Comparison Between Turbulent Helical Dynamo Simulations and a Nonlinear Three-Scale Theory

Abstract

Progress toward understanding principles of nonlinear growth and saturation of large scale magnetic fields has emerged from comparison of theoretical models that incorporate the evolution of magnetic helicity with numerical simulations for problems that are more idealized than expected in astrophysical circumstances, but still fully non-linear. We carry out a new comparison of this sort for the magnetic field growth from forced isotropic helical turbulence in a periodic box. Previous comparisons be- tween analytic theory and simulations of this problem have shown that a two-scale model compares well with the simulations in agreeing that the driver of large scale field growth is the difference between kinetic and current helicities associated with the small scale field, and that the backreaction that slows the growth of the large scale field as the small scale current helicity grows. However, the two-scale model artificially re- stricts the small scale current helicity to reside at the same scale as the driving kinetic helicity. In addition, previous comparisons have focused on the late time saturation regime, and less on the early-time growth regime. Here we address these issues by comparing a three scale model to new simulations for both early and late time growth regimes. We find that the minimalist extension to three scales provides a better model for the field evolution than the two-scale model because the simulations show that the small scale current helicity does not reside at the same scale as that of the driving kinetic helicity. The simulations also show that the peak of the small scale current helicity migrates toward lower wave numbers as the growth evolves from the fast to saturated growth regimes.

This paper has been withdrawn by the author due to some typos

References in corpus (4)

• Galactic dynamos supported by magnetic helicity fluxes
• Kinetic and magnetic alpha effects in nonlinear dynamo theory
• Magnetic helicity transport in the advective gauge family
• The critical role of magnetic helicity in astrophysical large-scale dynamos

Cited by in corpus (10)

• Advances in mean-field dynamo theory and applications to astrophysical turbulence
• Accretion Disks and Dynamos: Toward a Unified Mean Field Theory
• Simulations of a Magnetic Fluctuation Driven Large Scale Dynamo and Comparison with a Two-scale Model
• On the Inverse Transfer of (Non-)Helical Magnetic Energy in a Decaying Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence
• Negative Magnetic Diffusivity beta replacing alpha effect in Helical Dynamo
• Influence of small scale $E_M$ and $H_M$ on the growth of large scale magnetic field
• Magnetic Effect on Potential Barrier for Nucleosynthesis II
• Influence of initial conditions on the large-scale dynamo growth rate
• Principle of Helical \& Nonhelical Dynamo and $\alpha$ effect in Field Structure model
• $\alpha$ Effect and Magnetic Diffusivity $\beta$ in Helical Plasma under Turbulence Growth