The strongest gravitational lenses: II. Is the large Einstein radius of MACS J0717.5+3745 in conflict with LCDM?

Abstract

Can the standard cosmological model be questioned on the basis of a single observed extreme galaxy cluster? Usually, the word extreme refers directly to cluster mass, which is not a direct observable and thus subject to substantial uncertainty. Hence, it is desirable to extend studies of extreme clusters to direct observables, such as the Einstein radius (ER). We aim to evaluate the occurrence probability of the large observed ER of MACS J0717.5 within the standard LCDM cosmology. In particular, we want to model the distribution function of the single largest ER in a given cosmological volume and to study which underlying assumptions and effects have the strongest impact on the results. We obtain this distribution by a Monte Carlo approach, based on the semi-analytic modelling of the halo population on the past lightcone. After sampling the distribution, we fit the results with the general extreme value (GEV) distribution which we use for the subsequent analysis. We find that the distribution of the maximum ER is particularly sensitive to the precise choice of the halo mass function, lens triaxiality, the inner slope of the halo density profile and the mass-concentration relation. Using the distributions so obtained,we study the occurrence probability of the large ER of MACS J0717.5, finding that this system is not in tension with LCDM. We also find that the GEV distribution can be used to fit very accurately the sampled distributions and that all of them can be described by a Frechet distribution. With a multitude of effects that strongly influence the distribution of the single largest ER, it is more than doubtful that the standard LCDM cosmology can be ruled out on the basis of a single observation. If, despite the large uncertainties in the underlying assumptions, one wanted to do so, a much larger ER (> 100 arcsec) than that of MACS J0717.5 would have to be observed.

arXiv comment15 pages, 11 figures, accepted for publication in Astronomy and Astrophysics, minor corrections to match the accepted version, added discussion of the distribution of the largest Einstein radii for the MACS survey area, extended Fig. 9

References in corpus (47)

• Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
• The Structure of Cold Dark Matter Halos
• Large scale bias and the peak background split
• Toward a halo mass function for precision cosmology: the limits of universality
• Cluster Lensing And Supernova survey with Hubble (CLASH): An Overview
• Triaxial Modeling of Halo Density Profiles with High-resolution N-body Simulations
• The 10 Meter South Pole Telescope
• MACS: A quest for the most massive galaxy clusters in the universe
• Gravitational Lensing
• The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: Sunyaev Zel'dovich Selected Galaxy Clusters at 148 GHz in the 2008 Survey
• A complete sample of twelve very X-ray luminous galaxy clusters at z>0.5
• Cluster Lenses
• An SZ-selected sample of the most massive galaxy clusters in the 2500-square-degree South Pole Telescope survey
• Discovery of an X-ray-Luminous Galaxy Cluster at z=1.4
• Simulating the Universe with MICE: The abundance of massive clusters
• Mass Function Predictions Beyond LCDM
• The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: ACT-CL J0102-4915 "El Gordo," a Massive Merging Cluster at Redshift 0.87
• Analytic models of plausible gravitational lens potentials
• Multi-wavelength study of XMMU J2235.3-2557: the most massive galaxy cluster at z > 1
• Simultaneous Falsification of LCDM and Quintessence with Massive, Distant Clusters
• What is the largest Einstein radius in the universe?
• Strong Gravitational Lensing and Velocity Function as Tools to Probe Cosmological Parameters: Current Constraints and Future Predictions
• Arc Statistics in Triaxial Dark Matter Halos: Testing the Collisionless Cold Dark Matter Paradigm
• Hubble Space Telescope Weak-lensing Study of the Galaxy Cluster XMMU J2235.3-2557 at z=1.4: A Surprisingly Massive Galaxy Cluster when the Universe is One-third of its Current Age
• Newtonian and Relativistic Cosmologies
• Revealing the magnetic field in a distant galaxy cluster: discovery of the complex radio emission from MACS J0717.5 +3745
• Statistics of Giant Arcs in Galaxy Clusters
• Discovery of a large-scale filament connected to the massive galaxy cluster MACSJ0717.5+3745 at z=0.55
• Strong lensing in the MareNostrum Universe: biases in the cluster lens population
• Lensing Constraints on the Cores of Massive Dark Matter Halos
• The Largest Gravitational Lens: MACS J0717.5+3745 (z=0.546)
• Effects of Triaxiality on the Statistics of Large-Separation Gravitational Lenses
• The impact of gas physics on strong cluster lensing
• Arc sensitivity to cluster ellipticity, asymmetries and substructures
• Strong Lensing by a Node of the Cosmic Web. The Core of MACS J0717.5+3745 at z=0.55
• Comparison of an X-ray selected sample of massive lensing clusters with the MareNostrum Universe LCDM simulation
• The spatial distribution of galaxies of different spectral types in the massive intermediate-redshift cluster MACSJ0717.5+3745
• The strongest gravitational lenses: I. The statistical impact of cluster mergers
• Testing Cosmology with Extreme Galaxy Clusters
• Most massive halos with Gumbel Statistics
• Probability of the most massive cluster under non-Gaussian initial conditions
• The most massive objects in the Universe
• Primordial Non-Gaussianity and Extreme-Value Statistics of Galaxy Clusters
• Quantifying the rareness of extreme galaxy clusters
• Exact Extreme Value Statistics and the Halo Mass Function
• An application of extreme value statistics to the most massive galaxy clusters at low and high redshifts
• On a novel approach using massive clusters at high redshifts as cosmological probe

Cited by in corpus (19)

• Weak lensing analysis of SZ-selected clusters of galaxies from the SPT and Planck surveys
• The Three-Dimensional Shapes of Galaxy Clusters
• A Measurement of the Kinetic Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Signal Toward MACS J0717.5+3745
• Weighing "El Gordo" with a Precision Scale: Hubble Space Telescope Weak-lensing Analysis of the Merging Galaxy Cluster ACT-CL J0102-4915 at z=0.87
• CLASH: Complete Lensing Analysis of the Largest Cosmic Lens MACS J0717.5+3745 and Surrounding Structures
• Arc Statistics
• Statistics of extreme objects in the Juropa Hubble Volume simulation
• On the shape of dark matter halos from MultiDark Planck simulations
• A highly elongated prominent lens at z=0.87: first strong lensing analysis of El Gordo
• The strongest gravitational lenses: I. The statistical impact of cluster mergers
• SARCS strong-lensing galaxy groups: II - mass-concentration relation and strong-lensing bias
• A Very Large (${\theta }_E\gtrsim 40$") Strong Gravitational Lens Selected with the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect: PLCK G287.0+32.9 ($z$ = 0.38)
• Optical & Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Observations of a New Sample of Distant Rich Galaxy Clusters in the ROSAT All Sky Survey
• Characterising Strong Lensing Galaxy Clusters using the Millennium-XXL and MOKA simulations
• Strong Lensing Analysis of the Powerful Lensing Cluster MACS J2135.2-0102 ($z$=0.33)
• The strongest gravitational lenses: III. The order statistics of the largest Einstein radii
• The powerful lens galaxy cluster PLCK G287.0+32.9 (${\theta }_E\sim 43^{\prime \prime }$)
• The strongest gravitational lenses: IV. The order statistics of the largest Einstein radii with cluster mergers
• Extreme value statistics of CMB lensing deflection angles