series spectroscopy of two candidate double degenerates in the open cluster NGC 6633
• Simulating Eclipsing Binary Yields of the Rubin Observatory in the Galactic Field and Star Clusters
• Orbital Parameters and Binary Properties of 37 FGK stars in the Cores of Open Clusters NGC 2516 and NGC 2422
• Stellar Multiplicity in Open Clusters: Investigating Binary Fractions and Their Relationship with Cluster Properties
• Dynamical double black holes and their host cluster properties
• Resonance locking and tidal evolution in rotating γ-Doradus binaries