Is the 130 GeV Line Real? A Search for Systematics in the Fermi-LAT Data

Abstract

Our recent claims of a Galactic center feature in Fermi-LAT data at approximately 130 GeV have prompted an avalanche of papers proposing explanations ranging from dark matter annihilation to exotic pulsar winds. Because of the importance of such interpretations for physics and astrophysics, a discovery will require not only additional data, but a thorough investigation of possible LAT systematics. While we do not have access to the details of each event reconstruction, we do have information about each event from the public event lists and spacecraft parameter files. These data allow us to search for suspicious trends that could indicate a spurious signal. We consider several hypotheses that might make an instrumental artifact more apparent at the Galactic center, and find them implausible. We also search for an instrumental signature in the Earth limb photons, which provide a smooth reference spectrum for null tests. We find no significant 130 GeV feature in the Earth limb sample. However, we do find a marginally significant 130 GeV feature in Earth limb photons with a limited range of detector incidence angles. This raises concerns about the 130 GeV Galactic center feature, even though we can think of no plausible model of instrumental behavior that connects the two. A modest amount of additional limb data would tell us if the limb feature is a statistical fluke. If the limb feature persists, it would raise doubts about the Pass 7 processing of E > 100 GeV events. At present we find no instrumental systematics that could plausibly explain the excess Galactic center emission at 130 GeV.

16 pages, 22 figures

References in corpus (26)

• A Tentative Gamma-Ray Line from Dark Matter Annihilation at the Fermi Large Area Telescope
• Dark Matter and Collider Phenomenology of Universal Extra Dimensions
• Gamma Ray Signals from Dark Matter: Concepts, Status and Prospects
• Dark Matter Evidence, Particle Physics Candidates and Detection Methods
• How Dark Are Majorana WIMPs? Signals from MiDM and Rayleigh Dark Matter
• Fermi 130 GeV gamma-ray excess and dark matter annihilation in sub-haloes and in the Galactic centre
• Search for heavy bottom-like quarks in 4.9 inverse femtobarns of pp collisions at sqrt(s) = 7 TeV
• Strong Evidence for Gamma-ray Line Emission from the Inner Galaxy
• UV Completions of Magnetic Inelastic Dark Matter and RayDM for the Fermi Line(s)
• Two Lines or Not Two Lines? That is the Question of Gamma Ray Spectra
• Investigating Gamma-Ray Lines from Dark Matter with Future Observatories
• The WIMP Forest: Indirect Detection of a Chiral Square
• Three Exceptions for Thermal Dark Matter with Enhanced Annihilation to Gamma Gamma
• Search with EGRET for a Gamma Ray Line from the Galactic Center
• Searching for the continuum spectrum photons correlated to the 130 GeV gamma-ray line
• Cold ultrarelativistic pulsar winds as potential sources of galactic gamma-ray lines above 100 GeV
• Disentangling Instrumental Features of the 130 GeV Fermi Line
• The 130 GeV Fingerprint of Right-Handed Neutrino Dark Matter
• Fermi-LAT gamma-ray signal from Earth Limb, systematic detector effects and their implications for the 130 GeV gamma-ray excess
• Spectral and spatial variations of the diffuse gamma-ray background in the vicinity of the Galactic plane and possible nature of the feature at 130 GeV
• Double Gamma-ray Lines from Unassociated Fermi-LAT Sources
• Dipole-interacting Fermionic Dark Matter in positron, antiproton, and gamma-ray channels
• Brightening the (130 GeV) Gamma-Ray Line
• A Simple Recipe for the 111 and 128 GeV Lines
• Are Lines From Unassociated Gamma-Ray Sources Evidence For Dark Matter Annihilation?
• Mixed Wino-Axion Dark Matter in String/M Theory and the 130 GeV Gamma-line "Signal"

Cited by in corpus (54)

• Update on scalar singlet dark matter
• The DArk Matter Particle Explorer mission
• Double-Disk Dark Matter
• Search for Gamma-ray Spectral Lines with the Fermi Large Area Telescope and Dark Matter Implications
• The Dark Z' Portal: Direct, Indirect and Collider Searches
• Sensitivity Projections for Dark Matter Searches with the Fermi Large Area Telescope
• Loopy Constraints on Leptophilic Dark Matter and Internal Bremsstrahlung
• Dark matter vs. Pulsars: Catching the impostor
• Search for 100 MeV to 10 GeV gamma-ray lines in the Fermi-LAT data and implications for gravitino dark matter in the $\mu \nu$SSM
• Unidentified sources in the Fermi-LAT second source catalog: the case for DM subhalos
• Two Component Dark Matter : A Possible Explanation of 130 GeV γ-Ray Line from the Galactic Centre
• Resolving Small-Scale Dark Matter Structures Using Multi-Source Indirect Detection
• Search for a gamma-ray line feature from a group of nearby Galaxy clusters with Fermi LAT Pass 8 data
• Constraining dark matter annihilation with the isotropic $\gamma$-ray background: updated limits and future potential
• Gravity-mediated (or Composite) Dark Matter Confronts Astrophysical Data
• Multiple Gamma Lines from Semi-Annihilation
• Neutralino dark matter and the Fermi gamma-ray lines
• Indirect Detection of Dark Matter with gamma rays
• Galactic Center Radio Constraints on Gamma-Ray Lines from Dark Matter Annihilation
• Gamma-ray lines and One-Loop Continuum from s-channel Dark Matter Annihilations
• Dark Matter Velocity Spectroscopy
• Fermi-LAT gamma-ray signal from Earth Limb, systematic detector effects and their implications for the 130 GeV gamma-ray excess
• Looking for new charged states at the LHC: Signatures of Magnetic and Rayleigh Dark Matter
• Dark Matter and Dark Force in the Type-I Inert 2HDM with Local U(1)_H Gauge Symmetry
• The 130 GeV gamma-ray line and Sommerfeld enhancements
• Interplay between Fermi gamma-ray lines and collider searches
• Formation of Dark Matter Torii Around Supermassive Black Holes Via The Eccentric Kozai-Lidov Mechanism
• Axino dark matter with R-parity violation and 130 GeV gamma-ray line
• The 130 GeV gamma-ray line and generic dark matter model building constraints from continuum gamma rays, radio and antiproton data
• Confronting the Fermi Line with LHC data: an Effective Theory of Dark Matter Interaction with Photons
• Electroweak Baryogenesis And The Fermi Gamma-Ray Line
• Gamma Rays from Top-Mediated Dark Matter Annihilations
• Detecting interactions between dark matter and photons at high energy $e^{+}{e}^{-}$ colliders
• Re-Examining Astrophysical Constraints on the Dark Matter Model
• TASI 2014 Lectures: The Hunt for Dark Matter
• General calculation of the cross section for dark matter annihilations into two photons
• Mirage Models Confront the LHC: I. Kahler-Stabilized Heterotic String Theory
• The Dark Knight Falters
• A Clustering Analysis of the Morphology of the 130 GeV Gamma-Ray Feature
• Searching for Spurious Solar and Sky Lines in the Fermi-LAT Spectrum
• Vector Higgs-portal dark matter and Fermi-LAT gamma ray line
• Observing Higgs boson production through its decay into gamma-rays: A messenger for Dark Matter candidates
• Gamma-ray line from radiative decay of gravitino dark matter
• Search for the gamma-ray spectral lines with the DAMPE and the Fermi-LAT observations
• Diphoton resonance at e+e- and photon colliders
• Where are the Fermi Lines Coming From?
• Cosmic Rays in the Milky Way and Beyond
• Gamma Rays from Bino-like Dark Matter in the MSSM
• Dark matter from unification
• The gamma-ray spectral feature from Kaluza-Klein dark matter annihilation and its observability
• Magnetic dipole moment of neutral particles from quantum corrections at two-loop order
• Indirect searches for dark matter with the Fermi LAT instrument
• LHC constraints on dark matter with (130 GeV) gamma ray lines
• 130GeV gamma-ray line through axion conversion