Multilevel Bayesian framework for modeling the production, propagation and detection of ultra-high energy cosmic rays
arXiv:1206.4569 · doi:10.1214/13-AOAS654
Abstract
Ultra-high energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) are atomic nuclei with energies over ten million times energies accessible to human-made particle accelerators. Evidence suggests that they originate from relatively nearby extragalactic sources, but the nature of the sources is unknown. We develop a multilevel Bayesian framework for assessing association of UHECRs and candidate source populations, and Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithms for estimating model parameters and comparing models by computing, via Chib's method, marginal likelihoods and Bayes factors. We demonstrate the framework by analyzing measurements of 69 UHECRs observed by the Pierre Auger Observatory (PAO) from 2004-2009, using a volume-complete catalog of 17 local active galactic nuclei (AGN) out to 15 megaparsecs as candidate sources. An early portion of the data ("period 1," with 14 events) was used by PAO to set an energy cut maximizing the anisotropy in period 1; the 69 measurements include this "tuned" subset, and subsequent "untuned" events with energies above the same cutoff. Also, measurement errors are approximately summarized. These factors are problematic for independent analyses of PAO data. Within the context of "standard candle" source models (i.e., with a common isotropic emission rate), and considering only the 55 untuned events, there is no significant evidence favoring association of UHECRs with local AGN vs. an isotropic background. The highest-probability associations are with the two nearest, adjacent AGN, Centaurus A and NGC 4945. If the association model is adopted, the fraction of UHECRs that may be associated is likely nonzero but is well below 50%. Our framework enables estimation of the angular scale for deflection of cosmic rays by cosmic magnetic fields; relatively modest scales of to are favored. Models that assign a large fraction of UHECRs to a single nearby source (e.g., Centaurus A) are ruled out unless very large deflection scales are specified a priori, and even then they are disfavored. However, including the period 1 data alters the conclusions significantly, and a simulation study supports the idea that the period 1 data are anomalous, presumably due to the tuning. Accurate and optimal analysis of future data will likely require more complete disclosure of the data.
arXiv commentPublished in at http://dx.doi.org/10.1214/13-AOAS654 the Annals of Applied Statistics (http://www.imstat.org/aoas/) by the Institute of Mathematical Statistics (http://www.imstat.org)
References in corpus (24)
- Correlation of the highest energy cosmic rays with nearby extragalactic objects
- Measurement of the Depth of Maximum of Extensive Air Showers above 10^18 eV
- The Astrophysics of Ultrahigh Energy Cosmic Rays
- Measurements of the Cosmic Ray Composition with Air Shower Experiments
- Update on the correlation of the highest energy cosmic rays with nearby extragalactic matter
- Constrained Simulations of the Magnetic Field in the Local Universe and the Propagation of UHECRs
- Ultrahigh Energy Cosmic Rays
- Angular, spectral, and time distributions of highest energy protons and associated secondary gamma-rays and neutrinos propagating through extragalactic magnetic and radiation fields
- Implications of the cosmic ray spectrum for the mass composition at the highest energies
- Extensive Air Showers and Ultra High-Energy Cosmic Rays: A Historical Review
- Towards a Complete Census of AGNs in Nearby Galaxies: The Incidence of Growing Black Holes
- Cosmic Rays: Recent Progress and some Current Questions
- The angular resolution of the Pierre Auger Observatory
- Centaurus A: the one extragalactic source of cosmic rays with energies above the knee
- Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays from Centaurus A: Jet Interaction with Gaseous Shells
- Do Ultrahigh Energy Cosmic Rays Come from Active Galactic Nuclei and Fermi -ray Sources?
- Statistical Analysis of the Correlation between Active Galactic Nuclei and Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays
- A Bayesian analysis of the 27 highest energy cosmic rays detected by the Pierre Auger Observatory
- Disappointing model for ultrahigh-energy cosmic rays
- Studying the nuclear mass composition of Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays with the Pierre Auger Observatory
- Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays Detected by Auger and AGASA:Corrections for Galactic Magnetic Field Deflections, Source Populations, and Arguments for Multiple-Components
- Multilevel Bayesian framework for modeling the production, propagation and detection of ultra-high energy cosmic rays
- Magnetic lensing of ultra high energy cosmic rays
- Active Galactic Nuclei with Starbursts: Sources for Ultra High Energy Cosmic Rays
Cited by in corpus (6)
- Constraining models for the origin of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays with a novel combined analysis of arrival directions, spectrum, and composition data measured at the Pierre Auger Observatory
- Probabilistic record linkage in astronomy: Directional cross-identification and beyond
- Impact of using the ultra-high-energy cosmic ray arrival energies to constrain source associations
- Multilevel Bayesian framework for modeling the production, propagation and detection of ultra-high energy cosmic rays
- A Bayesian analysis of the 69 highest energy cosmic rays detected by the Pierre Auger Observatory
- A Bayesian self-clustering analysis of the highest energy cosmic rays detected by the Pierre Auger Observatory