What do gas-rich galaxies actually tell us about modified Newtonian dynamics?
arXiv:1108.5734 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.108.141302
Abstract
It has recently been claimed that measurements of the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation (BTFR), a power-law relationship between the observed baryonic masses and outer rotation velocities of galaxies, support the predictions of modified Newtonian dynamics for the slope and scatter in the relation, while challenging the cold dark matter (CDM) paradigm. We investigate these claims, and find that: 1) the scatter in the data used to determine the BTFR is in conflict with observational uncertainties on the data; 2) these data do not make strong distinctions regarding the best-fit BTFR parameters; 3) the literature contains a wide variety of measurements of the BTFR, many of which are discrepant with the recent results; and 4) the claimed CDM "prediction" for the BTFR is a gross oversimplification of the complex galaxy-scale physics involved. We conclude that the BTFR is currently untrustworthy as a test of CDM.
arXiv comment5 pages, 2 figures; minor revisions to match published version
References in corpus (37)
- Particle Dark Matter: Evidence, Candidates and Constraints
- Modified Gravity and Cosmology
- Profiles of dark haloes: evolution, scatter, and environment
- Stellar mass-to-light ratios and the Tully-Fisher relation
- Relativistic gravitation theory for the MOND paradigm
- The Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation
- The Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation of Galaxies with Extended Rotation Curves and the Stellar Mass of Rotating Galaxies
- The Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation of Gas Rich Galaxies as a Test of LCDM and MOND
- The Ursa Major Cluster of Galaxies. V ; HI Rotation Curve Shapes and the Tully-Fisher Relations
- The Universal Rotation Curve of Spiral Galaxies. II The Dark Matter Distribution out to the Virial Radius
- Galaxies in LCDM with Halo Abundance Matching: luminosity-velocity relation, baryonic mass-velocity relation, velocity function and clustering
- The Baryon Content of Extremely Low Mass Dwarf Galaxies
- Bimetric MOND gravity
- The Stellar Mass Tully-Fisher Relation to z=1.2 from AEGIS
- A Novel Test of the Modified Newtonian Dynamics with Gas Rich Galaxies
- Field-theoretical formulations of MOND-like gravity
- The Tensor-Vector-Scalar theory and its cosmology
- Rotation curves of UMa galaxies in the context of modified Newtonian dynamics
- A First Attempt to Calibrate the Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation with Gas Dominated Galaxies
- The baryonic Tully-Fisher relation and its implication for dark matter halos
- The globular cluster NGC 2419: a crucible for theories of gravity
- The Angular Momentum Problem in Cosmological Simulations of Disk Galaxy Formation
- Structure and kinematics of edge-on galaxy discs -- V. The dynamics of the stellar discs
- Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation for Extremely Low Mass Galaxies
- On the baryonic, stellar, and luminous scaling relations of disk galaxies
- The high mass end of the Tully-Fisher relation
- Testing Modified Newtonian Dynamics with Rotation Curves of Dwarf and Low Surface Brightness Galaxies
- GHASP: an Hα kinematic survey of spiral and irregular galaxies -- IX. The NIR, stellar and baryonic Tully-Fisher relations
- The slope of the Baryonic Tully-Fisher relation
- The Radial Tully-Fisher relation for spiral galaxies I
- TeVeS gets caught on caustics
- Generalisations of the Tully-Fisher relation for early and late-type galaxies
- The Baryonic Tully-Fisher relation revisited
- Polytropic model fits to the globular cluster NGC 2419 in Modified Newtonian Dynamics
- Impact of Supernova feedback on the Tully-Fisher relation
- Incompatibility of Rotation Curves with Gravitational Lensing for TeVeS
- Dwarf Galaxies, MOND, and Relativistic Gravitation
Cited by in corpus (8)
- Testing General Relativity in Cosmology
- Phantom of RAMSES (POR): A new Milgromian dynamics N-body code
- The baryonic Tully-Fisher relation and galactic outflows
- An accurate measurement of the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation with heavily gas-dominated ALFALFA galaxies
- Unraveling the interplay between SIDM and baryons in MW halos: defining where baryons dictate heat transfer
- The Tully-Fisher relations for Hickson Compact Group galaxies
- Reconciliation of MOND and Dark Matter theory
- Tully-Fisher Relation of Late-type Galaxies at