Shortcomings of the Bond Orientational Order Parameters for the Analysis of Disordered Particulate Matter

Abstract

Local structure characterization with the bond-orientational order parameters q4, q6, ... introduced by Steinhardt et al. has become a standard tool in condensed matter physics, with applications including glass, jamming, melting or crystallization transitions and cluster formation. Here we discuss two fundamental flaws in the definition of these parameters that significantly affect their interpretation for studies of disordered systems, and offer a remedy. First, the definition of the bond-orientational order parameters considers the geometrical arrangement of a set of neighboring spheres NN(p) around a given central particle p; we show that procedure to select the spheres constituting the neighborhood NN(p) can have greater influence on both the numerical values and qualitative trend of ql than a change of the physical parameters, such as packing fraction. Second, the discrete nature of neighborhood implies that NN(p) is not a continuous function of the particle coordinates; this discontinuity, inherited by ql, leads to a lack of robustness of the ql as structure metrics. Both issues can be avoided by a morphometric approach leading to the robust Minkowski structure metrics ql'. These ql' are of a similar mathematical form as the conventional bond-orientational order parameters and are mathematically equivalent to the recently introduced Minkowski tensors [Europhys. Lett. 90, 34001 (2010); Phys. Rev. E. 85, 030301 (2012)].

References in corpus (12)

• Accurate determination of crystal structures based on averaged local bond order parameters
• Packing Hyperspheres in High-Dimensional Euclidean Spaces
• Structure of the First and Second Neighbor Shells of Water: Quantitative Relation with Translational and Orientational Order
• Structural anomalies for a three dimensional isotropic core-softened potential
• Homogeneous and heterogeneous nucleation of Lennard-Jones liquids
• The equilibrium intrinsic crystal-liquid interface of colloids
• Icosahedral packing of polymer-tethered nanospheres and stabilization of the gyroid phase
• Shear Induced Structural Ordering of a Model Metallic Glass
• Crystal nucleation and cluster-growth kinetics in a model glass under shear
• Local Anisotropy of Fluids using Minkowski Tensors
• Suppression of the rate of growth of dynamic heterogeneities and its relation to the local structure in a supercooled polydisperse liquid
• Heat Transport in a Random Packing of Hard Spheres

Cited by in corpus (73)

• Physics-inspired structural representations for molecules and materials
• 2D Melting: From Liquid-Hexatic Coexistence to Continuous Transitions
• Identification of structure in condensed matter with the topological cluster classification
• Generalized event-chain Monte Carlo: Constructing rejection-free global-balance algorithms from infinitesimal steps
• Thermodynamic phases in two-dimensional active matter
• The Mechanism of the Ultra-Fast Crystal Growth of Pure Metals from their Melts
• The structural origin of the hard-sphere glass transition in granular packing
• Shape and symmetry determine two-dimensional melting transitions of hard regular polygons
• Exploring the jamming transition over a wide range of critical densities
• Nucleation in sheared granular matter
• Non-universal Voronoi cell shapes in amorphous ellipsoid packings
• A local order metric for condensed phase environments
• A jamming plane of sphere packings
• Dimensionality reduction of local structure in glassy binary mixtures
• New Tessellation-Based Procedure to Design Perfectly Hyperuniform Disordered Dispersions for Materials Discovery
• Methodology to Construct Large Realizations of Perfectly Hyperuniform Disordered Packings
• The barrier to ice nucleation in monatomic water
• Sampling from a polytope and hard-disk Monte Carlo
• Tuning the glass-forming ability of metallic glasses through energetic frustration
• Remarkable nuances of crystallization: From ordinary crystal nucleation to rival mechanisms of crystallite coalescence
• Spherical structure factor and classification of hyperuniformity on the sphere
• Change in the Crystallization Features of Supercooled Liquid Metal with an Increase in the Supercooling Level
• The rich polymorphic behavior of Wigner bilayers
• Structure and Morphology of Crystalline Nuclei arising in a Crystallizing Liquid Metallic Film
• Asymmetric crystallization during cooling and heating in model glass-forming systems
• Characterization of Anisotropic Gaussian Random Fields by Minkowski Tensors
• Re-entrant phase separation in nematically aligning active polar particles
• A kinetic-Monte Carlo perspective on active matter
• Biased ensembles of pulsating active matter
• A Domain Specific Language for Performance Portable Molecular Dynamics Algorithms
• Local structural features elucidate crystallization of complex structures
• Excellent glass former Ni${}_{62}$Nb${}_{38}$ crystallizing under combined shear and ultra-high pressure
• Non-equilibrium molecular dynamics and continuum modelling of transient freezing of atomistic solids
• Quasi-Stable Structures in Equilibrium Dense Bismuth Melt: Experimental and First Principles Theoretical Studies
• Non-equilibrium steady states, coexistence and criticality in driven quasi-two-dimensional granular matter
• Nucleation and structural growth of cluster crystals
• Morphology of Critically-Sized Crystalline Nuclei at Shear-Induced Crystal Nucleation in Amorphous Solid
• Reliable computational prediction of supramolecular ordering of complex molecules under electrochemical conditions
• Sequence of phase transitions in a model of interacting rods
• Classification of atomic environments via the Gromov-Wasserstein distance
• Crystal phases of soft spheres systems in a slab geometry
• Graph neural network-based structural classification of glass-forming liquids and its interpretation via self-attention mechanism
• Rotation covariant local tensor valuations on convex bodies
• papaya2: 2D Irreducible Minkowski Tensor computation
• Controlling the dewetting morphologies of thin liquid films by switchable substrates
• Self-propulsion and self-navigation: Activity is a precursor to jamming
• $\mathrm{SO}(n)$ covariant local tensor valuations on polytopes
• Equilibrium structures of anisometric, quadrupolar particles confined to a monolayer
• Structural analysis of disordered dimer packings
• Structure of the simple harmonic-repulsive system in liquid and glassy states studied by the triple correlation function
• Change Point Detection of Events in Molecular Simulations using dupin
• Cuddling Ellipsoids: Densest local structures of uniaxial ellipsoids
• Morphometry on the sphere: Cartesian and irreducible Minkowski tensors explained and implemented
• Green-Kubo stress correlation function at the atomic scale and a long-range bond-orientational ordering in a model liquid
• The asymmetric Wigner bilayer
• Valuations and Boolean Models
• Structure and solidification of the (Fe0.75B0.15Si0.1)100-xTax (x=0-2) melts: experiment and machine learning
• Global order parameters for particle distributions on the sphere
• Kinetics of inherent processes counteracting crystallization in supercooled monatomic liquid
• Cavity nucleation in single-component homogeneous amorphous solids under negative pressure
• Atomistic understanding of hydrogen bubble-induced embrittlement in tungsten enabled by machine learning molecular dynamics
• Scale-Free Crystallization of two-dimensional Complex Plasmas: Domain Analysis using Minkowski Tensors
• Shape matters: Inferring the motility of confluent cells from static images
• Accurate force field of two-dimensional ferroelectrics from deep learning
• Liquid-solid transitions in the three-body hard-core model
• Ordered ground state configurations of the asymmetric Wigner bilayer system -- revisited: an unsupervised clustering algorithm analysis
• Structure-dynamics relationship in ratcheted colloids: Resonance melting, dislocations, and defect clusters
• How Real are Liquid Groundstates? Ultra-Fast Crystal Growth and the Susceptibility of Energy Minima in Liquids
• Geometric Algebra Attention Networks for Small Point Clouds
• Lattice Matching Dictates the Growth Mode and Quality of Deuterium Crystallization in Confined Spherical Shells
• Point Group Analysis in Particle Simulation Data
• Deep Learning Order Parameter for Polymer Phase Transition
• The Displacement Field Associated with the Freezing of a Melt and its Role in Determining Crystal Growth Kinetics