Development of simple quantitative test for lack of field emission orthodoxy
arXiv:1209.6611 · doi:10.1098/rspa.2013.0271
Abstract
This paper describes a simple quantitative test applicable to current-voltage data for cold field electron emission (CFE). It can decide whether individual reported field-enhancement-factor (FEF) values are spuriously large. The paper defines an "orthodox emission situation" by a set of ideal experimental, physical and mathematical conditions, and shows how (in these conditions) operating values of scaled barrier field (f) can be extracted from Fowler-Nordheim (FN) and Millikan-Lauritsen (ML) plots. By analyzing historical CFE experiments, which are expected to nearly satisfy the orthodoxy conditions, "apparently reasonable" and "clearly unreasonable" experimental ranges for f are found. These provide a test for lack of orthodoxy. For illustration, this test is applied to 17 post-1975 CFE data sets, mainly for carbon and semiconductor nanostructures. Some extracted f-value ranges are apparently reasonable (including many carbon results), some are clearly unreasonable. It is shown that this test applies to any field-emission diode geometry and any form of FN or ML plot. It is proved mathematically that, if the extracted f-value range is "unreasonably high", then FEF-values extracted by the usual literature method are spuriously large. Probably, all new field-emitter materials should be tested in this way. Appropriate data-analysis theory needs developing for non-orthodox emitters.
References in corpus (2)
Cited by in corpus (22)
- Comments on the continuing widespread and unnecessary use of a defective emission equation in field emission related literature
- Fractional Fowler-Nordheim Law for Field Emission from Rough Surface with Nonparabolic Energy Dispersion
- Physical electrostatics of small field emitter arrays/clusters
- Electron Emission Regimes of Planar Nano Vacuum Emitters
- Field emitter electrostatics: a review with special emphasis on modern high-precision finite-element modelling
- Nanostructures mechanically stable with desirable characteristic field enhancement factor: a response from scale invariance in electrostatics
- Modeling the Field Emission Enhancement Factor for Capped Carbon Nanotubes using the Induced Electron Density
- The consequences of dependence between the formal area efficiency and the macroscopic electric field on linearity behavior in Fowler-Nordheim plots
- Origin of the literature discrepancies in the fractional reduction of the apex-field enhancement factor considering small clusters of field emitters
- All field emission models are wrong, but are any of them useful?
- Unexpected validity of Schottky's conjecture for two-stage field emitters: a response via Schwarz-Christoffel transformation
- Restoring observed classical behavior of the carbon nanotube field emission enhancement factor from the electronic structure
- On the quantum mechanics of how an ideal carbon nanotube field emitter can exhibit a constant field enhancement factor
- Field electron emission theory (October 2016),v2
- Proposal that interpretation of field emission current-voltage characteristics should be treated as a specialized form of electrical engineering
- Field emission: applying the "magic emitter" validity test to a recent paper, and related research-literature integrity issues
- Implementation of the orthodoxy test as a validity check on experimental field emission data
- Interplay between morphological and shielding effects in field emission via Schwarz-Christoffel transformation
- Universal scaling of electrostatic effects of a curved counter-electrode on the emitter field enhancement
- Theory of field emission
- Interpreting the empirical field emission equation for large area field emitters
- Ni3Si2 Nanowires for Efficient Electron Field Emission and Limitations of the Fowler-Nordheim Model