Collisional Penrose process near the horizon of extreme Kerr black holes
arXiv:1205.4350 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.109.121101
Abstract
Collisions of particles in black holes' ergospheres may result in an arbitrarily large center of mass energy. This led recently to the suggestion (Banados et al., 2009) that black holes can act as ultimate particle accelerators. If the energy of an outgoing particle is larger than the total energy of the infalling particles the energy excess must come from the rotational energy of the black hole and hence this must involve a Penrose process. However, while the center of mass energy diverges the position of the collision makes it impossible for energetic particles to escape to infinity. Following an earlier work on collisional Penrose processes (Piran & Shaham 1977) we show that even under the most favorable idealized conditions the maximal energy of an escaping particle is only a modest factor above the total initial energy of the colliding particles. This implies that one shouldn't expect collisions around a black hole to act as spectacular cosmic accelerators.
arXiv comment4 pages, 5 figures (minor corrections, matches PRL accepted version)
References in corpus (7)
- Efficient Generation of Jets from Magnetically Arrested Accretion on a Rapidly Spinning Black Hole
- Kerr Black Holes as Particle Accelerators to Arbitrarily High Energy
- Observational Evidence for a Correlation Between Jet Power and Black Hole Spin
- Spinning Black Holes as Particle Accelerators
- Comment on "Kerr Black Holes as Particle Accelerators to Arbitrarily High Energy"
- Emergent Flux from Particle Collisions Near a Kerr Black Hole
- Numerical estimation of the escaping flux of massless particles created in collisions around a Kerr black hole
Cited by in corpus (82)
- Foundations of Black Hole Accretion Disk Theory
- Extracting black-hole rotational energy: The generalized Penrose process
- Revised upper limit to energy extraction from a Kerr black hole
- Black holes as particle accelerators: a brief review
- Ultra-high-energy debris from the collisional Penrose process
- Optical effects related to Keplerian discs orbiting Kehagias-Sfetsos naked singularities
- Can Schwarzschild Black Holes Be Accelerators of Spinning Massive Particles?
- Particle motion and collisions around rotating regular black hole
- On the maximal efficiency of the collisional Penrose process
- Energy extraction from extremal charged black holes due to the BSW effect
- Kerr black holes as accelerators of spinning test particles
- The Collisional Penrose Process
- Energetics of particle collisions near dirty rotating extremal black holes: Banados-Silk-West effect versus Penrose process
- High energy collision of two particles in wormhole spacetimes
- Electromotive Force in the Blandford-Znajek Process
- Near horizon geometry of extremal black holes and Banados-Silk-West effect
- Black Holes are neither Particle Accelerators nor Dark Matter Probes
- On some novel features of the Kerr-Newman-NUT Spacetime
- Is the super-Penrose process possible near black holes?
- Infinite efficiency of collisional Penrose process: Can over-spinning Kerr geometry be the source of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays and neutrinos ?
- Rotating 4D Gauss-Bonnet black hole as particle accelerator
- Escape of superheavy and highly energetic particles produced by particle collisions near maximally charged black holes
- Observers in Kerr spacetimes: the ergoregion on the equatorial plane
- Center of mass energy of colliding electrically neutral particles and super-Penrose process
- Collisional super-Penrose process and Wald inequalities
- Collisional Penrose Process in Rotating Wormhole Spacetime
- Maximal Efficiency of Collisional Penrose Process with Spinning Particles
- Study of Center of Mass Energy by Particles Collision in Some Black Holes
- Unbound geodesics from the ergosphere and potential observability of debris from ultrahigh energy particle collisions
- Maximal Efficiency of Collisional Penrose Process with Spinning Particle II
- Proto-jets configurations in RADs orbiting a Kerr SMBH: symmetries and limiting surfaces
- High efficiency of collisional Penrose process requires heavy particle production
- Disclosing connections between black holes and naked singularities: Horizon remnants, Killing throats and bottlenecks
- Maximum efficiency of the collisional Penrose process
- Maximal efficiency of the collisional Penrose process with spinning particles in Kerr-Sen black hole
- Enhanced Line Signals from Annihilating Kaluza-Klein Dark Matter
- Bañados-Silk-West effect with nongeodesic particles: extremal horizons
- Escape probability of the super-Penrose process
- Charged Dilation Black Holes as Particle Accelerators
- Super-Penrose process and rotating wormholes
- Particle Acceleration by Static Black Holes in a Model of Gravity
- General limitations on trajectories suitable for super-Penrose process
- Particle collision with an arbitrarily high center-of-mass energy near a Bañados-Teitelboim-Zanelli black hole
- Extraction of energy from an extremal rotating electrovacuum black hole: Particle collisions along the axis of symmetry
- Extraction of energy from an extremal rotating electrovacuum black hole: Particle collisions in the equatorial plane
- Ultra-high-energy head-on collisions without horizons or naked singulrities: general approach
- Banados-Silk-West effect with nongeodesic particles: Nonextremal horizons
- Comment on "Black Holes are Neither Particle Accelerators Nor Dark Matter Probes"
- Kinematic restrictions on particle collisions near extremal black holes: A unified picture
- Unbounded energies of debris from head-on particle collisions near black holes
- Consistent analytic approach to the efficiency of collisional Penrose process
- Self-consistent multidimensional Penrose process driven by magnetic reconnection
- Particle acceleration by Majumdar-Papapetrou di-hole
- Exploring black holes as particle accelerators: hoop-radius, target particles and escaping conditions
- Ultra-high energy collisions of nonequatorial geodesic particles near dirty black holes
- Effect of the self-gravity of shells on a high energy collision in a rotating Bañados-Teitelboim-Zanelli spacetime
- Amplification of gravitational wave by a Kerr black hole
- Upper bound on the center-of-mass energy of the collisional Penrose process
- Collisional Penrose process with spinning particles in braneworld black hole
- Rotating Black Hole with an Anisotropic Matter Field as a Particle Accelerator
- Pure electric Penrose and super-Penrose processes in the flat space-time
- Spacetime noncommutative effect on black hole as particle accelerators
- Collision of spinning particles near BTZ black holes
- Penrose and super-Penrose energy extraction from a Reissner-Nordström black hole spacetime with a cosmological constant through the BSW mechanism: Full story
- Extremal Kerr white holes as a source of ultra high energy particles
- Collisional Penrose process of BTZ black holes
- Super-Penrose process for nonextremal black holes
- Notes on extraction of energy from an extremal Kerr-Newman black hole via charged particle collisions
- Implementing black hole as efficient power plant
- Signatures of particle collisions near extreme black holes
- Collisions near Kerr black holes: lower limit of energy between orbiting and incoming particles
- Is there a trade-off relation between efficiency and power in a collisional Penrose process in an extreme Reissner-Nordström spacetime?
- Neutral particle collisions near Gibbons-Maeda-Garfinkle-Horowitz-Strominger black holes after shadow observations
- Naked singularity explosion in higher-dimensional dust collapse
- Decay of charged particles near naked singularities and super-Penrose process without fine-tuning
- Rapidly rotating spacetimes and collisional super-Penrose process
- Magnetic Penrose Process and Blanford-Zanejk mechanism: A clarification
- Collisional Penrose process of extended test particles near an extremal Kerr black hole
- Near-Horizon Collisions around Near-Extremal Black Holes
- Energy extraction from electrovacuum black holes via production of pairs of oppositely charged particles
- Efficiency of Higher Dimensional Black Holes as Particle Accelerators
- A New Approach for Testing Einstein's Theory of Gravity Close to Rapidly Spinning Black Holes